31 Cal. 2d 489, 190 P.2d 1 (1948)
Plaintiff Albert L. Luthringer was employed at Flynn's pharmacy in the Sacramento Medico-Dental Building.1 Defendant B. L. Moore operated a pest eradication business and was engaged to fumigate basement areas under a restaurant and dress shop in adjacent buildings owned by Sacramento Medico-Dental Building Company.2 On November 16, 1943, Moore released hydrocyanic acid gas in the basement rooms around midnight.3
The following morning, Luthringer arrived at the pharmacy at approximately 8:45 a.m. to open the store for the day.4 He entered through a door from the office building lobby that bore no warning signs about the gas.5 After proceeding to a mezzanine floor to change clothes, Luthringer felt ill, returned to the main floor, and lost consciousness.6
Luthringer was discovered unconscious by the pharmacy bookkeeper between 9:15 and 9:30 a.m.7 He was treated at the scene by city firemen using a resuscitator.8 He was then transported to the hospital, where he was diagnosed with hydrocyanic acid gas poisoning.9 Multiple witnesses, including the bookkeeper, a lobby visitor, a pharmacy employee, a fireman, and the treating doctor, detected the characteristic odor of the gas in the pharmacy, on Luthringer's person and clothing, and in nearby areas of the building.10
Luthringer brought suit against Moore, the building owner, and the restaurant operator, pleading counts for absolute liability and for negligence.11 The trial court granted a nonsuit on the negligence count.12 The jury returned a verdict awarding Luthringer $20,000 against Moore, which the court reduced to $10,000 upon motion for new trial.13 Moore appealed from the judgment, while Luthringer's appeal as to the other defendants was abandoned following affirmance as to Moore.14
Whether the evidence is sufficient to justify the verdict in favor of plaintiff against defendant Moore?15
The evidence must point unerringly to the conclusion that there was cyanide gas in the pharmacy, that it came from the fumigation operation in the basement, and that plaintiff was poisoned by such gas.16
Yes. Moore released the gas in the basement the night before the injury.17 The gas is lighter than air, readily diffuses, and is very penetrating.18 Multiple witnesses, including the bookkeeper whose throat burned, a lobby visitor who smelled the bitter almond odor, a pharmacy employee, a fireman whose clothes were saturated, and the treating doctor who detected the odor on plaintiff's breath, confirmed the gas reached the pharmacy and poisoned Luthringer.19
Moore's arguments about care used and conflicts in detection merely pose questions for the jury that were resolved in plaintiff's favor.20
The evidence is sufficient to justify the verdict against Moore.21
Whether the trial court erred in instructing the jury that the use and release of hydrocyanic acid gas constituted an ultra-hazardous activity as a matter of law?22
The question of whether the case is a proper one for imposing absolute or strict liability is one of law for the court.23
No. The trial court properly determined as a matter of law that releasing hydrocyanic acid gas under the circumstances constituted an ultra-hazardous activity.24 The instruction accurately stated the legal standard without invading the jury's province on factual questions such as whether the gas escaped or caused harm, as those elements were left for jury determination under separate proximate cause instructions.25
The trial court did not err in instructing the jury that the use and release of hydrocyanic acid gas constituted an ultra-hazardous activity as a matter of law.26
Whether Moore was absolutely liable for the injury without fault under the doctrine of strict liability?27
One who carries on an ultra-hazardous activity is liable to another whom the actor should recognize as likely to be harmed by the unpreventable miscarriage of the activity for harm resulting to said person from that which makes the activity ultra-hazardous, although the utmost care is exercised to prevent the harm.28 This liability applies unless the person injured knew or in the exercise of reasonable care should have known its ultra-hazardous nature and fails to exercise reasonable care to avoid the harm threatened thereby after acquiring knowledge that the ultra-hazardous activity is being carried on and after it has miscarried or is about to miscarry.29 An activity is ultra-hazardous if it (a) necessarily involves a risk of serious harm to the person, land or chattels of others which cannot be eliminated by the exercise of the utmost care, and (b) is not a matter of common usage.30
Yes. Moore carried on the activity of releasing hydrocyanic acid gas, a lethal substance that is highly penetrative and cannot be fully confined even with utmost care, in the basement of commercial buildings occupied by many tenants.31 The activity is not a matter of common usage because only three licensed operators exist in Sacramento and it is not carried on by the great mass of mankind.32 The gas escaped to the pharmacy, a location Moore should have recognized as likely to be harmed, and injured Luthringer who had no knowledge of the danger because no warning signs appeared on the door he used.33
These facts satisfy every element of the rule of strict liability for the miscarriage of an ultra-hazardous activity.34
Moore was absolutely liable for the injury without fault under the doctrine of strict liability.35