404 U.S. 189 (1971)
A jury in the Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois, convicted appellant Mayer on nonfelony charges of disorderly conduct and interference with a police officer in violation of ordinances of the city of Chicago.1 He was sentenced to a $250 fine on each offense, with each violation carrying a maximum penalty of $500.2
Desiring to appeal, Mayer petitioned the Circuit Court for a free transcript of the trial proceedings.3 He sought the transcript to support his claims that the evidence was insufficient for conviction and that prosecutorial misconduct denied him a fair trial.4 The Circuit Court found that he was indigent but denied the application because Rule 607 of the Illinois Supreme Court applied only to felony cases.5
Mayer then made a motion in the Illinois Supreme Court for an order that he be furnished a transcript of proceedings without cost.6 The Illinois Supreme Court denied the motion in an unreported order without filing an opinion.7 The United States Supreme Court noted probable jurisdiction of the appeal challenging the constitutionality of the limitation of Rule 607 to felony cases.8
At the time of his convictions in 1969, Mayer was a third-year student in New York University Medical School.9 A court reporter was provided at the trial, and the estimated cost of preparing a transcript was $300.10 Mayer's appeal from his conviction was docketed in the Illinois Supreme Court with its disposition deferred pending the decision in this case.11
Whether Illinois Supreme Court Rule 607(b) limiting free transcripts to felony cases denies indigent defendants convicted of nonfelony offenses an adequate appellate record under the Fourteenth Amendment?12
The principle established in Griffin v. Illinois requires that once avenues of appellate review are established, they must be kept free of unreasoned distinctions that can only impede open and equal access to the courts.13 This constitutional command, rooted in the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment, prohibits the state from conditioning effective appellate review on the defendant's ability to pay for a transcript in felony cases while denying it in nonfelony cases.14 The distinction between felony and nonfelony offenses drawn by Rule 607(b) can no more satisfy the requirements of the Fourteenth Amendment than could the like distinction in the Wisconsin law held invalid in Groppi v. Wisconsin.15
Yes. Mayer was convicted of nonfelony charges of disorderly conduct and interference with a police officer.16 The Circuit Court denied his petition for a free transcript solely because Rule 607(b) applied only to felony cases.17 Mayer was found indigent.18
He sought the transcript to raise claims of insufficient evidence and prosecutorial misconduct.19 The size of the defendant's pocketbook bears no more relationship to his guilt or innocence in a nonfelony than in a felony case.20 This renders the distinction an unreasoned one proscribed by the Fourteenth Amendment.21
Illinois Supreme Court Rule 607(b) therefore denies indigent defendants convicted of nonfelony offenses an adequate appellate record under the Fourteenth Amendment.22
Related opinions on this issue
Chief Justice Burger joined the Court's opinion but observed that there are alternatives in the majority of cases to a full verbatim transcript of an entire trial.23 He emphasized the duty of counsel as officers of the court to seek only what is needed.24 In most cases the essential facts are not in dispute on appeal or the dispute centers on limited aspects of the case.25
Burger warned that excessive demands for free transcripts cause delay.26 When costs are paid by the public, counsel are sometimes profligate in their demands.27 He agreed that a full verbatim record should be provided where necessary but stressed that judges and lawyers have a duty to avoid abuses that promote delays.28
Whether an indigent defendant sentenced only to fines is entitled to a free transcript or equivalent record to support claims of insufficient evidence and prosecutorial misconduct on appeal?29
Griffin does not represent a balance between the needs of the accused and the interests of society.30 Its principle is a flat prohibition against pricing indigent defendants out of as effective an appeal as would be available to others able to pay their own way.31 The invidiousness of the discrimination that exists when criminal procedures are made available only to those who can pay is not erased by any differences in the sentences that may be imposed.32 The State's fiscal interest is therefore irrelevant.33
Yes. Although Mayer was sentenced only to fines of $250 on each nonfelony offense rather than imprisonment, the principle of Griffin applies equally.34 A fine may bear as heavily on an indigent accused as forced confinement.35 The collateral consequences of conviction may be even more serious.36
The impecunious medical student finds himself barred from the practice of medicine because of a conviction he is unable to appeal for lack of funds.37 Mayer's claims of insufficiency of the evidence and prejudicial prosecutorial misconduct require a record of sufficient completeness.38
An indigent defendant sentenced only to fines is entitled to a free transcript or equivalent record to support claims of insufficient evidence and prosecutorial misconduct on appeal.39
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Blackmun concurred in the opinion and judgment but added an observation that the record indicates that in 1969, when the charges were brought against the appellant and he asserted his indigency, he was a third-year student in New York University Medical School.40 He noted that perhaps in the intervening two years the appellant has completed his professional training and is even licensed and earning his living.41 If so, these will be factors to be considered by the Illinois courts on remand.42
Whether the state must demonstrate that alternatives to a full verbatim transcript suffice before denying an indigent appellant's request in a nonfelony case?43
Where the grounds of appeal make out a colorable need for a complete transcript. The burden is on the State to show that only a portion of the transcript or an alternative will suffice for an effective appeal on those grounds.44 The state must provide a full verbatim record where that is necessary to assure the indigent as effective an appeal as would be available to the defendant with resources to pay his own way.45 A record of sufficient completeness does not translate automatically into a complete verbatim transcript, but alternatives must place before the appellate court an equivalent report of the events at trial.46
Yes. Mayer urged that his claims of insufficiency of the evidence and prejudicial prosecutorial misconduct cannot be fairly judged without recourse to the trial record.47 Draper suggests that these are the kinds of claims that require provision of a verbatim transcript.48 The City of Chicago urged that the Illinois procedures for a Settled or Agreed statement may provide adequate alternatives.49
The record before the Court contained only the parties' conflicting assertions.50 Neither Illinois court below regarded resolution of the dispute to be relevant in light of Rule 607(b).51
The state must demonstrate that alternatives to a full verbatim transcript suffice before denying an indigent appellant's request in a nonfelony case.52