792 A.2d 1145 (Md. 2002)
In June 1999, three-year-old Jordan Garris died two days after shooting himself in the head with a Ruger P89 semi-automatic pistol that belonged to his father, Clifton Garris.1 Jordan’s mother filed suit as petitioner against the pistol’s manufacturer, respondent Sturm, Ruger & Co., after dismissing her claims against the retailer On Target, Inc.2
The father had purchased the handgun from On Target in March 1999.3 With the purchase, Garris received an instruction manual with highlighted warnings to store firearms securely and unloaded away from children, a Youth Handgun Safety Act Notice from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, a lock box and padlock, and an offer for a free safety course that he declined.4 Garris signed an acknowledgment that the On Target salesperson had explained the instruction manual, the safety lever, and the action of the gun.5 There was a dispute in the affidavits about whether the retailer recommended that Garris also purchase a separate trigger lock.6
Garris stored the gun under his mattress and the loaded magazine on a bookshelf in the same room.7 Jordan found the gun and magazine, loaded the magazine into the gun based on knowledge gained from watching television, pulled the slide to chamber a round, and fired the weapon after the safety lever was in or moved to the fire position.8 The child was able to access the items because they were not secured in the provided lock box.9
The mother alleged in her complaint filed in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City that the gun was defective and unreasonably dangerous because it lacked child-resistant features such as a grip safety, heavy trigger-pull, child-resistant manual safety, built-in lock, trigger lock, or personalized gun technology.10 She attached an affidavit from a Johns Hopkins professor citing statistics on child gun deaths and unsafe storage practices by gun owners.11 The circuit court granted the manufacturer’s motion for summary judgment, a divided panel of the Court of Special Appeals affirmed, and the Court of Appeals granted further review.12
Whether Maryland courts should continue to apply the consumer expectation test or adopt a risk-utility analysis to evaluate design defect claims in strict liability actions involving handguns?13
Yes. The Court of Appeals applied the consumer expectation test from Kelley v. R.G. Industries to the Ruger P89 pistol purchased by Clifton Garris in March 1999.16 The gun performed exactly as designed when three-year-old Jordan Garris loaded the magazine, chambered a round, and fired it after accessing the unsecured weapon stored under a mattress and the loaded magazine on a bookshelf.17
Maryland courts continue to apply the consumer expectation test rather than adopting a risk-utility analysis for design defect claims involving handguns.18
Related opinions on this issue