818 A.2d 669
Steven L. Henderson and Angela C. Henderson married in Colorado on August 16, 1985, and established their marital domicile in Missouri.1 Their three children were born during the marriage: Crystal Dawn in February 1986, Pamela Rene in April 1988, and Stephen Craig in October 1993.2 The couple separated in June 2000 due to irreconcilable differences.3
In October 2000, Steven moved to Rhode Island, and Stephen joined him there in December 2000. Pamela moved to Rhode Island to live with her father in March 2001.4 On May 31, 2001, Steven filed a complaint in Rhode Island Family Court seeking a divorce from bed and board.5 Angela responded on July 20, 2001, with a motion to dismiss the complaint for lack of jurisdiction.6
Steven also filed a motion for temporary orders on July 30, 2001, requesting sole custody of Pamela and Stephen, exclusive use of the marital domicile, and equitable distribution of assets.7 The Family Court held a hearing on October 12, 2001, and on October 22, 2001, the motion justice denied Angela's motion to dismiss and ordered that the children's current placement remain in effect.8
Angela filed a notice of appeal on November 6, 2001, and a petition for a writ of certiorari on November 9, 2001.9 The Rhode Island Supreme Court granted the petition for certiorari on October 10, 2002, consolidated it with the appeal, and proceeded to review the interlocutory order via certiorari after denying and dismissing the appeal.10
Whether Rhode Island has jurisdiction over a petition for divorce from bed and board filed by a domiciled inhabitant?11
Divorces from bed and board may be granted pursuant to G.L.1956 § 15-5-9. The statute requires that the petitioner be a domiciled inhabitant of this state and have resided in this state for a length of time that the court in its discretion seems to warrant the exercise of the conferred powers. Jurisdiction over such actions is quasi in rem and grounded in the power of states to adjudicate the legal status of their citizens regardless of the other spouse's minimum contacts.12
Yes. Steven L. Henderson moved to Rhode Island in October 2000 and resided there for close to a year before filing his complaint on May 31, 2001.13 The motion justice determined that this period of residence was sufficient to warrant exercise of the powers conferred by the statute.14 Although Angela C. Henderson lacks minimum contacts with Rhode Island, the petition concerns the plaintiff's marital and parental status as a domiciled inhabitant.15 Quasi in rem jurisdiction therefore permits Rhode Island to proceed without personal jurisdiction over the defendant.16
The Family Court properly denied the motion to dismiss on jurisdictional grounds.17 The statutory language requires only domicile of the petitioner, and the motion justice's discretionary finding on residence was not clearly wrong.18
Rhode Island has jurisdiction over the petition for divorce from bed and board.19
Whether the possibility of reconciliation is a prerequisite for granting a divorce from bed and board?20
The potential for reconciliation is not a prerequisite to obtain a legal separation.21 The General Assembly has given marriage partners an option of seeking an absolute divorce or a legal separation based upon the irreconcilable-differences ground, and differences thought to be irreconcilable at one time may later be resolved.22
No. Steven L. Henderson and Angela C. Henderson separated in June 2000 due to irreconcilable differences that led to the breakdown of their marriage.23 Steven filed for divorce from bed and board in May 2001.24 Even though the parties currently view reconciliation as improbable, the statute expressly permits a spouse to elect a bed-and-board divorce rather than an absolute divorce.25 The court has recognized that this option preserves the possibility of future reconciliation.26
The possibility of reconciliation is not a prerequisite for granting a divorce from bed and board.27
Whether the pendency of a Rhode Island divorce from bed and board action prevents a party from filing for an absolute divorce in Missouri?28
The pendency of a divorce petition in Rhode Island does not preclude one of the parties from instituting another divorce action in a foreign state.29 A valid foreign ex parte divorce divests the Family Court of jurisdiction over a Rhode Island divorce petition pending at the time the foreign divorce is entered.30
No. Angela C. Henderson has in fact filed for an absolute divorce in Missouri, and that action is now pending.31 Rhode Island law contains no authority that would bar her from pursuing the Missouri proceeding while the bed-and-board action remains pending in Rhode Island.32 The pendency of the Rhode Island petition therefore imposes no legal obstacle to the Missouri filing.33
The pendency of a Rhode Island divorce from bed and board action does not prevent a party from filing for an absolute divorce in Missouri.34
Whether Rhode Island has jurisdiction to determine custody and placement of the parties' children?35
Rhode Island has adopted the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction Act.36 A state's power to decide a custody matter depends on its ability to adjudicate matters concerning the status of its citizens through quasi in rem jurisdiction rather than on personal jurisdiction over the parties.37 Rhode Island has jurisdiction when it is the home state of the child at the time of commencement of the proceeding.38
Yes. Pamela moved to Rhode Island in March 2001 and Stephen joined his father there in December 2000.39 Both children were living in Rhode Island with Steven at the time he commenced the proceeding on May 31, 2001.40 Rhode Island is therefore their home state under the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction Act.41 The Family Court correctly exercised jurisdiction to order that the children's current placement remain in effect.42
Rhode Island has jurisdiction to determine custody and placement of the parties' children.43