504 U.S. 374 (1992)
In 1978 Congress enacted the Airline Deregulation Act, which added 49 U.S.C. App. § 1305(a)(1) prohibiting states from enforcing any law relating to rates, routes, or services of air carriers while retaining the prior saving clause and the federal authority to address deceptive practices.1
In 1987 the National Association of Attorneys General adopted detailed Air Travel Industry Enforcement Guidelines that set standards for the content and format of airline fare advertisements, including requirements for disclosure of restrictions, fare availability, inclusion of surcharges, and use of terms such as sale or discount.2
In February 1988 the attorneys general of seven states, including Texas, sent a memorandum to major airlines stating that failure to disclose all surcharges violated § 2.5 of the guidelines and their respective state deceptive advertising laws, described the memorandum as an advisory notice before enforcement actions, and expressed hope that litigation would be unnecessary.3 Several months later the Texas Attorney General's office sent formal notices of intent to sue to several airlines.4
Trans World Airlines, Inc. and other carriers responded by filing suit in the Western District of Texas seeking declaratory and injunctive relief on the ground that state regulation of fare advertisements is preempted by § 1305(a)(1).5 The district court entered a preliminary injunction barring Texas from enforcing the guidelines in conjunction with its consumer protection laws and later extended the injunction to thirty-three additional states.6
After the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit affirmed the preliminary injunction, the district court issued a permanent injunction prohibiting the states from taking any enforcement action restricting any aspect of the airlines' fare advertising or operations involving rates, routes, or services.7 The Fifth Circuit again affirmed, and the Supreme Court granted certiorari.8
The guidelines themselves contain specific provisions governing print, broadcast, and billboard advertisements, requiring clear and conspicuous disclosure of material restrictions, sufficient seat availability or a statement of unavailability, inclusion of all taxes and surcharges in the advertised price, and limitations on the use of sale or discount terminology.9
Whether the Airline Deregulation Act of 1978 preempts state enforcement of the NAAG Air Travel Industry Enforcement Guidelines on airline fare advertising through general consumer protection statutes?10
Yes. The NAAG guidelines relate to rates because every provision on print, broadcast, and billboard advertisements bears a reference to air fares and collectively establishes binding requirements as to how tickets may be marketed if sold at given prices.13 The attorneys general of seven states including Texas sent the February 1988 memorandum threatening enforcement of section 2.5 and other guidelines through state deceptive advertising laws, followed by formal notices of intent to sue.14 The guidelines impose requirements for disclosure of restrictions, fare availability statements, inclusion of all surcharges, and limits on sale terminology that have a significant economic effect on the airlines' ability to market and set fares.15
The Airline Deregulation Act of 1978 preempts state enforcement of the NAAG guidelines through general consumer protection statutes.16
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Rehnquist, C. J., And Blackmun, J.
Justice Stevens, joined by the Chief Justice and Justice Blackmun, dissented.17 He maintained that the Court erred in giving the ADA's pre-emption provision the same broad construction as ERISA's relating-to clause without examining the ADA's distinct language, structure, and legislative history.18 Congress enacted the pre-emption provision solely to prevent states from replacing the withdrawn federal economic regulation of airline rates, routes, and services with their own.19
State laws prohibiting deceptive advertising relate primarily to the advertising itself rather than to rates, and any connection is indirect.20 The history demonstrates that state deceptive-practice prohibitions had long coexisted with federal airline regulation, and nothing in the ADA or its history indicates an intent to exempt airlines from those traditional state laws.21
Whether federal district courts may award injunctive relief against state attorneys general who have threatened imminent enforcement actions under state deceptive advertising laws that are claimed to be preempted?22
Under Ex parte Young federal courts may enjoin state officers who threaten and are about to commence proceedings to enforce an act claimed to violate federal law when enforcement is imminent, repetitive penalties attach, and the moving party lacks a realistic option to test the law once and raise federal defenses.23
Yes. The attorneys general had made clear through the February 1988 memorandum and subsequent formal notices of intent to sue that they would enforce the fare advertising guidelines under state laws.24 Texas law imposes additional civil penalties and consumer treble damages for multiple violations.25 The airlines therefore faced a Hobson's choice of continual violation with huge liability or obeying the law during litigation, satisfying the requirements for equitable relief.26
Federal district courts may award injunctive relief against the state attorneys general in these circumstances.27
Whether an injunction restraining state enforcement may extend beyond the specific fare advertising provisions that the states have threatened to enforce?28
Injunctive relief must be limited to the imminent state enforcement actions actually threatened.29 A broader injunction would require federal courts to adjudicate the constitutionality of state laws in hypothetical situations where it is not clear the state would apply its law, violating Article III requirements.30
No. The district court entered a permanent injunction barring any enforcement action restricting any aspect of the airlines' fare advertising or operations involving rates, routes, or services.31 The states had threatened enforcement only of the fare advertising sections of the guidelines through the memorandum and notices of intent to sue.32 The blunderbuss injunction exceeded the limits on equitable power and must be vacated as to other matters.33
An injunction restraining state enforcement may not extend beyond the specific fare advertising provisions that the states have threatened to enforce.34