123 N.J. Super. 48, 301 A.2d 463 (1973)
Dwyer had been a tenant for 15 years in a multiple-family garden apartment development owned by Skyline Apartments, Inc. On February 8, 1971, she was in the bathtub of her apartment when she turned on the hot water faucet.1 As a result, the entire fixture came out of the tile, and scalding water gushed out of the pipe, causing burns to her body.2
The testimony presented at trial was limited to that of the plaintiff.3 She described the faucet after it came out of the wall as very corroded.4 However, the corrosion was on the portion of the faucet which was in the wall, so she had no idea of its condition prior to the accident, and no complaint was ever made to the landlord.5 The defect was therefore latent and unknown to both the tenant and the landlord, and not discernible on reasonable inspection.6
After a trial without a jury, a judge of the Bergen County District Court entered judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $1,500.7 Defendant appeals from that judgment.8 The matter was argued on January 29, 1973, and decided on March 8, 1973, by Judges Carton, Mintz and Larner, with the opinion authored by Larner, A.J.S.C., temporarily assigned.9
Whether a landlord may be held liable for personal injuries sustained by a tenant as a result of a latent defect in the leased premises without proof of actual or constructive notice of the condition?10
A landlord of a multiple-family dwelling has the duty to maintain all parts of the structure and equipment in good repair, including the premises within the confines of the tenant's apartment.11 This duty arises under the Hotel and Multiple Dwelling Act and the theory of control over integral facilities such as water pipes and faucets.12 Nevertheless, the nexus between duty and liability is proof of negligence.13 Negligence requires not only proof of the condition that caused the injury but also that the condition was known or should have been known by the landlord prior to the occurrence so that he had an opportunity to correct it.14 A landlord is liable only for injurious consequences arising from defects of which the landlord has knowledge or that have existed for so long a time that the landlord had both an opportunity to discover and to remedy them.15 An exception exists only where the landlord created the condition.16
No. The established facts demonstrate that Dwyer had been a tenant for fifteen years in the multiple-family garden apartment development owned by Skyline Apartments, Inc. On February 8, 1971, while turning on the hot water faucet in her bathtub, the entire fixture came out of the tile, allowing scalding water to gush from the pipe and burn her body.17 Plaintiff Dwyer testified that the faucet appeared very corroded after the incident.18 Yet the corrosion lay on the portion inside the wall.19 This rendered the defect latent and unknown to both the tenant and the landlord, and not discernible on reasonable inspection.20 No complaint had ever been made to Skyline Apartments, Inc.21 The trial court entered judgment for Dwyer in the amount of $1,500 after a bench trial.22 The Appellate Division reviewed the record and found that the proofs established beyond dispute that the defect was latent and not reasonably discoverable by the defendant.23 Because the landlord's duty requires only the exercise of reasonable care rather than insurance of tenant safety, and because the facts show neither actual nor constructive notice, Skyline Apartments, Inc. cannot be held liable under settled negligence principles.24
The mere happening of the event resulting from a latent defect does not impose liability absent the traditional elements of negligence.25 The court therefore reversed the judgment and directed entry of judgment for the defendant.26
A landlord may not be held liable for personal injuries sustained by a tenant as a result of a latent defect in the leased premises without proof of actual or constructive notice of the condition.27
Whether the implied covenant of habitability articulated in Marini v. Ireland eliminates the requirement of proving negligence for a tenant's personal injury claim against a landlord arising from the condition of the premises?28
The implied covenant of habitability recognized in Marini v. Ireland provides that at the inception of the lease there are no latent defects in facilities vital to the use of the premises for residential purposes.29 These facilities will remain in usable condition during the entire term of the lease.30 In performance of this covenant the landlord must maintain those facilities in a condition that renders the property livable.31 The mutual dependence of this covenant and the tenant's covenant to pay rent permits the tenant either to make repairs and deduct the cost from future rents or to remove from the premises upon constructive eviction.32 This remedy is available only after timely and adequate notice to the landlord.33 Marini addressed the narrow context of summary dispossess actions and the protection of tenants facing uninhabitable premises.34 It did not overturn existing principles of tort liability for personal injuries.35
No. The facts establish that Dwyer suffered burns when a corroded faucet fixture detached inside the wall of her apartment on February 8, 1971, yet the defect remained unknown to Skyline Apartments, Inc. and not reasonably discoverable.36 Although Marini v. Ireland imposes an implied covenant of habitability that is mutually dependent with the obligation to pay rent, that holding was confined to eviction proceedings and the availability of self-help remedies or constructive eviction.37 The subsequent cases applying Marini likewise addressed only the sphere of eviction and its social consequences.38 The language in Marini was not intended to eliminate the requirement of proving negligence, including notice, in a tort action for personal injuries.39
If the covenant of habitability is to be extended to create strict tort liability, that determination lies with the Supreme Court rather than an intermediate appellate court.40 Application of the facts of Dwyer's latent defect and the absence of any notice to Skyline Apartments, Inc. therefore leaves the traditional negligence standard intact.41
The implied covenant of habitability articulated in Marini v. Ireland does not eliminate the requirement of proving negligence for a tenant's personal injury claim against a landlord arising from the condition of the premises.42
Whether the strict liability doctrine applied to manufacturers, sellers, and mass builders of homes extends to impose liability without fault upon the owner of a multiple-family apartment building for injuries to tenants?43
Strict liability has been imposed upon sellers and manufacturers of products, mass builder-vendors of real estate, and lessors of motor vehicles because those parties place a product into the stream of commerce.44 A landlord is not engaged in mass production whereby he places his product — the apartment — in a stream of commerce exposing it to a large number of consumers.45 He has not created the product with a defect which is preventable by greater care at the time of manufacture or assembly.46 He does not have the expertise to know and correct the condition, so as to be saddled with responsibility for a defect regardless of negligence.47 An apartment involves several rooms with many facilities constructed by many artisans with differing types of expertise, and subject to constant use and deterioration from many causes.48 It is a commodity wholly unlike a product which is expected to leave the manufacturer's hands in a safe condition with an implied representation upon which the consumer justifiably relies.49 The policy considerations underlying the adoption of strict liability in areas already determined by the Supreme Court are non-existent in the landlord-tenant relationship involved herein.50
No. Dwyer resided for fifteen years in the garden apartment development owned by Skyline Apartments, Inc. When the latent corrosion caused the bathtub fixture to detach on February 8, 1971, the resulting injury occurred without any evidence that Skyline had created the defect or possessed superior expertise to detect it.51 Skyline Apartments, Inc. is not engaged in mass production that places apartments into a stream of commerce in the manner of a manufacturer or mass builder-vendor.52 The apartment comprises multiple rooms and facilities assembled by many artisans and subject to ongoing deterioration, rendering it unlike a product expected to remain safe throughout its life.53 Imposing strict liability would require the landlord to prevent or repair every latent defect in every part of the building regardless of foreseeability or notice.54 This would create an unjust burden unsupported by the policy rationales that justified strict liability in product and mass-housing cases.55
The facts of the unknown, non-discoverable corrosion therefore do not trigger strict liability.56
The strict liability doctrine applied to manufacturers, sellers, and mass builders of homes does not extend to impose liability without fault upon the owner of a multiple-family apartment building for injuries to tenants.57