283 F.3d 138 (3d Cir. 2002)
Lori Johnson attended Elk Lake School District in Pennsylvania as a student.1 From 1993 to 1996, she was taught by Richard W. Hall, a science teacher and athletic coach at the district.2 During this time, Hall sexually abused Johnson on numerous occasions both on and off school property.3
The abuse began in the fall of 1993 when Johnson was a freshman.4 Hall, who was her science teacher and coached the junior varsity basketball team on which she played, began showing her special attention.5 He called her out of other classes, gave her gifts, and wrote notes.6 In the spring of 1994, the abuse turned sexual, starting with an incident in a locked equipment room in the school gymnasium after a basketball game where Hall kissed Johnson and touched her breasts and genital area.7 Similar incidents occurred on school property at least ten other times during her freshman and sophomore years.8 Hall also took her to a motel for sexual intercourse and to his home on several occasions for abuse.9
The abuse continued until Johnson graduated in 1997.10 During her junior and senior years on the varsity basketball team coached by Hall, the frequency decreased but the abuse persisted.11
Johnson filed suit against Hall, the Elk Lake School District, and school officials in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania.12 She brought claims under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, Title IX, and state law.13 The district court granted summary judgment to the school officials on all claims and to Elk Lake on the § 1983 claims.14 The Title IX and state law claims against Elk Lake, along with the claims against Hall, proceeded to trial.15
At trial, Johnson attempted to introduce evidence that Hall had sexually abused two other students, Tami B. and Missy H., several years earlier.16 The district court excluded this evidence under Federal Rule of Evidence 415, finding its probative value substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice.17 The jury returned a verdict in favor of Elk Lake on the Title IX claim but found Hall liable on the state law claims, awarding Johnson $100,000 in compensatory damages.18 Johnson appealed the judgment in favor of Elk Lake on her Title IX claim and the exclusion of the prior misconduct evidence.19
Whether a school district may be held liable under Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 for the sexual abuse of a student by a teacher when the school district had no notice of the teacher's misconduct?20
Title IX imposes liability on a school district for a teacher's sexual abuse of a student only when the district has actual notice of the misconduct. The district must also respond with deliberate indifference.21
No. The Supreme Court in Gebser held that a school district may not be held liable under Title IX on the basis of respondeat superior or constructive notice.22 Rather, the district must have actual knowledge of the teacher's misconduct and must be deliberately indifferent to it.23 Applying this rule to the established facts, Johnson never reported the abuse to school officials.24 The abuse came to light only after she graduated from high school.25
Elk Lake therefore cannot be held liable under Title IX.26
The school district may not be held liable under Title IX because it lacked actual notice of the teacher's misconduct.27
Whether evidence of the teacher's prior sexual misconduct with other students was properly excluded at trial under Federal Rule of Evidence 415?28
Yes. The evidence of Hall's prior misconduct with Tami B. and Missy H. had little probative value on the issue of Elk Lake's liability under Title IX.31
It did not tend to prove that the district had actual notice of his abuse of Johnson.32 At most, the evidence tended only to prove that the District was negligent in failing to discover the prior misconduct.33 Negligence is not a basis for Title IX liability.34 Moreover, the evidence posed a substantial danger of unfair prejudice by suggesting that because Hall had abused other students in the past, he must have abused Johnson.35
The district court properly excluded the evidence of the teacher's prior sexual misconduct under Rule 403.36