383 U.S. 413 (1966)
John Cleland wrote Memoirs of a Woman of Pleasure, commonly known as Fanny Hill, in about 1750.1 The book recounts the adventures of a young girl who becomes a prostitute in London.2 At the end she abandons that life and marries her first lover, observing that the paths of virtue are strewn with unfading roses.
In 1963 an American publishing house undertook publication of the book.3 Universities and libraries placed unusually large orders, and the Library of Congress requested the right to translate it into Braille. The Attorney General of Massachusetts brought a civil equity suit under General Laws of Massachusetts Chapter 272 sections 28C through 28H to have the book declared obscene.4 Notice of the order to show cause was published in a Boston daily newspaper and sent by registered mail to G. P. Putnam's Sons, the alleged publisher and copyright holder.
G. P. Putnam's Sons intervened on behalf of the book but did not request a jury trial.5 At the hearing before a justice of the Superior Court conducted under the usual course of equity proceedings the court received the book in evidence along with expert testimony and book reviews.6 Neither side introduced evidence concerning the manner and form of publication advertisement and distribution.7 The trial justice entered a final decree adjudging the book obscene and declaring that it lacked First and Fourteenth Amendment protection.8
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court affirmed the decree.9 The United States Supreme Court noted probable jurisdiction and reversed.10
Whether Memoirs of a Woman of Pleasure satisfies the test of obscenity established in Roth v. United States?11
Under Roth v. United States material is obscene only if three elements coalesce.12 The dominant theme of the material taken as a whole appeals to a prurient interest in sex.13 The material is patently offensive because it affronts contemporary community standards relating to the description or representation of sexual matters.14 The material is utterly without redeeming social value.15 Each criterion must be applied independently.16
No. The Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts erred in its application of the Roth test when it adjudged Memoirs obscene. John Cleland wrote the book in about 1750. The Attorney General brought a civil equity suit to have it declared obscene. The Supreme Judicial Court purported to apply the Roth definition but misinterpreted the social value criterion by holding that a book need not be unqualifiedly worthless before it can be deemed obscene.
Reversal is required because the court below erred on the third element without any need to examine prurient appeal or patent offensiveness.17
The judgment of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court must be reversed because the book was not shown to be utterly without redeeming social value under the correct independent application of the Roth criteria.18
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Douglas concurred in the judgment on the ground that the First Amendment does not permit censorship of expression not brigaded with illegal action.19 He observed that the prosecution made virtually no effort to prove the book utterly without redeeming social importance.20 The defense on the other hand introduced considerable and impressive testimony establishing the book's literary historical and social importance.21
Even under the prevailing view of the Roth test reversal was compelled by the record which made clear that Fanny Hill is not obscene.22 He would pair his assessment with expert literary views rather than decide literary merit himself.23 Four of seven justices on the Massachusetts court found the book obscene while four of seven New York judges reached the opposite conclusion.24
To outlaw the book on such a record would allow majorities to rule where minorities were intended to be supreme.25
Justice Clark dissented on the ground that Memoirs is typical pornographic material consisting of a series of minutely and vividly described sexual episodes.26 The whole purpose of the book is to arouse prurient interest and the repetition of episodes renders it patently offensive.27 He maintained that the trial court's specific findings that the book is utterly without redeeming social importance were never overturned on appeal.28
Social importance is not a separate constitutional test but must be considered together with prurient appeal and patent offensiveness.29 The defense experts produced strained testimony that failed to establish any genuine literary or historical value.30 The book's repeated appeals to prurient interest leave it utterly without redeeming social importance.31
Whether the social value criterion requires that a book be unqualifiedly worthless before it can be deemed obscene?32
A book cannot be proscribed unless it is found to be utterly without redeeming social value.33 This element must be applied independently.34 The social value of the book can neither be weighed against nor canceled by its prurient appeal or patent offensiveness.35 Even a modicum of social value precludes a finding of obscenity.36
Yes. The Supreme Judicial Court erred when it stated that a book appealing to prurient interest and patently offensive need not be unqualifiedly worthless before it can be deemed obscene.37 The trial court received the book in evidence together with expert testimony and book reviews.38 The Supreme Judicial Court itself acknowledged that the testimony indicated some minimal literary value yet still upheld the obscenity finding.39
Because each of the three federal constitutional criteria must be applied independently the judgment rests on an erroneous interpretation of the federal standard.40
A finding of obscenity is impermissible whenever a book possesses even minimal redeeming social value regardless of its prurient appeal or patent offensiveness.41
Related opinions on this issue
Justice White dissented on the ground that treating social importance as an independent test rejects the basic proposition of Roth that material meeting the prurient appeal definition is inherently and utterly without social value.42 He maintained that social importance is relevant only to determining the predominant prurient interest of the material.43 If the predominant theme of the book appeals to the prurient interest as stated in Roth but the book nevertheless contains here and there a passage descriptive of character geography or architecture the book would not be obscene under the social importance test.44
Well written obscenity would be protected while poorly written obscenity would remain vulnerable.45 The Roth Court's emphatic reliance on the quotation from Chaplinsky means that such material is of slight social value as a step to truth and is outweighed by the social interest in order and morality.
Whether the circumstances of production, sale, and publicity are relevant in determining whether a book with minimal social value is obscene?46
On the premise that a book has the requisite prurient appeal and is patently offensive but has only a minimum of social value the circumstances of production sale and publicity are relevant in determining whether the publication or distribution is constitutionally protected.47 Evidence that the book was commercially exploited for the sake of prurient appeal to the exclusion of all other values might justify the conclusion that the book was utterly without redeeming social importance.48
Yes. The Supreme Court explained that where the purveyor's sole emphasis is on the sexually provocative aspects a court could accept that evaluation at face value.49 In this proceeding the courts were asked to judge the obscenity of Memoirs in the abstract.50 The declaration of obscenity was neither aided nor limited by any specific set of circumstances of production sale and publicity.51
All possible uses of the book must therefore be considered.52 The mere risk that the book might be exploited by panderers cannot alter the fact that the book will have redeeming social importance in the hands of those who publish or distribute it on the basis of its value.53
Because the case was decided without reference to any particular circumstances of commercial exploitation the book cannot be condemned as obscene when it possesses a modicum of social value in some hands.54
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Harlan dissented on the ground that the prevailing opinion's use of the pandering notion to offset social value wipes out any certainty the latter term might be given by reliance on experts.55 It admits highly prejudicial evidence without appropriate restrictions.56 He would have affirmed the judgment because the State may weigh elements of offensiveness pruriency and social value and ban a particular work without exceeding constitutional limits.57
The latitude the States deserve cautions against any federally imposed formula listing the exclusive ingredients of obscenity.58 On this record the book has been shown to have some quantum of social value yet may at the same time be deemed offensive and salacious.59