11 Cal. Rptr. 2d 92, 834 P.2d 786 (1992)
On August 20, 1989, Jose and Mary Louise Menendez were killed in their Beverly Hills residence. The incident was reported shortly after its occurrence by their sons Joseph Lyle (Lyle) and Erik Galen (Erik) Menendez, who were then apparently 21 and 18 years of age, respectively.1
On March 7, 1990, a magistrate in the Municipal Court of the Beverly Hills Judicial District of Los Angeles County issued a search warrant authorizing a search of the offices and residence of Leon Jerome Oziel, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist who was Lyle’s and Erik’s psychotherapist, and seizure of specified items if found therein, including audiotape recordings containing information relating to the killings. At or about the time of issuance, the magistrate appointed a special master to accompany those who would serve the warrant.2
On March 8, 1990, accompanied by the special master, officers of the Beverly Hills Police Department served the search warrant. Dr. Oziel provided the materials and claimed the psychotherapist-patient privilege on behalf of the Menendezes, stating that none of the items should be disclosed because all were within the scope of the protection. The special master sealed the materials for a subsequent hearing in the superior court. Among the items in question were three audiotape cassettes: one contains Dr. Oziel’s notes relating to sessions with Lyle and Erik on October 31 and November 2, 1989; one contains Dr. Oziel’s notes relating to a session with Erik on November 28, 1989; and one contains an actual session Dr. Oziel conducted with Lyle and Erik on December 11, 1989. Lyle and Erik were subsequently arrested and placed in custody.3
On March 12, 1990, a felony complaint was filed on behalf of the People against the Menendezes in the Municipal Court of the Beverly Hills Judicial District of Los Angeles County.4 Count I charged the brothers with the murder of their father. As to this offense, it alleged the special circumstances of intentional murder for financial gain and intentional murder while lying in wait.5 Count II charged the brothers with the murder of their mother. As to this offense, it alleged the special circumstances of intentional murder for financial gain and intentional murder while lying in wait.6 The complaint separately alleged the special circumstance of multiple murder.7
On March 19, 1990, Dr. Oziel filed a motion in the Los Angeles Superior Court under Penal Code section 1524, subdivision (c), effectively claiming for the Menendezes the psychotherapist-patient privilege, as established by Evidence Code section 1014, as to the items seized pursuant to the search warrant.8 The Menendezes successfully moved to intervene. They filed papers in support of the privilege.9 By contrast, the People, through the Los Angeles District Attorney, filed papers in opposition.10
Over several days between June 8 and August 3, 1990, the superior court conducted an evidentiary hearing on the claim of the psychotherapist-patient privilege as to the items seized.11 For the most part, on the Menendezes’ motion pursuant to Evidence Code section 915 and over the People’s opposition, the superior court held the proceedings in camera in the presence of the brothers and their respective counsel without the People’s representatives. At the hearing in camera, Dr. Oziel and Smyth were among those who testified. Exhibits submitted included the three audiotape cassettes as well as transcripts of their contents made at the direction of the Menendezes’ counsel.12 On August 6, 1990, the superior court rejected the claim of the psychotherapist-patient privilege as to each and every one of the three audiotape cassettes.13
On August 14, 1990, the Menendezes filed a petition for writ of mandate and/or prohibition in the Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, attacking the superior court’s ruling rejecting the claim of the psychotherapist-patient privilege as to the three audiotape cassettes. In support, they also filed certain transcripts and exhibits under seal against the eyes of the People. On August 23, the Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Five, summarily denied the petition with a citation to Clark.14 On October 10, the Supreme Court granted review and transferred the matter to the Court of Appeal. On March 28, 1991, the Court of Appeal filed a decision again denying the Menendezes’ petition.15 On June 27, the Supreme Court granted review.1617
The superior court found that as to the sessions of October 31 and November 2, Dr. Oziel had reasonable cause to believe that Lyle and Erik were dangerous and that disclosure was necessary to prevent harm.18 By contrast, as to the sessions of November 28 and December 11, the superior court found that the evidence was insufficient to establish that Dr. Oziel had reasonable cause to believe that disclosure was necessary to prevent any harm.19
Whether the psychotherapist-patient privilege applies to the communications reflected on the audiotape containing Dr. Oziel's notes of the October 31 and November 2, 1989 sessions?20
The psychotherapist-patient privilege established by Evidence Code section 1014 protects confidential communications between patient and psychotherapist transmitted in the course of the relationship and in confidence by a means which so far as the patient is aware discloses the information to no outside third persons.21 The dangerous patient exception under Evidence Code section 1024 provides there is no privilege if the psychotherapist has reasonable cause to believe that the patient is in such mental or emotional condition as to be dangerous to himself or to the person or property of another. Disclosure of the communication must be necessary to prevent the threatened danger.22
