435 U.S. 829 (1978)
On October 4, 1975, the Virginian Pilot, a newspaper published by Landmark Communications, Inc., printed an article accurately reporting on a pending inquiry by the Virginia Judicial Inquiry and Review Commission into the conduct of a state judge and identifying that judge.1 The article stated that no formal complaint had been filed by the commission against the judge, indicating either insufficient cause or that the case remained under review.2
A month later, on November 5, 1975, a grand jury indicted Landmark for violating Va. Code § 2.1-37.13 by unlawfully divulging the identification of the judge who was the subject of the investigation and hearing by the Commission.3 The trial commenced on December 16, 1975, after the court denied Landmark’s motion to quash or dismiss the indictment on statutory and constitutional grounds.4
The essential facts were stipulated, revealing that the Commission had not filed a formal complaint with the Supreme Court of Virginia at the time of publication.5 Joseph W. Dunn, Jr., managing editor of the Virginian Pilot, testified that he decided to publish because the subject was a matter of public importance, that he knew the statute made participation in Commission proceedings a misdemeanor but did not understand it to apply to newspaper reports, and that no reporter or representative of Landmark had been subpoenaed by or appeared before the Commission.6
Landmark was found guilty after a bench trial and fined $500 plus costs of prosecution.7 The Supreme Court of Virginia affirmed the conviction, with Justice Poff dissenting.8 At the time, 47 states, the District of Columbia, and Puerto Rico had established judicial inquiry and disciplinary procedures, nearly all providing for confidentiality of proceedings, though only Virginia and Hawaii imposed criminal sanctions for disclosure by third parties.9
The United States Supreme Court noted probable jurisdiction and heard the appeal from the Virginia Supreme Court’s judgment.10
Whether the First Amendment permits the criminal punishment of third persons who are strangers to the inquiry, including the news media, for divulging or publishing truthful information regarding confidential proceedings of the Judicial Inquiry and Review Commission?11
The First Amendment protects publication by the press of truthful information about confidential proceedings of a judicial inquiry commission.12 The state's interests in confidentiality do not justify criminal sanctions against nonparticipants absent a clear and present danger to the administration of justice.13
No. Landmark published an accurate article identifying the judge under investigation by the Commission at a time when no formal complaint had been filed.14 Landmark was a stranger to the proceedings with no representative having appeared before the Commission.15 The state's asserted interests in protecting judicial reputation and maintaining public confidence in the courts fall short of justifying criminal punishment.16
The record contains no actual facts showing an imminent threat to the administration of justice.17 More than forty other states maintain similar commissions without imposing criminal sanctions on nonparticipants.18 The mechanical application of the clear-and-present-danger test by the Virginia Supreme Court cannot sustain the conviction when the danger posed by the publication is neither extremely serious nor extremely imminent.19
The First Amendment prohibits Virginia from imposing criminal sanctions on Landmark for publishing the truthful information about the confidential Commission proceedings.20
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Stewart concurred in the judgment.21 He agreed that Virginia may punish participants who violate the confidentiality of Commission proceedings.22 However, Virginia cannot constitutionally punish a newspaper for publishing information that has come into its possession.23
If the constitutional protection of a free press means anything, government cannot take it upon itself to decide what a newspaper may and may not publish.24 Government may deny access to information and punish its theft, but government may not prohibit or punish the publication of that information once it falls into the hands of the press, unless the need for secrecy is manifestly overwhelming.25