131 Va. 125, 108 S.E. 690 (1921)
The plaintiff is a young girl between eighteen and nineteen years of age.1 She held a ticket from the city of Washington, D.C., to Seminary station in Fairfax County.2 On the second day of February, 1919, she was a passenger on the defendant's train.3
The train failed to stop at Seminary.4 Another passenger called the flagman's attention and alighted.5 The conductor initially told the plaintiff he would back the train to the station but instead pulled ahead.6 He then said he could not go back for fear of another train and offered her the choice to continue through to Richmond or get off at that point.7
The plaintiff chose to get off about seven-tenths of a mile beyond Seminary.8 A man in a United States army uniform got off on the opposite side.9 The soldier followed her, overtook her, and forcibly carried her across the track and down a high embankment where he raped her.10 Within a few moments a civilian appeared and raped her a second time.11
After the assaults the plaintiff came back to the railroad grade.12 She was met by two citizens who escorted her home.13 Her mother later confirmed she had been subjected to physical violence.14 The point of departure was near a ravine known as Hoboes’ Hollow that had been frequented by tramps and questionable characters.15 Following a verdict and judgment for the plaintiff, the defendant appealed to the Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia.16
Whether the plaintiff was ejected from the defendant’s train under such circumstances as to entitle her to claim the relationship of a passenger until she had returned to Seminary station?17
The relationship and liability of a carrier to a passenger, having once commenced, will ordinarily continue until the passenger has reached his destination; but such relationship and liability may be terminated at some other point by the passenger’s voluntary departure from the carrier’s vehicle.18
No. The plaintiff is a young girl between eighteen and nineteen years of age who held a ticket from Washington, D.C., to Seminary station in Fairfax County. On February 2, 1919, she was a passenger on the defendant's train when it failed to stop at Seminary. Another passenger called the flagman's attention and alighted. The conductor initially told the plaintiff he would back the train to the station but instead pulled ahead.
He then said he could not go back for fear of another train and offered her the choice to continue through to Richmond or get off at that point. The plaintiff chose to get off about seven-tenths of a mile beyond Seminary. A man in a United States army uniform got off on the opposite side. He followed her, committing the first rape.
A civilian committed the second shortly after. After the assaults, she was met by two citizens who escorted her home. Her injuries were confirmed by her mother. The departure point was near Hoboes’ Hollow, known for tramps and questionable characters.
The evidence was conflicting on whether she exercised free will in leaving the train.19 Therefore, the question of whether she voluntarily terminated the passenger relationship was one for the jury under proper instructions.20
Whether the assaults to which she was subjected can be regarded as proximately caused by such wrongful ejection from the train?23
When once it has been determined that the act is wrongful or negligent, the guilty party is liable for all the consequences which naturally flow therefrom, whether they were reasonably to have been anticipated or not, and in determining whether or not the consequences do naturally flow from the wrongful act or neglect, the case should be viewed retrospectively.24
Yes. Assuming the plaintiff did not voluntarily leave the train, the ejection at a point near Hoboes’ Hollow, which was known to be infested by tramps and questionable characters, at near nightfall, exposed the young girl to the very danger that occurred.25 The assaults were the natural consequences of placing her in that dangerous and unprotected place, and the carrier owed the highest degree of care to its passengers.26 It was sufficiently probable that such danger would overtake her under these circumstances.27