43 N.Y. 502 (1871)
The plaintiff's intestate observed a small child standing on the railroad track directly in the path of an approaching train that was visible from a distance.1 Realizing that the child would be crushed if not immediately rescued, the deceased entered the track in an attempt to save the child from the rapidly moving train.2
The defendant was operating its train at a high rate of speed in a negligent manner as it approached the location.3 The intestate's attempt to rescue the child placed him directly in the path of the train, and he was struck and killed as a result.4
At trial in the City Court of Brooklyn, the defendant moved for a nonsuit.5 The motion was made at the close of the evidence on the ground that the negligence of the plaintiff's intestate contributed to the injury that caused his death.6 The trial court denied the motion.7 The case then proceeded to a jury verdict in favor of the plaintiff.8
Judgment was entered for the plaintiff.9 The Supreme Court and the City Court of Brooklyn affirmed the judgment.10 The defendant appealed the judgment to the Court of Appeals.11
Whether the negligence of the plaintiff's intestate contributed to the injury that caused his death?12
Negligence implies some act of commission or omission wrongful in itself.13 The law has so high a regard for human life that it will not impute negligence to an effort to preserve it, unless made under such circumstances as to constitute rashness in the judgment of prudent persons.14 When the exposure is for the purpose of saving life, it is not wrongful, and therefore not negligent unless such as to be regarded either rash or reckless.15
No. The evidence showed that the train was approaching in plain view of the deceased.16 There was a small child upon the track who if not rescued must have been inevitably crushed by the rapidly approaching train.17 This the deceased saw, and he entered the track to attempt a rescue.18 The deceased had no time for deliberation.19
He must act instantly if at all as a moment's delay would have been fatal to the child.20 Under these facts the jury were warranted in finding the deceased free from negligence under the rule as above stated.21
The negligence of the plaintiff's intestate did not contribute to the injury that caused his death.22
Whether the trial court properly denied the defendant's motion for a nonsuit on the ground of contributory negligence?23
The motion for a nonsuit upon the ground that the negligence of the plaintiff's intestate contributed to the injury that caused his death is properly denied when the jury could find the deceased free from negligence.24 This occurs because his exposure was for the purpose of saving life and not rash or reckless.25
Yes. The defendant moved for a nonsuit upon the ground that the negligence of the plaintiff's intestate contributed to the injury that caused his death.26 The motion was denied by the trial court and the case proceeded to a jury verdict in favor of the plaintiff.27 Judgment was entered for the plaintiff and affirmed by the Supreme Court and the City Court of Brooklyn.28 Upon the facts showing the rescue attempt the motion for a nonsuit was properly denied.29
The trial court properly denied the defendant's motion for a nonsuit on the ground of contributory negligence.30