502 N.E.2d 184 (N.Y. 1986)
In 1983, Maxton Builders, Inc. entered into a contract to sell a newly constructed house to the Lo Galbo defendants for $210,000.1 On August 3, the defendants provided a check for $21,000 as a down payment to be held in escrow.2 The contract included a handwritten rider requested by the defendants allowing cancellation if real estate taxes exceeded $3,500 based on the full assessment, upon written notice within three days and return of escrow funds.3
The following day, defendant Cynthia Lo Galbo and plaintiff's president Scott Seeman visited the county tax assessor's office and learned the assessment exceeded $3,500.4 The defendants' attorney then telephoned plaintiff's counsel to inform him of the decision to cancel and mailed a certified letter on August 5, which plaintiff's attorney received on August 9.5 Several days later, plaintiff's attorney received notice that the defendants had stopped payment on the check.6
On September 20, 1983, the plaintiff commenced an action against the defendants to recover the down payment amount.7 The defendants answered that they had properly exercised their cancellation right.8 On December 20, 1983, the plaintiff sold the house to another purchaser for the same price, but incurred a $12,000 real estate broker's fee for that sale.9 Both parties moved for summary judgment.10
Special Term denied the plaintiff's motion for summary judgment, finding a fact question as to whether recovery of the down payment would constitute a penalty.11 The Appellate Division modified the order and granted summary judgment to the plaintiff for the down payment amount.12 The defendants then appealed to the Court of Appeals.13
Whether the defendants' notice of cancellation satisfied the timing and delivery requirements stated in the contract rider?14
When a contract requires that written notice be given within a specified time, the notice is ineffective unless the writing is actually received within the time prescribed.15
No. The handwritten rider required written notice of cancellation within three days. The defendants mailed the certified letter on August 5, but plaintiff's attorney received it on August 9.16 Although the defendants' attorney telephoned plaintiff's counsel within the period, the contract specified written notice actually received within the three-day window.17
The defendants' notice of cancellation did not satisfy the timing and delivery requirements stated in the contract rider.18
Whether a purchaser who stops payment on a down payment check after attempting to cancel may recover that payment from the vendor?19
A vendee who defaults on a real estate contract without lawful excuse cannot recover the down payment.20
No. Because the cancellation was ineffective, the defendants' refusal to perform constituted a breach.21 Under the rule of Lawrence v Miller, the plaintiff vendor may retain the $21,000 down payment even though it later resold the house for the same price.22 The defendants stopped payment on the check after their attempt to cancel failed to comply with the contract terms, triggering the traditional forfeiture rule.23
A purchaser who stops payment on a down payment check after attempting to cancel may not recover that payment from the vendor.24
Whether the rule allowing a vendor to retain a down payment upon a purchaser's default in a real estate contract should be reexamined?25
A court should not depart from its prior holdings unless impelled by the most cogent reasons.26 This standard is particularly apt in cases involving the legal effect of contractual relations.27 When contractual rights are at issue, stability and adherence to precedent are generally more important than a better or even a correct rule of law.28
No. The rule permitting a vendor to retain a down payment approximating ten percent upon the purchaser's default has been settled in this State for more than a century.29 Changing the rule would not provide a better or more workable approach because actual damages in real estate transactions are difficult to estimate and often close to the amount retained.30 The parties may address any dissatisfaction at the bargaining table.31
The rule allowing a vendor to retain a down payment upon a purchaser's default in a real estate contract should not be reexamined.32