279 U.S. 438 (1929)
The Tariff Act of 1922 included section 316.1 Section 316 authorizes the Tariff Commission to investigate allegations of unfair methods of competition and unfair acts in the importation of articles into the United States and in their sale after importation.2 The Bakelite Corporation filed a sworn complaint with the Tariff Commission charging unfair methods and acts in the importation and subsequent sale of certain articles.3 The complaint alleged a resulting injury to its domestic business of manufacturing and selling similar articles.4
The commission entertained the complaint.5 It gave public notice and conducted a hearing in which interested importers appeared and presented evidence.6 The commission made findings sustaining the charge and recommended that the articles to which the unfair practice related be excluded from entry.7
The importers appealed to the Court of Customs Appeals.8 In that court the Bakelite Corporation challenged the court's jurisdiction on constitutional grounds.9 The Court of Customs Appeals upheld its jurisdiction and announced its purpose to entertain the appeal.10 The Bakelite Corporation then presented to the Supreme Court its petition for a writ of prohibition.11
The Supreme Court issued a rule to show cause.12 A return was made to the rule.13 A hearing has been had on the petition and return.14 Pending a decision on the petition further proceedings on the appeal have been suspended.15
Whether the Court of Customs Appeals is an inferior court created by Congress under Article III of the Constitution?16
Article III of the Constitution vests the judicial power of the United States in constitutional courts.17 These courts share in the exercise of the judicial power defined in section 2.18 They can be invested with no other jurisdiction.19 Their judges hold office during good behavior.20 Congress possesses authority under other articles to create legislative courts.21 The functions of these legislative courts are directed to the execution of enumerated powers such as the power to lay and collect duties on imports.22 These legislative courts may be clothed with functions that do not require judicial determination.23 Their judges hold office for such terms as Congress prescribes.24
No. The Court of Customs Appeals was created by Congress in virtue of its power to lay and collect duties on imports and to adopt any appropriate means of carrying that power into execution.25 The full province of the court under the act creating it is that of determining matters arising between the Government and others in the executive administration and application of the customs laws.26 These matters are brought before it by appeals from decisions of the Customs Court, formerly called the Board of General Appraisers.27 The appeals include nothing which inherently or necessarily requires judicial determination, but only matters the determination of which may be, and at times has been, committed exclusively to executive officers.28
In the present case the appeal arises from findings of the Tariff Commission in a proceeding under section 316 of the Tariff Act of 1922.29 The Bakelite Corporation filed a sworn complaint with the Tariff Commission charging unfair methods and acts in the importation and subsequent sale of articles.30 The commission made findings sustaining the charge and recommended exclusion from entry.31 The importers appealed to the Court of Customs Appeals. This proceeding forms part of the executive administration of the customs laws and is susceptible of performance by executive officers.32 The Court of Customs Appeals therefore functions as a legislative court rather than a constitutional court under Article III.33
The distinction between the two classes of courts turns on the power under which the court was created and the jurisdiction conferred rather than on any declaration by Congress respecting tenure of judges.34 Features such as the absence of a tenure provision or provisions for temporary assignments of other judges do not alter the legislative character of the Court of Customs Appeals.35
The Court of Customs Appeals is a legislative court created under Congress's power to regulate imports and is not an Article III constitutional court.36
Whether the proceeding presented by the appeal from the Tariff Commission under section 316 of the Tariff Act of 1922 is a case or controversy within the meaning of Article III?37
Section 2 of Article III extends the judicial power only to cases and controversies of enumerated classes and applies exclusively to constitutional courts established under Article III.38 Legislative courts created under other constitutional powers may be invested with jurisdiction over proceedings that are not cases or controversies within the meaning of Article III, including advisory proceedings in aid of executive action.39
No. Because the Court of Customs Appeals is a legislative court, section 2 of Article III does not restrict its jurisdiction.40 The proceeding under section 316 of the Tariff Act of 1922 involves an appeal from findings and recommendations of the Tariff Commission.41 Those findings assist the President in deciding whether to impose additional duties or exclude articles from entry.42 The Bakelite Corporation filed the complaint.43 The commission conducted a hearing and made findings.44 The importers appealed.45 This proceeding is merely an advisory step in the executive process of administering the customs laws and does not require judicial determination.46 Legislative courts may receive jurisdiction over such matters even when they would fall outside the admissible jurisdiction of constitutional courts.47
The Court of Customs Appeals may therefore entertain the appeal without regard to whether the proceeding qualifies as a case or controversy under Article III.48 The Supreme Court need not decide that classification because the legislative status of the court removes any constitutional barrier.49
The proceeding under section 316 need not constitute a case or controversy within the meaning of Article III because the Court of Customs Appeals is a legislative court.50
Whether the Supreme Court has power to issue a writ of prohibition to the Court of Customs Appeals to arrest the proceedings on the appeal?51
The power of the Supreme Court to issue writs of prohibition has never been clearly defined by statute or decision, and its existence in a given situation is not free from doubt.52 Even assuming the power exists, a writ of prohibition does not lie to a court that is proceeding within the limits of its jurisdiction.53
No. Assuming the power to issue a writ of prohibition exists, there is no tenable basis for exercising it in this instance.54 The Court of Customs Appeals is a legislative court that has been validly invested with jurisdiction over the appeal from the Tariff Commission findings under section 316 of the Tariff Act of 1922.55 The Bakelite Corporation challenged jurisdiction in that court on constitutional grounds.56 The court upheld its jurisdiction.57 The Bakelite Corporation then sought prohibition from the Supreme Court.58 Because the Court of Customs Appeals is acting within the limits of its jurisdiction, a writ of prohibition does not lie.59
The Supreme Court therefore denies the petition without resolving the underlying question of its own power to issue the writ in this context.60 The rule to show cause was issued.61 A return was made.62 A hearing was held.63 Yet the petition fails on the merits of the jurisdictional claim.64
The Supreme Court lacks a basis to issue a writ of prohibition because the Court of Customs Appeals is proceeding within its jurisdiction as a legislative court.65