567 U.S. 239 (2012)
In 2002 Fox Television Stations, Inc. broadcast the Billboard Music Awards during which singer Cher made an unscripted remark containing the F-word.1 The following year Fox broadcast the same awards show during which presenter Nicole Richie made unscripted remarks containing the S-word and the F-word.2
In February 2003, ABC Television Network aired an episode of NYPD Blue that depicted an adult female character’s nude buttocks for approximately seven seconds and the side of her breast for a moment while a child character entered the bathroom.3 The Commission had received complaints about all three broadcasts.4
Before issuing notices of apparent liability to Fox and ABC, the Commission released the Golden Globes Order.5 The order sanctioned NBC for Bono’s fleeting use of the F-word during the 2003 Golden Globe Awards and reversed prior precedent that had treated isolated expletives as non-actionable.6 The Commission then applied its revised approach to the Fox and ABC incidents and found each broadcast indecent.7
For the Fox broadcasts the Commission issued an order finding violations but imposed no forfeiture.8 Fox and intervenors challenged the order in the Second Circuit, which held the policy change arbitrary and capricious.9 The Supreme Court in Fox I upheld the administrative change as rational and remanded for consideration of the constitutional claims.10 On remand the Second Circuit held the indecency policy unconstitutionally vague.11
For the NYPD Blue episode the Commission issued a forfeiture order imposing $27,500 on each of forty-five ABC-affiliated stations.12 The Second Circuit vacated the order in a summary decision relying on its Fox ruling.13 The Supreme Court granted certiorari in both cases.14
Whether the Federal Communications Commission provided Fox Television Stations, Inc., and ABC Television Network with fair notice prior to the 2002 and 2003 broadcasts that fleeting expletives and a brief display of nudity could be found actionably indecent under 18 U.S.C. § 1464?15
A fundamental principle in our legal system is that laws which regulate persons or entities must give fair notice of conduct that is forbidden or required.16 This requirement of clarity in regulation is essential to the protections provided by the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment.17 It requires the invalidation of laws that are impermissibly vague.18 A conviction or punishment fails to comply with due process if the statute or regulation under which it is obtained fails to provide a person of ordinary intelligence fair notice of what is prohibited, or is so standardless that it authorizes or encourages seriously discriminatory enforcement.19
Even when speech is not at issue, the void for vagueness doctrine addresses at least two connected but discrete due process concerns.20 First, regulated parties should know what is required of them so they may act accordingly.21 Second, precision and guidance are necessary so that those enforcing the law do not act in an arbitrary or discriminatory way.22 When speech is involved, rigorous adherence to those requirements is necessary to ensure that ambiguity does not chill protected speech.23
No. The regulatory history makes it apparent that the Commission policy in place at the time of the broadcasts gave no notice to Fox or ABC that a fleeting expletive or a brief shot of nudity could be actionably indecent.24 Under the 2001 guidelines in force when the broadcasts occurred, a key consideration was whether the material dwelled on or repeated at length the offending description or depiction.25 In the 2004 Golden Globes Order, issued after the broadcasts, the Commission changed course and held that fleeting expletives could be a statutory violation.26 In the challenged orders now under review, the Commission applied the new principle promulgated in the Golden Globes Order and determined fleeting expletives and a brief moment of indecency were actionably indecent.27
As for the two fleeting expletives, the Government concedes that Fox did not have reasonable notice at the time of the broadcasts that the Commission would consider non-repeated expletives indecent.28 With respect to ABC, an isolated and ambiguous statement from a 1960 Commission decision does not suffice for the fair notice required when the Government intends to impose over a $1 million fine for allegedly impermissible speech.29 The Commission had released decisions before sanctioning ABC that declined to find isolated and brief moments of nudity actionably indecent.30 In light of this record of agency decisions and the absence of any notice in the 2001 guidance that seven seconds of nude buttocks would be found indecent, ABC lacked constitutionally sufficient notice prior to being sanctioned.31
The Commission failed to give Fox or ABC fair notice prior to the broadcasts in question that fleeting expletives and momentary nudity could be found actionably indecent.32 Therefore, the Commission’s standards as applied to these broadcasts were vague, and the Commission’s orders must be set aside.33
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Ginsburg wrote separately to express her view that the Court’s decision in FCC v. Pacifica Foundation was wrong when it issued.34 She observed that time, technological advances, and the Commission’s untenable rulings in the cases now before the Court show why Pacifica bears reconsideration.35