329 S.E.2d 106 (W. Va. 1985)
Elizabeth Elana Gant and Frank Larry Gant were married on December 21, 1979, in Reno, Nevada.1 At the time of the marriage, Larry was approximately forty-seven years old and specialized in internal medicine, while Elana was about thirty-four years old and held a vocational nurse license in California along with a realtor license in Nevada.2 Both parties had prior marriages, with Larry having been married at least once and Elana three times previously.3 The couple had lived together in Reno for approximately one year before their wedding.4
Due to Larry's mental health difficulties, including severe depression, the couple moved to Charleston, West Virginia, so that Larry could complete a residency in psychiatry while receiving treatment.5 Their marriage featured numerous separations and reconciliations accompanied by physically violent fights, arguments, and other erratic behavior.6 On September 29, 1981, the parties executed a separation agreement providing for Larry to pay Elana $800 per month for twenty-four months, a $3,000 payment upon execution, and tuition for three semesters of nurse training.7 After signing the separation agreement, the parties reconciled for a short period before Elana initiated divorce proceedings in September 1982.8
Larry and Elana owned assets including a condominium in Reno with approximately $54,000 equity belonging to Larry, a boat, and personal property. Elana owned two horses, a silver-studded saddle, costly silver flatware, and had contributed $20,000 in cash to joint expenses at the outset of the marriage.9 The circuit court entered a pendente lite support order effective December 1, 1982, directing Larry to pay Elana $600 per month, $375 in monthly rent, and all reasonable family expenses incurred before October 1, 1982.10
On June 11, 1984, the circuit court found Larry in arrears and entered judgments totaling $7,850 for temporary support through May 1984 and $3,457.51 for additional amounts, each subject to a one-percent-per-day penalty until paid.11 On October 22, 1984, after three hearings before a commissioner, the circuit court issued its final decree addressing property division, support arrearages, and attorneys' fees.12 The final order invalidated the prenuptial agreement, enforced most of the separation agreement, awarded personal property in Elana's residence to her and stored property to Larry, denied Elana's dower claim, granted Larry title to the boat, preserved the prior arrearage judgments with penalties, and awarded Elana $4,552.50 in attorneys' fees plus $675.71 in costs.13 Larry appealed from the circuit court's orders to the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia.14
Whether the prenuptial agreement signed the day before the parties' marriage is valid and enforceable?15
Prenuptial agreements that establish property settlements and support obligations at the time of divorce are presumptively valid in West Virginia if validly procured without fraud, duress, or misrepresentation and entered into knowledgeably and voluntarily, with the burden on the challenging party.16 Courts will not evaluate substantive fairness unless the agreement is unconscionable under commercial contract principles.17 Enforcement occurs only to the extent that circumstances at the time the marriage ends are roughly what the parties foresaw when they signed it.18
Yes. Elizabeth Elana Gant and Frank Larry Gant were both middle-aged with prior marriages when they signed the prenuptial agreement the day before their December 21, 1979 marriage in Reno, Nevada.19 The agreement was valid under Nevada law.20 The record shows no overbearing behavior, fraud, or duress by Larry, and Elana had the opportunity to consult independent counsel though she did not.21
The divorce occurred only five years later, an eventuality the parties had foreseen, with no children or other unforeseen changes in position.22
The prenuptial agreement is valid and enforceable.23
Whether the circuit court's award of monthly payments to the wife after divorce constitutes alimony or an equitable distribution of property?24
Payments denominated as alimony but functioning as installment payments to recoup a share of marital property brought into the marriage, without any right to modification, constitute equitable distribution of property rather than traditional lifetime alimony subject to a prenuptial waiver.25
Yes. The circuit court awarded Elizabeth Elana Gant $650 per month for eighteen months totaling $11,700 after the divorce, which the court denominated alimony but which actually allowed her to recoup her share of marital property including the $20,000 cash she brought into the marriage along with furniture and other assets.26 The payments carried no right to modification and the court permitted use of the contempt power solely because of Frank Larry Gant's recalcitrance in paying prior obligations.27
The award constitutes an equitable distribution of property.28
Whether the circuit court had authority to impose a continuing one-percent-per-day penalty for nonpayment of temporary support obligations?29
A court lacks jurisdiction to impose a continuing one-percent-per-day penalty for nonpayment of temporary support.30 Such a penalty constitutes a criminal contempt fine payable to a private party without the procedural safeguards required for criminal contempt.31 The proper civil contempt remedy is incarceration until the contemnor purges the contempt by payment.32
No. On June 11, 1984 the circuit court entered judgments against Frank Larry Gant for $7,850 in temporary support arrears through May 1984 and $3,457.51 in additional amounts, each subject to a continuing one-percent-per-day penalty, and the final October 22, 1984 order expressly preserved those judgments and penalties in full force and effect.33
The circuit court lacked authority to impose the continuing one-percent-per-day penalty.34
Whether the award of attorneys' fees to the wife was proper?35
Yes. Most of the litigation in the Gant divorce was a direct result of Frank Larry Gant's litigious behavior and his willful resistance to court orders concerning temporary support and other obligations.38 The circuit court awarded Elizabeth Elana Gant $4,552.50 in attorneys' fees plus $675.71 in costs in addition to an earlier $300 award.39
The award of attorneys' fees to the wife was proper.40