45 Mich. 569, 8 N.W. 511 (1881)
In August 1874 John Headley entered into a written contract with Hackley & McGordon dated August 20 under which Headley agreed to cut on specified lands and deliver in the main Muskegon river the next spring 8,000,000 feet of logs.1 The logs were to be measured or scaled by a competent person selected by Hackley & McGordon in accordance with the standard rules or scales in general use on Muskegon lake and river, and the expense of scaling was to be mutually borne by the parties.2 Headley performed the labor of cutting, hauling, and delivering the logs, but the parties disagreed on the proper scaling standard and on payments claimed to have been made to others.3
At the time the contract was made scaling on the river and lake followed the Scribner rule, yet the Doyle rule was in general use when the logs were cut and delivered, producing a difference of some $2000 in the amount Headley would receive.4
On August 3, 1875, Headley traveled from his home in Kent county to Muskegon to collect the balance he claimed was due, upwards of $6200 by the Scribner scale.5 After an initial meeting Hackley offered a note for $4000, stating that was the best he would do and that Headley could sue if he wished.6 Headley replied that he could not afford to sue because he needed the money that day and would probably be ruined financially if he failed to obtain it, having made no other arrangements.7 He ultimately accepted the note and signed a receipt stating it was in full for all claims of every kind and nature against Hackley & McGordon.8
Headley later sued Hackley & McGordon in the circuit court to recover additional compensation.9 The defendants produced the receipt as evidence of a full settlement, but Headley contended it had been given under duress, and the jury returned a verdict in his favor.10
Whether the contract required scaling of the logs according to the Scribner rule in general use when the contract was made or the Doyle rule in general use when the logs were delivered?11
The contract specified that logs were to be scaled in accordance with the standard rules or scales in general use on Muskegon lake and river at the time scaling occurred.12
No. The contract was for the performance of labor in the future.13 Scaling was to be done by third persons using standards generally accepted at the time their services were called for.14 The evidence showed the Doyle rule was in general use when the logs were cut and delivered.15 The Scribner rule therefore did not govern the measurement.16
The contract required scaling of the logs according to the Doyle rule in general use when the logs were delivered.17
Whether the receipt signed by Headley on August 3, 1875, was obtained under duress?18
Duress exists when one by the unlawful act of another is induced to make a contract or perform some act under circumstances which deprive him of the exercise of free will.19 Duress of goods may exist when one is compelled to submit to an illegal exaction to obtain goods from one who has them in possession but refuses to surrender them unless the exaction is submitted to.20 Where the party threatens nothing which he has not a legal right to perform, there is no duress.21
No. Headley accepted the note for four thousand dollars and gave the receipt because he needed the money that day and would be ruined financially otherwise.22 Hackley and McGordon had not done anything to bring Headley to that condition or interfere with other funds due to him.23 They merely refused to pay more than they believed was due under their view of the contract.24 This withholding of their own debt even if Headley was in pecuniary straits does not constitute duress.25
The receipt signed by Headley on August 3, 1875, was not obtained under duress.26