364 U.S. 339 (1960)
In 1957, the Legislature of Alabama passed Local Act No. 140, which redefined the boundaries of the City of Tuskegee.1
The Act changed the city's shape from a square to a strangely irregular twenty-eight-sided figure.2
Petitioners, who were Negro citizens and residents of Tuskegee at the time, filed suit in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Alabama.3 They sought a declaratory judgment that the Act was unconstitutional and an injunction against its enforcement by the Mayor and officers of Tuskegee and Macon County officials.4
The complaint alleged that the boundary change removed all but four or five of the city's 400 Negro voters while removing no white voter or resident.5 This action was claimed to discriminate against Negro citizens in violation of the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments.6
The District Court granted the motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim.7 The Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit affirmed the judgment of dismissal.8 The Supreme Court granted certiorari to resolve serious questions concerning the power of a State over its municipalities in relation to the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments.9
Whether Local Act No. 140 violates the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment?10
The Due Process Clause affords no immunity against mere inequalities in tax burdens.11 It provides no protection against their increase as an indirect consequence of a State's exercise of its political powers.12 No constitutionally protected contractual obligation arises between a State and its subordinate governmental entities solely as a result of their relationship.13
No. The established facts show only that Act No. 140 redefined municipal boundaries by transforming Tuskegee into a twenty-eight-sided figure and removing nearly all Negro voters.14 The Hunter line of cases establishes that a State may consolidate or alter municipal boundaries without violating due process even when the change increases tax burdens on some residents.15 Petitioners alleged no impairment of contract and no specific property right beyond the general consequences of boundary change.16
Local Act No. 140 does not violate the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment on the allegations presented.17
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Whittaker concurred in the judgment but would have rested the decision on the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment rather than the Fifteenth Amendment.18 He was doubtful that the averments showed a purpose by the Act to abridge petitioners' right to vote in the Fifteenth Amendment sense.19 Whittaker reasoned that the right to vote guaranteed by the Fifteenth Amendment is the same right enjoyed by all others within the same election precinct or ward.20
He concluded that fencing Negro citizens out of one division and into another constitutes unlawful racial segregation in violation of equal protection.21
Whether Local Act No. 140 denies petitioners the right to vote in violation of the Fifteenth Amendment?22
Yes. The established facts allege that Act No. 140 transformed Tuskegee into an irregular twenty-eight-sided figure and removed all but four or five of its 400 Negro voters while removing no white voter or resident.25 These allegations demonstrate that the legislation is solely concerned with segregating white and colored voters by fencing Negro citizens out of town so as to deprive them of their pre-existing municipal vote.26 Such affirmative legislative action that singles out a racial minority for discriminatory withdrawal of the vote violates the Fifteenth Amendment.27
Local Act No. 140 denies petitioners the right to vote in violation of the Fifteenth Amendment.28
Whether a state's power to alter municipal boundaries is limited by the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments?29
Yes. The established facts show that Alabama exercised its power to redefine Tuskegee boundaries through Act No. 140 in a manner that removed nearly all Negro voters while sparing all white voters.32 Although a State possesses broad authority over its political subdivisions, that authority is met and overcome by the Fifteenth Amendment when used to deprive citizens of the vote because of race.33 The same principle that prevents impairment of contracts through municipal destruction likewise prevents circumvention of voting rights through boundary manipulation.34
A state's power to alter municipal boundaries is limited by the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments.35
Whether the claims present a justiciable controversy under the Fifteenth Amendment in light of Colegrove v. Green?36
A statute alleged to have worked unconstitutional deprivations of voting rights is not immune to attack simply because the mechanism employed is a redefinition of municipal boundaries.37 When a legislature singles out a racial minority for special discriminatory treatment it violates the Fifteenth Amendment and lifts the controversy out of the political arena.38
Yes. The established facts present affirmative legislative action that deprives petitioners of their votes through boundary redefinition rather than mere dilution from population shifts over many years as in Colegrove v. Green.39 Petitioners complain that the Act removes nearly all Negro voters from Tuskegee while leaving white voters untouched.40 These considerations distinguish the case from Colegrove and render the controversy justiciable under the Fifteenth Amendment.41
The claims present a justiciable controversy under the Fifteenth Amendment.42