432 U.S. 1 (1977)
New York provides three primary forms of financial assistance for higher education.1 Regents college scholarships are awarded to high school graduates based on performance in a competitive examination. In the usual case, a recipient receives $250 annually for four years.2 Tuition assistance awards are noncompetitive. They are available to graduate and undergraduate students enrolled in approved programs who demonstrate the ability to complete the courses. The amount depends on tuition and income.3 Student loans are guaranteed by the State. Qualifying borrowers receive favorable interest rates and an interest-free grace period.4
Section 661(3) of the New York Education Law restricts eligibility. An applicant must be a United States citizen, have applied for citizenship, submit a statement affirming intent to apply for citizenship as soon as qualified and apply when eligible, or be a paroled refugee under federal authority.5 Jean-Marie Mauclet is a French citizen. He has lived in New York since April 1969 and has been a permanent resident of the United States since November 1969. He is married to a United States citizen and has a United States citizen child.6 Mauclet applied for a tuition assistance award to support his graduate studies at the State University of New York at Buffalo. His application was not processed because he refused to apply for United States citizenship to retain his French citizenship.7
Alan Rabinovitch is a Canadian citizen.8 He was admitted to the United States as a permanent resident alien in 1964 at the age of nine.9 He has lived in New York with his parents and sister since then.10 He graduated from the New York public school system in 1973.11 Rabinovitch qualified for a Regents college scholarship based on his performance on competitive examinations.12 The offer was withdrawn because he intended to retain his Canadian citizenship.13 He attended Brooklyn College without state financial aid.14
Mauclet brought suit in the United States District Court for the Western District of New York. Rabinovitch brought suit in the Eastern District. Each alleged that the citizenship bar in § 661(3) was unconstitutional. The cases were consolidated before a three-judge district court.15 After cross-motions for summary judgment, the district court ruled in the plaintiffs' favor and enjoined enforcement of the statute.16 The state officials responsible for administering the educational assistance programs appealed. The Supreme Court noted probable jurisdiction.17
Whether New York Education Law § 661(3) violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment?18
Classifications by a State based on alienage are inherently suspect and subject to close judicial scrutiny. The governmental interest claimed to justify the discrimination must be carefully examined to determine whether it is legitimate and substantial. Inquiry must be made whether the means adopted to achieve the goal are necessary and precisely drawn.19
Yes. The statute creates a classification based on alienage.20 It bars resident aliens such as Mauclet and Rabinovitch from educational assistance unless they apply for citizenship or declare an intent to do so. Only aliens are harmed by the restriction. Strict scrutiny therefore applies even though the bar is not absolute because the classification is directed at aliens.21 The state's asserted interests in encouraging naturalization and limiting aid to those who will become voters are not legitimate and substantial under the required examination because control over naturalization belongs exclusively to the federal government.22
Resident aliens pay taxes and contribute to the community in the same manner as citizens.23
New York Education Law § 661(3) violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.24
Related opinions on this issue
Chief Justice Burger dissented on the ground that prior alienage cases involved denial of the ability to earn a livelihood or welfare benefits essential to sustain life.25 Here the State is merely providing economic incentives for higher education to those it considers most likely to provide a long-range return to the community.26 He concluded that the Constitution allows States broad latitude to reserve limited scholarship funds for citizens and aliens willing to declare intent to become citizens.
Higher education is not a fundamental personal interest. The line drawn supplies a rational means to further legitimate state objectives without preventing aliens from obtaining an education on equal terms.27
Joined by Chief Justice Burger, Justice Stewart
Justice Powell dissented on the ground that the line New York drew is not between aliens and citizens but between aliens who prefer to retain foreign citizenship and all others.28 The classification therefore lacks the traditional indicia of suspectness.29 Prior cases do not justify strict scrutiny.30
He further concluded that the line is rational because States have a substantial interest in encouraging allegiance to the United States. New York may legitimately reserve scholarship assistance to citizens and resident aliens who declare their intention to become citizens.31
Justice Rehnquist dissented on the ground that the reason for according alienage classifications strict scrutiny is that aliens are a discrete and insular minority identified by a status over which they are powerless.32 Under this statute a resident alien has at all times the power to remove himself from the disfavored class by declaring intent to become a citizen.33 He concluded that because the classification avoids the underlying reason for strict scrutiny, rational-basis review applies.
The scheme is rational as a permissible legislative judgment in distributing limited funds to those more likely to contribute to the State's future well-being.34