34 P.3d 995 (Colo. 2001)
During a child custody dispute, Joe Dickerson & Associates, LLC and Joe Dickerson were hired to investigate Rosanne Marie (Brock) Dittmar.1 Dickerson noticed inconsistencies in the way Dittmar came to possess bearer bonds and reported the results of his investigation to authorities.2 Dittmar was thereafter charged with and convicted of felony theft of the bonds.3
Dickerson publishes a newsletter called "The Dickerson Report," which is sent free of charge to law enforcement agencies, financial institutions, law firms, and others.4 The newsletter contained a series of articles under the heading "Fraud DuJour."5 One such article, titled "Fraud DuJour Five Cases, 100% + Recovery," appeared on the front page, mentioned Dittmar by name, and included her photograph.6
The article detailed how Dittmar, who worked as a secretary at a brokerage firm, stole a customer's bearer bonds from her place of employment and cashed them for personal use.7 In addition, the article described Dickerson's investigation of Dittmar, the fact that the jury convicted Dittmar of theft, and how the court ordered her to pay restitution to the theft victim.8
Dittmar sued Dickerson and his firm on several tort theories, including defamation, outrageous conduct, and invasion of privacy by appropriation of another's name or likeness.9 The trial court granted summary judgment for Dickerson on all claims.10 With respect to the appropriation claim, the trial court noted that Colorado has not explicitly recognized this tort and granted summary judgment because Dittmar presented no evidence that her name or likeness had any value.11
Dittmar appealed the trial court's dismissal of her appropriation claim.12 The court of appeals reversed the grant of summary judgment, concluding that the plaintiff raised issues of material fact regarding the purpose of the publication and whether the use benefited Dickerson.13 Dickerson petitioned the Colorado Supreme Court for certiorari on three issues.14
Whether the tort of invasion of privacy by appropriation of another's name or likeness is cognizable under Colorado law?15
The tort of invasion of privacy by appropriation of another's name or likeness is cognizable under Colorado law.16 The elements are (1) the defendant used the plaintiff's name or likeness; (2) the use of the plaintiff's name or likeness was for the defendant's own purposes or benefit, commercially or otherwise; (3) the plaintiff suffered damages; and (4) the defendant caused the damages incurred.17
Yes. Colorado precedent in Rugg v. McCarty and Ozer v. Borquez recognized other privacy torts by relying on majority-rule acceptance across jurisdictions, and the same rationale supports recognizing appropriation here.18 Dickerson used Dittmar's name and photograph in the front-page article of The Dickerson Report.19 The article appeared under the Fraud DuJour heading and described Dickerson's investigation during the child custody dispute, Dittmar's theft of bearer bonds, her felony conviction, and the restitution order.20
The elements of the tort are satisfied on the facts alleged.21
The tort of invasion of privacy by appropriation of another's name or likeness is cognizable under Colorado law.
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Coats concurs in the judgment only.22 He agrees that Dittmar failed to allege a compensable injury resulting from any breach of duty owed by the defendant.23 He would not adopt the appropriation tort even in limited form because it is not a natural outgrowth of Colorado's prior privacy decisions.24
Publication of a felony conviction record does not appropriate any protected value such as reputation or prestige.25 He would avoid deciding the constitutional privilege question altogether because the case does not require it and because the facts do not implicate any value deserving protection by a private damages action.26
Whether an appropriation claim requires evidence that the plaintiff's name or likeness has exploitable value?27
When a plaintiff seeks only personal damages for mental anguish, an appropriation claim does not require evidence that the plaintiff's name or likeness has exploitable commercial value.28 The market value of identity is unrelated to whether the plaintiff suffered mental anguish from an unauthorized use.29
No. Dittmar sought only personal damages and presented no evidence of commercial value in her name or likeness.30 The trial court granted summary judgment on that ground, but the court of appeals reversed after finding factual issues on purpose and benefit.31 Because the claim is limited to personal injury, the absence of proof of pre-existing value does not defeat the claim.32 The Restatement comments suggesting a value element apply principally to commercial exploitation claims, which Dittmar did not pursue.33
An appropriation claim does not require evidence that the plaintiff's name or likeness has exploitable value when the plaintiff seeks only personal damages.34
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Coats would not reach the value question.35 He concludes that publication of a felony conviction simply does not implicate any value deserving protection by a private damages action.36 This conclusion applies whether the damages sought are personal or commercial.37
He would not use the case to expand the tort in any form.38 Largely for reasons set out in the majority's explanation of the cause of action, he does not consider appropriation to be a natural outgrowth of Colorado privacy law.39 He would avoid deciding constitutional issues unnecessary to the resolution of the controversy.40
Whether the defendant's article constituted constitutionally protected speech?41
A First Amendment newsworthiness privilege protects the use of a plaintiff's name or likeness when the use is made in the context of, and reasonably relates to, a publication concerning a matter of legitimate public concern such as the commission of crime, prosecutions, and judicial proceedings.42
Yes. The article detailed Dittmar's theft of bearer bonds from her brokerage employer, Dickerson's investigation during the child custody dispute, the jury conviction for felony theft, and the restitution order.43 These facts are matters of legitimate public concern under Cox Broadcasting Corp. v. Cohn.44 Although the newsletter was distributed to promote Dickerson's firm and contained commercial undertones, the predominant character remains noncommercial because the content reports truthful information about a felony conviction.45
The privilege therefore bars the appropriation claim as a matter of law.46
The defendant's article constituted constitutionally protected speech.47
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Coats concurs in the judgment because use of the name and picture under these circumstances does not implicate any value deserving of protection by a private action for damages.48 He would not decide the First Amendment privilege issue.49 The facts simply do not call for creation of a broad new duty or its constitutional limitation.50
He agrees with the judgment because the plaintiff failed to allege a compensable injury resulting from the breach of a duty.51 He would not abandon the caution with which Colorado has approached adoption of privacy torts in the past.52