591 A.2d 932 (N.J. 1991)
On September 1, 1987, Milton and Ruth Kutzin entered into a contract with Duncan and Gertrude Pirnie for the sale of the Kutzins' house in Haworth, New Jersey, for $365,000.1 The standard-form contract prepared by the sellers' real-estate agent Weichert Realtors required the Pirnies to pay a $1,000 deposit upon signing and an additional $35,000 within seven days.2 The Pirnies provided the initial $1,000 check to their agent Russo Real Estate.3
The contract included an attorney-review clause allowing either party's attorney three days to disapprove the contract by notifying the realtors and the other party via certified mail, telegram, or personal delivery.4 On September 2 and 3, the Kutzins' attorney Marshall Kozinn wrote to Russo approving the contract except for requesting that he hold the deposit.5 On September 4, the Pirnies' attorney Joseph Maccarone wrote to Kozinn proposing amendments via a rider for buyer protection.6
The attorneys discussed changes to the rider on September 10 and agreed on modifications. The Pirnies sent the $35,000 balance on September 11.7 On September 21, Maccarone sent revised riders signed by the Pirnies.8 On September 28, the Pirnies' new attorney Harold Goldman sent a letter withdrawing the offer and requesting return of the deposit.9
The Kutzins refused to return the deposit and sued for specific performance. After selling the house to another buyer for $352,500, they amended to seek damages.10 The trial court found the contract binding and awarded the Kutzins $17,325 in damages while ordering return of the $18,675 balance of the deposit.11 The Appellate Division affirmed the contract's validity but held that the Kutzins could retain the entire $36,000 deposit.12 The Supreme Court granted certification.
Whether the contract between the parties was validly rescinded under the attorney-review provision?13
To rescind under the attorney-review clause, an attorney must notify the realtors and the other party within the three-day period by certified mail, telegram, or personal delivery; absent such notice the contract becomes legally binding as written.14
No. The established facts show that neither attorney complied with the clause's requirements during the three-day period.15 On September 2 and 3, Kozinn sent a letter to Russo that approved the contract except for a request to hold the deposit, but the letter was not sent by certified mail, did not reach Weichert, and contained no disapproval.16 On September 4, Maccarone sent a letter to Kozinn proposing a buyer-protection rider, yet that letter likewise omitted any disapproval, failed to use the required delivery methods, and reached neither the realtors nor the Kutzins.17 Because the clause demands strict adherence to its notice formalities before rescission can occur, the contract remained enforceable after the review period ended.18 The Pirnies' later withdrawal therefore constituted a breach rather than a valid rescission.19
The trial court correctly determined that the contract bound the parties.20 The Appellate Division likewise upheld enforceability.21 The Supreme Court granted certification to resolve both validity and the separate damages question.22
The contract was not rescinded under the attorney-review provision and remained enforceable.23
Whether the sellers are entitled to retain the buyers' entire deposit as damages under the contract that lacks a liquidated-damages clause?24
Under section 374(1) of the Restatement (Second) of Contracts, a breaching buyer is entitled to restitution of any benefit conferred by part performance that exceeds the loss caused by the breach; when the contract contains no liquidated-damages clause, retention of the entire deposit is not permitted if it would produce unjust enrichment.25
No. The established facts establish that the Pirnies paid a $36,000 deposit and then breached by refusing to close.2627 The trial court quantified the Kutzins' actual loss at $17,325, comprising the $12,500 resale shortfall, carrying costs of $3,825, and $1,000 for new carpet.28 Because the deposit exceeded proven damages by $18,675, the excess constitutes unjust enrichment that must be returned.29 The Appellate Division's contrary holding that the sellers could keep the entire deposit is inconsistent with the modern rule adopted by the court.30 The Kutzins therefore may retain only the amount of their actual damages and must refund the balance.31
The absence of a forfeiture clause in the contract reinforces this result.32 The Pirnies met their burden of showing that retention of the full deposit would exceed the sellers' injury.33
The sellers are not entitled to retain the buyers' entire deposit and may keep only the amount of their proven damages.34