427 U.S. 445 (1976)
Present and retired male employees of the State of Connecticut sued in the United States District Court for the District of Connecticut on behalf of all present and retired male employees of the State.1
Their amended complaint asserted that provisions in the State’s statutory retirement benefit plan discriminated against them because of their sex and therefore contravened Title VII of the 1964 Act.2 Title VII had been amended in 1972 to bring the States within its purview.3 The District Court held that the Connecticut State Employees Retirement Act violated Title VII’s prohibition against sex-based employment discrimination.4 It entered prospective injunctive relief in petitioners’ favor against respondent state officials.5
Petitioners also sought an award of retroactive retirement benefits as compensation for losses caused by the State’s discrimination.6 They further sought a reasonable attorney’s fee as part of the costs.7 The District Court held that both requests would constitute recovery of money damages from the State’s treasury and were therefore precluded by the Eleventh Amendment and by this Court’s decision in Edelman v. Jordan.8
On petitioners’ appeal the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed in part and reversed in part.9 It agreed that the action insofar as it seeks damages is in essence against the state and as such is subject to the Eleventh Amendment.10 The Court of Appeals found that under the 1972 Amendments to Title VII Congress intended to authorize a private suit for backpay by state employees against the state.11 It held that a private federal action for retroactive damages is not a constitutionally permissible method of enforcing Fourteenth Amendment rights.12 The Court of Appeals reversed the District Court and remanded as to attorneys’ fees.13 It reasoned that such an award would have only an ancillary effect on the state treasury.14 The Supreme Court granted certiorari to resolve this important constitutional question.15
Whether Congress has the power under section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment to authorize federal courts to award money damages in favor of a private individual against a state government found to have subjected that person to employment discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin?16
The Fourteenth Amendment quite clearly contemplates limitations on state authority.17 Section 5 grants Congress the power to enforce the provisions of the Amendment by appropriate legislation.18 When Congress acts pursuant to section 5, it is exercising legislative authority that is plenary within the terms of the constitutional grant.19 Congress may provide for private suits against states or state officials which are constitutionally impermissible in other contexts.20
Yes. The 1972 Amendments to Title VII were enacted pursuant to section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment to extend coverage to the States as employers.21 Present and retired male employees of the State of Connecticut sued in the United States District Court for the District of Connecticut.22 They asserted that the State's statutory retirement benefit plan discriminated against them because of their sex and therefore contravened Title VII.23 The District Court held that the Connecticut State Employees Retirement Act violated Title VII's prohibition against sex-based employment discrimination. It entered prospective injunctive relief.
Petitioners also sought retroactive retirement benefits as compensation for losses caused by the State's discrimination.24 The suit for retroactive benefits is indistinguishable from that in Edelman v. Jordan.25 It seeks a damages award payable from the state treasury.26 Nevertheless the threshold fact of congressional authorization to sue the State as employer is present under the 1972 Amendments.27 The substantive provisions of the Fourteenth Amendment are directed at the States.28 They impose duties with respect to their treatment of private individuals.29 Congress may enforce those duties by authorizing private actions for money damages against the State.30
Congress possesses the constitutional power under section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment to authorize the Title VII damages action against the State.31
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Brennan concurred in the judgment.32 He concluded that Connecticut may not assert sovereign immunity.33 The States surrendered that immunity in the plan of the Convention that formed the Union.34
This surrender applies at least insofar as the States granted Congress specifically enumerated powers.35 Congressional authority to enact the provisions of Title VII at issue is found in the Commerce Clause and in section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment.36 Because of its surrender, no immunity exists that can be the subject of a congressional declaration or a voluntary waiver.37
Justice Stevens concurred in the judgment but questioned whether section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment provides adequate support.38 He was not sure that the 1972 Amendments were needed to secure the guarantees of the Fourteenth Amendment.39 He would reject the Eleventh Amendment defense for a different reason.40
Even if the Amendment covers a citizen's suit against his own State, it does not bar an action against state officers enforcing an invalid statute under Ex parte Young.41 Since the Connecticut pension law has been held invalid at least in part, the federal court properly acquired jurisdiction.42 The award from separate pension funds does not sufficiently distinguish this case from others in which a State must conform its practices to the Constitution and incur additional expense.43
Whether the Eleventh Amendment bars an award of attorneys' fees in a Title VII action against state officials when the fees would be paid out of the state treasury?44
Given the express congressional authority for an award of attorneys' fees in a case brought under Title VII, Congress' exercise of power under section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment is not barred by the Eleventh Amendment.45 An award of attorneys' fees falls within the same authorization that permits the underlying damages action.46
No. The Court of Appeals had reversed the District Court and remanded as to attorneys' fees.47 It reasoned that such an award would have only an ancillary effect on the state treasury of the kind permitted under Edelman.48 The holding establishes that Congress has the power under section 5 to authorize private suits for money damages against the State in Title VII actions. It follows that Congress' exercise of power with respect to attorneys' fees is also not barred by the Eleventh Amendment.
The state officials' cross-petition therefore fails.49
The Eleventh Amendment does not bar an award of attorneys' fees in this Title VII action against state officials.50
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Stevens addressed the fee issue separately.51 Even if the Eleventh Amendment were applicable, he would place fees in the same category as other litigation costs.52 He would reject the Eleventh Amendment defense because the award will not be paid directly from the state treasury but rather from two separate and independent pension funds.53
This approach aligns with the rationale of Ex parte Young. The holding in Edelman does not squarely cover the situation where reimbursement from general revenues occurs only as a future consequence of compliance. Stevens therefore concluded that the fee award is permissible without violating the Eleventh Amendment.