No. The established facts demonstrate that a search warrant was served on Dr. Oziel on March 8, 1990, resulting in seizure of three audiotape cassettes including the one containing notes of the October 31 and November 2 sessions. The Menendezes intervened in superior court to claim the privilege as to all seized items.23 The superior court conducted an evidentiary hearing over several days between June 8 and August 3, 1990, and on August 6, 1990, rejected the claim of privilege as to each of the three audiotape cassettes. The Court of Appeal denied the subsequent petition for writ of mandate.24
These procedural facts establish that the dangerous patient exception was satisfied for the October 31 and November 2 sessions because the superior court determined Dr. Oziel possessed the requisite reasonable cause regarding dangerousness and necessity of disclosure.25 The privilege therefore yields under the exception and does not apply to those communications.26
The psychotherapist-patient privilege does not apply to the communications reflected on the audiotape containing Dr. Oziel's notes of the October 31 and November 2, 1989 sessions.27
Whether the psychotherapist-patient privilege applies to the communications reflected on the audiotape containing Dr. Oziel's notes of the November 28, 1989 session?28
The psychotherapist-patient privilege established by Evidence Code section 1014 protects confidential communications between patient and psychotherapist transmitted in the course of the relationship and in confidence by a means which so far as the patient is aware discloses the information to no outside third persons. The dangerous patient exception under Evidence Code section 1024 provides there is no privilege if the psychotherapist has reasonable cause to believe that the patient is in such mental or emotional condition as to be dangerous to himself or to the person or property of another. Disclosure of the communication must be necessary to prevent the threatened danger.
Yes. The established facts demonstrate that a search warrant was served on Dr. Oziel on March 8, 1990, resulting in seizure of three audiotape cassettes including the one containing notes of the November 28 session. The Menendezes intervened in superior court to claim the privilege as to all seized items. The superior court conducted an evidentiary hearing over several days between June 8 and August 3, 1990, and on August 6, 1990, rejected the claim of privilege as to each of the three audiotape cassettes. The Court of Appeal denied the subsequent petition for writ of mandate.
These procedural facts establish that the dangerous patient exception was not satisfied for the November 28 session because the superior court determined the evidence was insufficient to show reasonable cause that disclosure was necessary to prevent harm.29 The communications at the November 28 session were made in the course of a psychotherapist-patient relationship for the purpose of therapy and no waiver occurred.30 The privilege therefore applies and was properly sustained as to those communications.31
The psychotherapist-patient privilege applies to the communications reflected on the audiotape containing Dr. Oziel's notes of the November 28, 1989 session.32
Whether the psychotherapist-patient privilege applies to the communications reflected on the audiotape containing the recording of the December 11, 1989 session?33
The psychotherapist-patient privilege established by Evidence Code section 1014 protects confidential communications between patient and psychotherapist transmitted in the course of the relationship and in confidence by a means which so far as the patient is aware discloses the information to no outside third persons. The dangerous patient exception under Evidence Code section 1024 provides there is no privilege if the psychotherapist has reasonable cause to believe that the patient is in such mental or emotional condition as to be dangerous to himself or to the person or property of another. Disclosure of the communication must be necessary to prevent the threatened danger.
Yes. The established facts demonstrate that a search warrant was served on Dr. Oziel on March 8, 1990, resulting in seizure of three audiotape cassettes including the one containing the recording of the December 11 session. The Menendezes intervened in superior court to claim the privilege as to all seized items. The superior court conducted an evidentiary hearing over several days between June 8 and August 3, 1990, and on August 6, 1990, rejected the claim of privilege as to each of the three audiotape cassettes. The Court of Appeal denied the subsequent petition for writ of mandate.
These procedural facts establish that the dangerous patient exception was not satisfied for the December 11 session because the superior court determined the evidence was insufficient to show reasonable cause that disclosure was necessary to prevent harm.34 The communications at the December 11 session were made in the course of a psychotherapist-patient relationship for the purpose of therapy and no waiver occurred.35 The privilege therefore applies and was properly sustained as to those communications.
The psychotherapist-patient privilege applies to the communications reflected on the audiotape containing the recording of the December 11, 1989 session.36