199 Ill. 2d 179, 766 N.E.2d 1118 (2002)
On August 4, 1993, Heidi Happel telephoned the office of her physician, Dr. Zbigniew T. Lorenc, complaining of severe menstrual cramps and requesting a more effective pain reliever.1 Dr. Lorenc prescribed Toradol and had his office telephone the prescription to the Wal-Mart pharmacy in McHenry, Illinois.2 Dr. Lorenc had been treating Heidi since December 1992 and knew of her allergies to aspirin, acetaminophen, and ibuprofen, but he did not know at the time that Toradol was contraindicated for patients with such allergies.3
Prior to August 4, 1993, Heidi had visited the Wal-Mart pharmacy in McHenry approximately six times to have prescriptions filled.4 On each visit, pharmacy workers asked about her drug allergies, and she reported her allergies to aspirin, acetaminophen, and ibuprofen.5 This information was stored in the pharmacy’s computer system and was available to pharmacists on August 4, 1993.6 Wal-Mart pharmacy manager Steven Odes and pharmacist Florence Bowser both confirmed that the pharmacy’s policy was to ask customers about known allergies to alert pharmacists to potential drug interactions.7
On August 4, 1993, pharmacist Florence Bowser took the call from Dr. Lorenc’s office and recorded the Toradol prescription.8 Although Bowser did not recall filling the prescription, she was the only pharmacist on duty that day according to Odes.9 The pharmacy’s computer system would have generated a drug interaction warning for Toradol given Heidi’s allergies, requiring the pharmacist to contact the physician or override the system with a special code.10 Kent Happel picked up the prescription after confirming Heidi’s allergies to a pharmacy worker, but the bottle contained no warning about contraindications.11
Heidi took the first dose of Toradol around 4 p.m. on August 4, 1993, and within 40 minutes experienced respiratory problems and tightness in her chest.12 She contacted the pharmacy twice regarding a possible reaction but was told there should be no problem after the first call was disconnected. Heidi then consulted a pharmacist friend and went to the emergency room, where she was diagnosed with anaphylactic shock.13 As a result, she later experienced more frequent asthma attacks, seizures, and a worsening of her multiple sclerosis.14
On September 30, 1994, Heidi and Kent Happel filed a negligence action against Dr. Lorenc and Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.15 Plaintiffs settled with Dr. Lorenc on March 15, 1999.16 The trial court granted Wal-Mart’s motion for summary judgment on September 17, 1999.17 The appellate court reversed the summary judgment, and the Supreme Court of Illinois granted Wal-Mart’s petition for leave to appeal.18
Whether a pharmacy has a duty to warn about a known drug contraindication, where the pharmacy is aware of a customer’s drug allergies, and knows that the medication prescribed by the customer’s physician is contraindicated for a person with those allergies?19
Courts determine the existence of a duty by examining the reasonable foreseeability of injury, the likelihood of injury, the magnitude of the burden of guarding against injury, and the consequences of placing that burden on the defendant.20 A pharmacy owes a narrow duty to warn the prescribing physician or the patient of a known contraindication when it has patient-specific allergy information and knows the prescribed drug is contraindicated for that patient.21
Yes. Wal-Mart possessed Heidi Happel’s allergy information in its computer system and knew Toradol was contraindicated for patients allergic to aspirin and other NSAIDs.22 The failure to warn was reasonably foreseeable to cause injury, as Heidi suffered anaphylactic shock shortly after taking the first dose.23 The burden of making a telephone call to the physician or informing the patient is minimal, and Wal-Mart pharmacists had previously notified physicians about allergies once or twice a month.24
This duty does not require the pharmacist to learn the customer’s condition or interject into the doctor-patient relationship, distinguishing it from cases applying the learned intermediary doctrine to pharmacists.25
The pharmacy owed a duty to warn in these circumstances, and summary judgment was improper.26