439 U.S. 410 (1979)
Bessie Givhan served as a junior high English teacher for the Western Line Consolidated School District during the 1970-1971 school year.1 The school district was then operating under a desegregation order issued by the United States District Court for the Northern District of Mississippi.2 At the conclusion of that school year, the district elected not to renew Givhan's teaching contract.3
Givhan responded by filing a complaint in intervention within the ongoing desegregation litigation.4 She sought reinstatement, asserting both a violation of the Fifth Circuit's Singleton rule and an infringement of her First Amendment free speech rights.5 During the ensuing two-day bench trial, the school district presented evidence of multiple private meetings between Givhan and her school principal in which she allegedly voiced demands in an insulting, hostile, loud, and arrogant manner.6
The District Court determined that Givhan had advanced demands on only two occasions and that those demands concerned employment policies and practices she believed to be racially discriminatory.7 The court further found that the primary reason for the nonrenewal was Givhan's criticism of the school district's policies and practices.8 On that basis, the District Court ordered her reinstatement.9
The Fifth Circuit reversed the District Court's judgment.10 It concluded that the private character of Givhan's communications placed them outside First Amendment protection.11 While the appeal remained pending, this Court issued its decision in Mt. Healthy City Board of Education v. Doyle.12
The Fifth Circuit determined that the school district had not carried its burden of proving that the termination decision would have been made even without regard to Givhan's demands.13 The case then proceeded to this Court for review.14
Whether the First Amendment protects a public employee's private expression of views to her employer rather than to the public?15
The First Amendment protects the freedom of speech of public employees, and this protection is not forfeited when the employee chooses to express views privately to the employer instead of publicly.16 The balancing test established in Pickering v. Board of Education requires weighing the employee's interest in commenting on matters of public concern against the state's interest in promoting the efficiency of public services.17 The fact that the expression is private does not remove it from constitutional protection, although the manner and context may affect the balancing.18
Yes. The District Court found that Givhan's criticism of the school district's policies and practices was the primary reason for the failure to renew her contract.19 The school district introduced evidence of private encounters between Givhan and the principal in which she made demands in an insulting, hostile, loud, and arrogant manner.20 The Court of Appeals erred in concluding that the private character of the expression placed it outside First Amendment protection.21
The principal had opened his office door to Givhan, making him not an unwilling recipient of her views.22 The rule from Pickering applies to private expression as well as public expression.23
The First Amendment protects Givhan's private expression to the principal, and the judgment of the Court of Appeals is vacated on this ground.24
Whether the Court of Appeals could decide on the existing record that the school district failed to prove it would have reached the same termination decision absent the teacher's protected conduct?25
A public employee who demonstrates that constitutionally protected conduct played a substantial part in the employer's decision not to rehire shifts the burden to the employer.26 The employer must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that it would have reached the same decision even in the absence of the protected conduct.27 This is a factual determination that the district court must make.28 An appellate court cannot resolve it on a record where the trial court did not have the opportunity to apply the correct standard.29
No. The District Court found that the criticism was the primary reason for the nonrenewal but did not find that Givhan would have been rehired but for the criticism.30
The case was tried before the decision in Mt. Healthy, so the school district did not attempt to prove that the same decision would have been made absent the protected conduct.31 The Court of Appeals could not make the factual determination on the existing record and should have remanded for further proceedings.32
The case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with the Mt. Healthy standard.33
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Stevens concurred separately to address the Mt. Healthy issue.34 He noted that the District Court had found the protected conduct to be the primary reason and almost entirely responsible for the termination decision.35 The Court of Appeals treated that finding as foreclosing the school district's Mt. Healthy claim.36
Stevens agreed that the District Court should have the opportunity to decide whether further proceedings are needed on the issue.37 If the present record is adequate, the District Court remains free to supplement its original findings without taking additional evidence.38