225 N.C. 690, 36 S.E.2d 227
The plaintiff brought suit against the defendant seeking recovery on an oral promise.1 The defendant had assaulted his wife, who took refuge in the plaintiff's house. The next day the defendant gained access to the house and began another assault upon his wife. The defendant's wife knocked him down with an axe and was on the point of cutting his head open or decapitating him while he was lying on the floor.
The plaintiff intervened and caught the axe as it was descending. The blow intended for the defendant fell upon her hand, mutilating it badly but saving the defendant's life.2 Subsequently the defendant orally promised to pay the plaintiff her damages. After paying a small sum the defendant failed to pay anything more, as substantially stated in the complaint.3
The defendant demurred to the complaint as not stating a cause of action. The demurrer was sustained. The plaintiff appealed from the judgment sustaining the demurrer.4
Whether there was a consideration recognized by law as sufficient to support the defendant's oral promise to pay the plaintiff's damages?5
A humanitarian act of this kind, voluntarily performed, is not such consideration as would entitle the plaintiff to recover at law on the defendant's subsequent promise.6
No. The facts show that the plaintiff voluntarily intervened in the domestic assault by catching the axe wielded by the defendant's wife, thereby suffering mutilation to her hand while saving the defendant's life, without any prior bargain or request from the defendant. The defendant's later oral promise to pay damages, made out of gratitude after the event and partially performed, does not supply the consideration required because the humanitarian act was not induced by or exchanged for the promise. Consequently, the promise is unenforceable at law, confirming that the demurrer was properly sustained for failure to state a cause of action.7
The demurrer was correctly sustained as the complaint failed to state a cause of action for lack of consideration.8