273 Md. 538, 332 A.2d 11 (1975)
On June 8, 1969, seventeen-year-old Nancy Moran visited the home of Mr. and Mrs. Louis P. Grigsby in Hillcrest Heights, Maryland, where she joined friends including fifteen-year-old Randy Williams, who was residing with the Grigsbys.1 The group gathered in the basement, which served partly as a family clubroom and partly as a laundry room.2 After listening to music on a warm summer evening with temperatures around 72 to 73 degrees Fahrenheit, most friends left, leaving only Nancy and Randy in the basement.3
The two girls focused on a lit Christmas-tree-shaped candle on a shelf behind the couch.4 They discussed whether the candle was scented and agreed it was not.5 Randy then grabbed a drip bottle of Faberge's Tigress cologne, which Mrs. Grigsby had placed in the basement for use as a laundry deodorant, and poured its contents onto the lower portion of the candle below the flame.6 A burst of fire immediately sprang out, burning Nancy's neck and breasts as she stood nearby.7
The Tigress cologne consisted of 82.06 percent alcohol, 5.1 percent perfume and oils, and 12.84 percent water by volume, with a flash point of 73 degrees Fahrenheit.8 No warning regarding flammability appeared on the drip bottle container.9 Faberge officials, including Vice President and Chief Perfumer Carl Mann and aerosol chemist Stephen Shernov, were aware of the product's hazardous flammable quality and that it might be dangerous when placed near flame.10
Nancy Moran, through her father Elbert M. Moran, sued Faberge, Inc., Randy Williams, and Louis P. Grigsby in the Circuit Court for Prince George's County.11 The jury found Faberge negligent and awarded Nancy $27,000 and her father $2,701.34 in damages, while exonerating Williams and Grigsby and finding Nancy not contributorily negligent.12 The trial court granted Faberge's motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict.13 The Court of Special Appeals affirmed that judgment, and the Court of Appeals of Maryland granted certiorari.14
Whether the evidence presented at trial was sufficient to support a jury finding that Faberge negligently failed to warn of the flammability of its Tigress cologne?15
A manufacturer has a duty to warn of latent dangers in its product if it knows or should know that the product has an inherent hidden danger.16 That danger could be a substantial factor in causing injury when the product is used in an environment where it can reasonably be expected to be brought near elements like flame that can ignite it. The foreseeability test focuses on whether the harm fell within a general field of danger which should have been anticipated, not the exact manner of the accident.17
Yes. The Tigress cologne had a flash point of 73 degrees Fahrenheit and was known by Faberge officials Carl Mann and Stephen Shernov to be flammable and potentially dangerous near flame. The cologne was placed in the Grigsby home basement for use as a laundry deodorant, an environment where candles and flames are normally present.18 The jury could reasonably conclude that bringing the cologne near a flame was within the general field of danger, even though the specific act of pouring it on a candle to scent it was unusual.19
This supports a finding that Faberge was negligent in failing to provide a flammability warning on the drip bottle.20
The evidence was sufficient to support the jury's finding of negligence, and the judgment notwithstanding the verdict should be reversed.21
Related opinions on this issue
Justice O'Donnell dissented.22 He argued that the specific use of pouring the cologne on a lit candle to scent it was not reasonably foreseeable by the manufacturer.23 The cologne is intended as a skin freshener with a 27-year accident-free history.24
The majority's application of foreseeability improperly extends liability to unforeseeable misuses without evidence that the manufacturer should have anticipated such a use.25 He would affirm the judgment n.o.v. because reasonable minds would not differ that Faberge could not have foreseen this particular misuse.26