391 U.S. 1 (1968)
Mathis was convicted by a jury in a United States District Court on two counts charging that he knowingly filed false claims against the Government in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 287.1 He was sentenced to 30 months' imprisonment on each count, the sentences to run concurrently.2 The frauds charged were claims for tax refunds growing out of petitioner's individual income taxes for 1960 and 1961.3
Both income tax returns for these two years asserted receipts of income from two different companies which the government agents were unable to locate and which evidence offered tended to show were nonexistent.4 The amount of income claimed in each tax return was calculated in such a way as to show that these two nonexistent employers had withheld taxes sufficient to justify substantial refunds to petitioner.5 The Government paid the 1960 tax refund to petitioner of $885.60 as claimed.6 The record fails to show whether the 1961 claimed refund was paid.7
A part of the evidence on which the conviction rested consisted of documents and oral statements obtained from petitioner by a government agent while petitioner was in prison serving a state sentence.8 On October 30, 1964, Internal Revenue Agent Lawless interviewed petitioner in the Florida State Penitentiary to determine if the 1960 return had been prepared by petitioner and to obtain petitioner's consent in writing to extend the statute of limitations on the 1960 return.9 At this interview petitioner identified the 1960 tax return and the signature thereon as his.10 He also signed the extension form.11 Again on March 2, 1965, Agent Lawless interviewed petitioner at the penitentiary.12 This time petitioner identified the 1961 tax return and signature thereon as his and signed an extension form for this return.13
Before eliciting this information, the government agent did not warn petitioner that any evidence he gave the Government could be used against him.14 The government agent did not warn petitioner that he had a right to remain silent if he desired.15 The government agent did not warn petitioner of a right to the presence of counsel.16 The government agent did not warn petitioner that if he was unable to afford counsel one would be appointed for him.17 At trial petitioner sought several times without success to have the judge hold hearings out of the presence of the jury.18 He sought to prove that his statements to the revenue agent were given without these warnings and should therefore not be used as evidence against him.19 The District Court rejected this contention as did the Court of Appeals in affirming. 376 F. 2d 595.20
The Supreme Court granted certiorari to decide whether the Miranda case calls for reversal.21
Whether the Miranda requirements apply to questioning conducted during a tax investigation?22
The Fifth Amendment requires that a person in custody who is interrogated by officers about matters that might tend to incriminate him must be warned that he has the right to remain silent.23 Anything he says can be used against him in a court of law.24 He has the right to the presence of an attorney.25 If he cannot afford an attorney one will be appointed for him prior to any questioning if he so desires.26
Yes. Petitioner Mathis was serving a state sentence in the Florida State Penitentiary when Internal Revenue Agent Lawless interviewed him on October 30, 1964.27 Agent Lawless interviewed him again on March 2, 1965. The agent did not provide any Miranda warnings before obtaining documents and oral statements identifying the tax returns and signatures.28
Those statements and documents formed part of the evidence used to convict Mathis on two counts of knowingly filing false claims for tax refunds in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 287.29 Although the investigation began as a civil tax matter concerning 1960 and 1961 returns that claimed refunds based on nonexistent employers, the revenue agent acknowledged the possibility that the work could lead to criminal prosecution.30 The second interview occurred only eight days before a full criminal investigation began.31
The Miranda requirements apply to questioning during a tax investigation, and the conviction must be reversed because the unwarned statements were admitted at trial.32
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justices Harlan And Stewart
Justice White, joined by Justices Harlan and Stewart, dissented.33 He had dissented from Miranda itself because he viewed the decision as an extravagant and unwise interpretation of the Fifth Amendment with no significant support in history or constitutional text.34 Even assuming Miranda was correctly decided, White argued that its warning requirements do not extend to civil tax investigations.35
Such inquiries are routine adjuncts to the tax system, aimed at settling civil accounts between citizens and the government, and only sometimes lead to criminal prosecution.36 The rationale given in Miranda for warnings during in-custody interrogation of persons suspected of crime furnishes no support for requiring warnings in these civil matters, and the majority offered no additional justification for the extension.37 White would therefore affirm the conviction rather than reverse based on the absence of Miranda warnings.38
Whether Miranda warnings must be given to a person in custody for an offense separate from the matter under investigation?39
Yes. Petitioner Mathis was in custody serving a state sentence in the Florida State Penitentiary when the federal revenue agent questioned him about his individual income tax returns for 1960 and 1961.42 The agent did not provide the required warnings.43 The resulting statements and documents were introduced against him at his federal trial.44
The distinction urged by the government that Miranda applies only when custody is connected to the very case under investigation finds no support in the Miranda opinion.45 The Miranda opinion was designed to give meaningful protection to Fifth Amendment rights whenever a person is in custody and interrogated.46
Miranda warnings are required even when the person is in custody for a separate offense, and the conviction must be reversed.47
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justices Harlan And Stewart
Justice White further dissented on the custody issue.48 He argued that the majority was cavalier in concluding that Mathis was in custody in the Miranda sense. Miranda rested not on the mere fact of physical restriction but on a conclusion that coercion usually flows from police station interrogation of someone charged with or suspected of a crime.49
Mathis was confined by the State of Florida for an unrelated offense and was interrogated in familiar surroundings rather than in the hostile atmosphere of a police station.50 The rationale of Miranda therefore has no relevance to a revenue agent's civil inquiry conducted outside that coercive setting.51 White would not apply Miranda warnings here and would affirm the conviction.52