217 Tenn. 400, 398 S.W.2d 240 (1966)
The plaintiff, a farmer who had previously found Ford tractors satisfactory, visited dealerships in Brownsville and Jackson, Tennessee, in early 1962 to obtain a large tractor with specific features including live power take-off.1 At these dealerships he obtained and read sales brochures describing the Fordson Major Diesel tractor and its specifications.2
Subsequently, the plaintiff discussed the purchase with Lon Lindsey, manager of Haywood Tractor Company, and mechanic Marcial Overton, whose statements were drawn from Ford sales literature supplied by the distributor Dealers Tractor & Equipment Company.3 In February 1962 the plaintiff purchased the tractor from Haywood Tractor Company for approximately $4,243.10 without a written warranty, at a time when Ford Motor Company was conducting extensive advertising of its products in farm magazines, on television, and other media.4
After the purchase, an experienced operator began using the tractor, but mechanical defects appeared on the second or third day, including failure of the power lift, malfunction of the live power take-off, repeated clutch failures, and continuous oil leakage from the crankshaft that could not be corrected.5 Ford field representative Ray Lambert assisted in repair attempts, and company representatives acknowledged similar problems with other tractors of the same model, resulting in the plaintiff losing many days of field work during the planting season.6
The plaintiff then sued Ford Motor Company, Dealers Tractor & Equipment Company, and Haywood Tractor Company.7 At trial the jury awarded $4,000 in damages against Ford Motor Company and returned verdicts in favor of the other two defendants.8
Ford Motor Company and the plaintiff appealed.9 The Court of Appeals reversed and remanded for a new trial due to an inconsistent verdict, prompting Ford to petition for certiorari on lack of privity and Haywood Tractor Company to petition on the inconsistency issue.10 The Supreme Court of Tennessee granted certiorari.11
Whether the manufacturer of a product that has been found to be seriously defective and unsuitable for use should be liable for a resulting commercial loss to the purchaser where there are no direct contractual relations between the purchaser and the manufacturer, in a situation where the purchaser has relied on the manufacturer’s booklets and tradename in making the purchase?12
Under the misrepresentation theory developed in 2 Restatement (Second) Torts sec. 402B and the parallel rule for pecuniary loss, one engaged in the business of selling chattels who, by advertising or labels, makes to the public a misrepresentation of material fact concerning the character or quality of a chattel is subject to liability for pecuniary loss caused to a purchaser by justifiable reliance on the misrepresentation, even though it is not made fraudulently or negligently and even though the purchaser has not bought the chattel from or entered into any contractual relation with the seller.13
Yes. The plaintiff obtained and read Ford sales brochures describing the live power take-off, power steering lift, and full specifications of the Fordson Major Diesel tractor, discussed the purchase with the retailer whose statements were based on Ford literature supplied by the distributor, and purchased the tractor in February 1962 for approximately $4,243.10 in reliance on those representations; the tractor developed uncorrectable defects in the power lift, live power take-off, and crankshaft oil seal on the second or third day of use by an experienced operator, causing loss of field work during planting season, and Ford representatives acknowledged identical problems on other tractors of the same model.14
The manufacturer is liable for the purchaser's commercial loss resulting from justifiable reliance on the manufacturer's public misrepresentations even without privity of contract.15
Whether a verdict holding the manufacturer liable while exonerating the immediate retailer is inconsistent so as to require reversal and remand for a new trial?16
A verdict against the manufacturer and in favor of the retailer is not inconsistent when liability rests on the manufacturer's own public misrepresentations through sales literature. The jury may reasonably conclude that the retailer acted merely as a conduit for those representations and that the purchaser's primary reliance was on the more extensive and detailed statements in the manufacturer's brochures rather than on any oral statements by the retailer.17
No. The jury could reasonably have found from the evidence that the retailer Haywood Tractor Company and its manager Lon Lindsey merely transmitted information from Ford sales literature supplied by distributor Dealers Tractor & Equipment Company.18 The only substantial reliance was on the manufacturer's representations, and the manufacturer's brochures contained more extensive and detailed statements than any oral representations by the retailer.19
The verdict holding Ford Motor Company liable while exonerating Haywood Tractor Company and Dealers Tractor & Equipment Company is not inconsistent and does not require reversal.20
Whether the damages awarded were excessive?21
Damages in a misrepresentation action include the difference between the actual value of the product and its value as represented, together with consequential damages proximately resulting from the defectiveness of the product.22
No. The plaintiff testified without contradiction that the defective tractor was worth only $1,000 at the time of purchase rather than the $4,243.10 paid.23 The record shows additional unrefuted losses from oil leakage, time spent by the plaintiff and employees attempting repairs, and lost field time during critical planting periods, supporting the jury's award of $4,000.24
The damages awarded are not excessive.25