717 F.2d 413 (7th Cir. 1983)
General Motors hired Baystone Construction, Inc. to build an addition to a Chevrolet plant in Muncie, Indiana.1 Baystone subcontracted with Morin Building Products Company to supply and erect the aluminum walls for the addition.2 The contract required the exterior siding to be aluminum type 3003, not less than 18 B & S gauge, with a mill finish and stucco embossed surface texture to match the finish and texture of existing metal siding.3
The contract also stated that all work would be done subject to the final approval of the Architect or General Motors' authorized agent.4 His decision on matters relating to artistic effect would be final if within the terms of the contract documents.5 Disputes as to the quality or fitness of materials or workmanship would be decided strictly by the Owner.6 The decision would be based on the requirement that all work and materials be first class in every respect, without regard to what is usual or customary.
Morin installed the walls, but General Motors' representative rejected the siding because it did not appear to have a uniform finish when viewed in bright sunlight from an acute angle.7 Baystone removed the siding and hired another subcontractor to replace it, after which General Motors approved the replacement.8
Baystone refused to pay Morin the $23,000 balance of the contract price, leading Morin to sue Baystone in federal district court under diversity jurisdiction.9 Morin prevailed at trial after the jury received an instruction that the satisfaction clause must be judged by objective criteria.10
On appeal to the Seventh Circuit, the sole issue was the correctness of that jury instruction, with evidence presented that the lack of uniformity was a trivial or inevitable defect given the definition of mill finish sheet as having a nonuniform finish which may vary from sheet to sheet.11
Whether the district court's jury instruction that the contract's satisfaction clause must be determined by objective criteria was correct?12
In contracts where one party's performance must satisfy the other, if it is practicable to determine whether a reasonable person in the position of the obligor would be satisfied, an interpretation is preferred under which the condition occurs if such a reasonable person would be satisfied.13 The reasonable person standard governs contracts involving commercial quality, operative fitness, or mechanical utility that knowledgeable persons can judge objectively, while the good faith standard applies when the contract involves personal aesthetics or fancy.14
Yes. The contract required Morin to supply and erect aluminum walls for a factory addition whose purpose was strictly utilitarian.15 The specified mill finish aluminum is defined in the trade as having a nonuniform finish that may vary from sheet to sheet.16 General Motors rejected the siding solely because it lacked uniform appearance when viewed in bright sunlight from an acute angle, yet evidence showed this defect was trivial or inevitable given the material chosen.17 Because the performance concerned commercial quality and mechanical utility susceptible of objective evaluation rather than personal aesthetics, the objective reasonable person standard properly governed the satisfaction clause.18
The contract language referencing artistic effect and owner approval appears in standard form provisions not tailored to aesthetic goals.19 The building was a Chevrolet plant addition, not a structure where beauty was a primary objective.20 Specifying unpainted mill finish further confirms that uniformity of appearance was secondary to function and cost. Therefore the district court correctly instructed the jury to apply objective criteria when deciding whether General Motors should have been satisfied.21
The jury instruction was correct and the judgment for Morin must be affirmed.22