6 Cal. 4th 1174, 26 Cal. Rptr. 2d 8, 864 P.2d 88 (1993)
Charles Hunter began working as a welder for Up-Right, Inc. in January 1973.1 In 1980 he was promoted to welding supervisor and worked in that capacity until his employment was terminated on September 10, 1987.2
In August 1988 Hunter sued Up-Right and his former supervisor Pat Nelson alleging breach of contract, breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, and tort claims.3 After this court filed its decision in Foley v. Interactive Data Corp., Hunter amended his complaint to allege a cause of action for fraud based on the same facts.4
At trial the evidence presented was in conflict regarding the circumstances of Hunter's termination.5 Hunter testified that at the end of the workday on September 10, 1987, he was called in to meet with Nelson. According to Hunter, Nelson told him that there had been a corporate decision to eliminate his position and that if he did not resign he would be terminated.6 Hunter then signed a document setting forth his resignation.7 The next day he picked up his final paycheck, which included $5,200 in severance pay.8
Nelson testified to a different series of events.9 On several occasions during a period prior to September 9, 1987, Nelson had admonished Hunter regarding excessive absences to attend to personal matters.10 On September 9, 1987, Hunter told Nelson he was thinking of resigning due to personal problems.11 Nelson directed his secretary to prepare a resignation form for Hunter's signature.12 On September 10, Hunter returned and told Nelson he had decided to resign.13 Hunter then signed the resignation form.14 Nelson testified that no corporate decision had been made to eliminate Hunter's job.15
John Maricich, who had been plant superintendent for Up-Right for eight years until his resignation in January 1988, testified that Up-Right had a policy of terminating employees only for good cause.16 He also testified that Hunter was an excellent employee.17 Dr. Gerald Martin, a professor of finance in the School of Business at Fresno State University, testified as an economic expert witness that Hunter's past economic losses resulting from termination were $38,013 and that the present value of his future losses was $146,456.18
The jury found in favor of Hunter on three theories: breach of implied contract not to terminate employment without good cause, breach of implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, and fraud.19 By special verdict, the jury awarded Hunter $38,013 on the contractual theories and $120,000 for misrepresentation.20 The parties agreed that the $120,000 figure represented the jury's finding as to Hunter's total damages, and thus included the $38,013 awarded as contractual damages.21 The trial court entered judgment in favor of Hunter in the amount of $120,000, and the Court of Appeal affirmed.22
Whether Foley v. Interactive Data Corp. precludes recovery of tort damages for fraud and deceit predicated on a misrepresentation made to effect termination of employment?23
Foley established that the employment relationship is fundamentally contractual, with contract damages as the appropriate remedy for wrongful termination absent a violation of public policy.24
Yes. The facts show that the misrepresentation by Nelson to Hunter was made to effect the termination of employment.25 Hunter was told his position was eliminated by corporate decision, leading him to resign, but the jury found no good cause for termination.26 The result of the misrepresentation is indistinguishable from an ordinary constructive wrongful termination.27 Therefore, under Foley, tort damages for fraud are precluded because the claim is not separate from the termination itself.28
Foley precludes recovery of tort damages for the fraud claim in this case.29
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justice Arabian
Justice Mosk dissents from the majority's conclusion that Foley precludes tort recovery for fraud in this context.30 He argues that Foley rejected tort remedies only for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, not for traditional intentional torts such as fraud.31 Fraud is an independent tort that may arise together with but is distinct from a breach of contract.32
The obligation to refrain from committing fraud is a duty imposed by society to govern commercial and other human relationships.33 The facts demonstrate that Hunter would not have resigned from his job but for his reliance on his supervisor's false representations that the loss of his job due to the elimination of his position by the corporation was imminent.34 The majority's approach overlooks the different rationales of tort and contract law.35
Whether a misrepresentation made by an employer in the course of terminating an employee can support an independent cause of action for fraud?36
A misrepresentation aimed at effecting termination of employment does not give rise to an independent fraud claim because it is merely the means to the end of termination.37 Tort recovery is available only if the misrepresentation is separate from the termination and the damages cannot be said to result from termination itself.38
No. In this case, the misrepresentation was used to accomplish the termination by inducing the resignation.3940 Up-Right employed a falsehood to do what it could have accomplished directly by terminating Hunter without good cause.41 The fraud claim lacks substance because there is no detrimental reliance separate from the constructive dismissal.42 Recognition of such a claim would contravene Foley and lead to adverse consequences by encouraging the pleading of fraud in nearly every wrongful termination case.43
A misrepresentation made by an employer in the course of terminating an employee cannot support an independent cause of action for fraud.44
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Kennard dissents, contending that the fraud is readily distinguishable from constructive wrongful discharge because the latter is the legal consequence of the employer's conduct rather than the conduct itself.45 Detrimental reliance occurred when Hunter resigned based on the misrepresentation.46 The employer's use of fraud to deprive the employee of his or her rights takes the conduct outside the scope of the contractual employment relationship.47
The practical effect of the majority's holding is troubling because an employer who has decided to wrongfully terminate an employee now has nothing to lose by accomplishing that termination through the means of fraud.48 If the fraud succeeds, the employee will never discover the true reason for the termination and will never trouble the employer with a wrongful termination action.49
Joined by Justice Arabian
Justice Mosk dissents on this issue as well, maintaining that the means of discharging an employee does matter and that fraud used to induce resignation and conceal a breach of the good cause provision is independently actionable.50 The majority disregards the important difference between fraud and contract claims and the different wrongs they are designed to rectify.51
In promissory fraud cases, tort recovery is permitted despite the fact that fraud and contract damages arise from the same set of facts because the judicial system seeks to vindicate a social policy of preventing injurious deliberate falsehoods.52 The majority arbitrarily elects to except employment contracts from the rule that fraudulently terminated contracts are subject to the sanctions of tort law.53