183 F. Supp. 2d 328 (D. Mass. 2002)
The plaintiff, i.LAN Systems, Inc., helps companies monitor their computer networks.1 The defendant, NetScout Service Level Corp., formerly known as NextPoint Networks, Inc., sells sophisticated software that monitors networks.2 In 1998, i.LAN and NextPoint signed a detailed Value Added Reseller agreement whereby i.LAN agreed to resell NextPoint's software to customers.3
In 1999, i.LAN claims that for $85,231.42 it purchased the unlimited right to use NextPoint's software, replete with perpetual upgrades and support.4 NextPoint points to the 1998 VAR agreement and the clickwrap license agreement contained in the software itself.5
The parties continued their relationship for several months without confronting their conflicting interpretations of the 1999 purchase order.6 i.LAN filed a complaint that alleges, among other things, breach of contract and violation of Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 93A.7
i.LAN brought a motion for summary judgment seeking specific performance in particular perpetual upgrades of NextPoint's software and unlimited support.8 NextPoint brought a cross-motion for summary judgment arguing that the clickwrap license agreement limits NextPoint's liability to the price paid for the software.9 The Court heard oral argument on the motions and ruled in favor of NextPoint on September 28, 2001.10
Whether the Uniform Commercial Code or Massachusetts common law applies to the clickwrap license agreement?17
Courts in Massachusetts have assumed without deciding that Article 2 of the UCC governs software licenses.18 Although Article 2 technically requires a sale of goods and software licenses involve only a right to use, the UCC best fulfills the reasonable expectations of parties entering software transactions.19
Yes. The Court examined the clickwrap license agreement through the lens of the UCC because the 1999 transaction involved software and the parties reasonably expected some body of commercial law to apply.20 Massachusetts precedent had already assumed Article 2 coverage for software licenses, and the UCC provisions better matched commercial practice than common law rules.21
The Uniform Commercial Code applies to the clickwrap license agreement.22
Whether NextPoint's software is unique such that specific performance is an available remedy?23
No. NextPoint's software is one of several competing packages that run on ordinary computers and perform substantially the same functions.26 Although copyrighted and the product of intense labor, the packages are interchangeable as a practical matter.27 i.LAN could purchase comparable software on the open market and reconfigure its systems, so the software is not unique.28
NextPoint's software is not unique and specific performance is not an available remedy.29
Whether the clickwrap license agreement is enforceable?30
Under UCC section 2-204 a contract for sale of goods may be made in any manner sufficient to show agreement, including conduct by both parties which recognizes the existence of such a contract.31 Clicking on the box stating "I agree" constitutes explicit manifestation of assent to the clickwrap license agreement.32
Yes. i.LAN manifested assent to the clickwrap license agreement when it clicked on the box stating "I agree."33 If analyzed under UCC section 2-207 as a counteroffer, i.LAN accepted the additional terms either explicitly by clicking.34 The additional terms were not material given the nearly identical limitations already present in the 1998 VAR agreement and in prior installations.35
The clickwrap license agreement is enforceable.36
Whether the limitation of liability in the clickwrap license agreement restricts any recovery to the license fees paid?37
Section 4 of the clickwrap license agreement provides that NextPoint's liability for damages to licensee for any cause whatsoever shall be limited to the license fees paid for the licensed product.38 The UCC permits sellers to limit liability even for claims under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 93A.39
Yes. The clickwrap license agreement contains a 30-day limited warranty but otherwise disclaims all warranties and limits NextPoint's liability to the fees received for the license.40 Because i.LAN accepted the enforceable clickwrap license agreement, any recovery on its breach of contract claim is capped at the $85,231.42 paid for the software.41
The limitation of liability in the clickwrap license agreement restricts any recovery to the license fees paid.42