99 S. Ct. 1171, 440 U.S. 391, 59 L. Ed. 2d 401 (1979)
Lake Tahoe is a unique mountain lake located partly in California and partly in Nevada.1 The Lake Tahoe Basin comprises a 500 square mile area that has grown rapidly as a popular resort area.2
In 1968 the States of California and Nevada agreed to create a single agency to coordinate and regulate development in the Basin and to conserve its natural resources.3 Congress gave its consent to the Compact in 1969, and the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency was organized with authority to adopt and enforce a regional plan for land use, transportation, conservation, recreation, and public services.4
Petitioners own property in the Lake Tahoe Basin.5 In 1973 they filed a complaint in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of California alleging that TRPA, the individual members of its governing body, and its executive officer had adopted a land-use ordinance and general plan that destroyed the economic value of petitioners’ property.6 Petitioners alleged violations of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments and sought monetary and equitable relief.7
The District Court dismissed the complaint.8 It concluded that an inverse condemnation action could not be brought against TRPA because the agency lacked condemnation authority.9 The court also held that the individual defendants were immune from liability for the exercise of the discretionary functions alleged.10
On appeal the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of TRPA but reinstated the complaint against the individual respondents.11 The court held that TRPA was protected by sovereign immunity under the Eleventh Amendment and remanded for a hearing on whether the challenged conduct was legislative or executive.12
The Supreme Court granted certiorari to decide whether TRPA is entitled to Eleventh Amendment immunity.13 The Court also addressed whether the individual members of the Agency’s governing body are entitled to absolute immunity from federal damages claims when acting in a legislative capacity.1415
Whether the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency is entitled to Eleventh Amendment immunity from suit in federal court?16
The Eleventh Amendment affords protection only to one of the United States.17 It does not extend to political subdivisions such as counties or municipalities.18 An interstate compact agency receives no such immunity unless the compacting states structured the entity as an arm of the state to enable it to enjoy the special constitutional protection and Congress concurred in that purpose.19
No. The Compact itself labels TRPA a separate legal entity and political subdivision.20
TRPA’s authority to make rules within its jurisdiction is not subject to veto at the state level.21 Because the Eleventh Amendment text protects only the states and the structure here mirrors a municipality, TRPA receives no immunity.22
The Tahoe Regional Planning Agency is not entitled to Eleventh Amendment immunity from suit in federal court.23
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Brennan dissented in part.24 He joined Part I of Justice Blackmun’s opinion dissenting in part.25 In addition he would not reach the question whether compacting States can create an agency protected by Eleventh Amendment immunity, which the Court discusses in dicta.26
In all other respects Justice Brennan joined the Court’s opinion.27 His position rests on the view that the Eleventh Amendment issue was unnecessary to decide once jurisdiction and the individual-immunity questions were resolved on alternative grounds.28
Whether the individual members of the Agency’s governing body are entitled to absolute immunity from federal damages claims when acting in a legislative capacity?29
State legislators enjoy absolute immunity from suit under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for actions taken in the sphere of legitimate legislative activity.30 The same absolute immunity extends to regional legislators performing comparable legislative functions.31 The public-good rationale of protecting uninhibited discharge of legislative duty applies equally at the regional level.32
Yes. The Court of Appeals correctly held that absolute immunity protects conduct of a legislative character.33 Petitioners seek damages from the individual respondents for adopting a land-use ordinance and general plan.34 Those actions fall within the sphere of legitimate legislative activity.35
The reasoning that legislators must be free from the cost and distraction of trial applies with equal force to regional officials.36 Although petitioners argued that only federal and state legislators should receive the protection, the common-law tradition and the need for immunity to serve the public good extend to regional bodies created by interstate compact.37 The record does not yet reveal the precise mix of legislative and executive conduct.38 To the extent the individuals acted in a legislative capacity they are absolutely immune from federal damages liability.39
The individual members of the Agency’s governing body are entitled to absolute immunity from federal damages claims when acting in a legislative capacity.
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Marshall dissented from the extension of absolute immunity to nonelected regional officials.40 He emphasized that Tenney rested on centuries of common-law legislative privilege and on the existence of electoral checks that allow voters to discourage or correct abuses.41 None of TRPA’s ten-member board is elected.42
Six are appointed by local governments, two by governors, and two serve ex officio.43 Because direct accountability to the public is absent, absolute immunity subverts the checks-and-balances system the privilege was designed to secure.44 Marshall also warned that the majority’s functional test would logically extend the same immunity to appointed municipal legislators, expanding the doctrine beyond historical limits.45
Joined by Justice Brennan
Justice Blackmun dissented from the grant of absolute immunity.46 TRPA members possess both legislative and executive powers.47 They are not in equipoise with other branches.48
They are not subject to the electoral process or internal discipline available in Congress or state legislatures.49 He would instead afford only qualified immunity under the standards of Scheuer v. Rhodes and Butz v. Economou.50 Blackmun also declined to join the majority’s flat statement that the Speech or Debate Clause has no application to state legislatures.51
The question was not presented and some federal courts had recognized a related common-law privilege.52
Whether the conduct of TRPA and its officers can be found to be under color of state law within the meaning of 42 U.S.C. § 1983 so as to support federal jurisdiction?53
Section 1983 provides a remedy for deprivations of constitutional rights by action taken under color of state law.54 An interstate compact agency and its officers act under color of state law when the compact originated in state legislation.55 Implementation depends on state and local appointments and financing.56 Federal involvement is limited to a single nonvoting member.57
Yes. Although the Court of Appeals held that congressional approval converted the Compact into federal law, the Compact had its genesis in the actions of California and Nevada. It remains part of the statutory law of both states.58 Implementation depended on appointments by the two states and their subdivisions together with mandatory county financing.59
In discharging their duties the state and county appointees necessarily served the interests of the political units that appointed them.60 Federal involvement is limited to one nonvoting member, and each state retains the right to withdraw.61 These facts adequately characterize the alleged actions as under color of state law, supplying both a cause of action under § 1983 and federal jurisdiction under § 1343.62
The conduct of TRPA and its officers can be found to be under color of state law within the meaning of 42 U.S.C. § 1983 so as to support federal jurisdiction.63