18 Cal. 2d 33, 112 P.2d 631 (1941)
The California Consumers Company purchased from S. L. Coker an ice distributing business, inclusive of good will, located in territory comprising the city of Santa Monica and the former city of Sawtelle.1 In the purchase agreement, Coker contracted not to engage in the business of selling or distributing ice, either directly or indirectly, in that territory so long as the purchasers or anyone deriving title to the good will remained engaged in a like business there.2
Plaintiff, the Imperial Ice Company, acquired from the successor in interest of the California Consumers Company full title to this ice distributing business, including the right to enforce the covenant not to compete.3 Coker subsequently began selling ice in the same territory in violation of the contract. The ice was supplied to him by a company owned by W. Bossier, J. A. Matheson, and Fred Matheson.4
Plaintiff brought this action in the superior court for an injunction to restrain Coker from violating the contract and to restrain Bossier and the Mathesons from inducing Coker to violate the contract.5 The complaint alleges that Bossier and the Mathesons induced Coker to violate his contract so that they might sell ice to him at a profit.6
The trial court sustained without leave to amend a demurrer to the complaint of the defendants Bossier and Mathesons and gave judgment for those defendants.7 Plaintiff has appealed from the judgment on the sole ground that the complaint stated a cause of action against the defendants Bossier and the Mathesons for inducing the breach of contract.89
Whether the complaint stated a cause of action against the defendants Bossier and the Mathesons for inducing the breach of contract?10
It is well established, however, that a person is not justified in inducing a breach of contract simply because he is in competition with one of the parties to the contract and seeks to further his own economic advantage at the expense of the other. In California, therefore, an action will lie for unjustifiably inducing a breach of contract.11
Yes. The complaint alleges that defendants actively induced Coker to violate his contract with plaintiffs so that they might sell ice to him. The defendants, by virtue of their interest in the sale of ice in that territory, were in effect competing with plaintiff. By inducing Coker to violate his contract, as alleged in the complaint, they sought to further their own economic advantage at plaintiff’s expense.
Such conduct is not justified. It is necessary to prove that they intentionally and actively induced the breach. Since the complaint alleges that they did so and asks for an injunction on the grounds that damages would be inadequate, it states a cause of action, and the demurrer should therefore have been overruled.12
The complaint stated a cause of action against the defendants Bossier and the Mathesons for inducing the breach of contract.