401 Ill. App. 3d 367 (2010)
The plaintiffs Larry Dobbs, Frances Dobbs, Wayne Richard, and Lorena Richard have lived on their properties along the dead-end road Triton Lane in rural Jefferson County, Illinois, for approximately thirty years.1 The defendant Donald Wiggins purchased the parcel directly south of the Dobbs property in 1995, constructed a home and dog kennels, and began raising, training, and kenneling bird dogs, initially keeping fifty to seventy dogs and later increasing the total to as many as one hundred.2 The plaintiffs filed their complaint on November 19, 2007, alleging that barking from the dogs on Wiggins's property constituted a private nuisance and requesting an injunction either prohibiting the kenneling or reducing the number of dogs while suppressing the noise.3
During the two-day bench trial that began on April 15, 2009, Larry Dobbs testified that his house stood two hundred to two hundred fifty yards from Wiggins's barn and that the dogs barked constantly day and night with only brief interruptions, a condition that reached its worst in 2007 and prevented him from enjoying outdoor activities or keeping windows open.4 Frances Dobbs, Wayne Richard, and Lorena Richard gave parallel accounts of continuous barking, whining, and howling audible inside their homes that forced them to curtail gardening, barbecues, reading on decks, and other outdoor pursuits while also requiring them to close windows and use radios or televisions to mask the sound.5 Additional witnesses included longtime neighbor Mary McKowen who heard the barking during frequent 2007 visits to the Dobbs home, neighbor Charles Downey who described the noise as annoying at the Dobbs property, contractor Randy Phillips who worked at the Dobbs residence for three and a half months and heard barking throughout each day, and mail carrier Randy Childers who recalled no noise during his brief daily stops.67
Wiggins testified that he had spoken with Larry Dobbs hundreds of times over the years and that Dobbs had always stated the dogs were not a problem until the August 11, 2007 conversation, after which Wiggins implemented noise-reduction steps including rotating bark collars, automatic water sprinklers, training muzzles, playing the radio, installing electronic silencers, and storing hay bales along the property line.8 On February 16, 2009, the parties inspected the kennels and counted a total of sixty-nine dogs; veterinarian Gordon Rhine examined the facilities for forty-five minutes to an hour and described them as clean with the dogs appearing healthy and happy.9 Jefferson County animal control officer Martin Boykin visited the area in January 2008 in response to a separate complaint and, during a half-hour conversation near the property line, found the barking neither loud nor disturbing.10
On July 21, 2009, the circuit court of Jefferson County entered judgment for the plaintiffs ordering Wiggins to reduce his dogs to no more than six, to kennel them only in the southern region of his property, and to take all steps necessary to suppress barking noise.11 Wiggins filed a timely notice of appeal.12
Whether the circuit court's finding that Wiggins's dogs constituted a nuisance was against the manifest weight of the evidence?13
A private nuisance is a substantial invasion of another’s interest in the use and enjoyment of his or her land that is either intentional or negligent and unreasonable. The standard is the conduct’s effect on a reasonable person.14 The court must balance the gravity of the harm done to the plaintiffs against the utility of the defendant’s use of the land and the suitability of the location.15
No. The plaintiffs presented sufficient evidence through the testimony of Larry Dobbs, Frances Dobbs, Wayne Richard, and Lorena Richard that the barking was constant day and night, audible inside their homes, and prevented them from enjoying outdoor activities such as gardening and barbecues.16 Additional witnesses including Mary McKowen, Charles Downey, and Randy Phillips corroborated the continuous barking audible at the Dobbs property.17 Wiggins knew that nearly one hundred dogs could be set off by wildlife and that a few dogs barking often caused a chain reaction.18 The circuit court properly balanced the factors and found the harm outweighed the utility of the kennels located in a suitable rural area.19
The circuit court's finding that Wiggins's dogs constituted a nuisance was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.20
Whether the circuit court's permanent injunction limiting Wiggins to no more than six dogs was unjust and unreasonable?21
The granting of an injunction is within a trial court’s discretion and is reviewed for manifest abuse of discretion.22 Equity will not order relief in nuisance cases until all the circumstances and consequences of such action are considered.23 The restraint imposed by an injunction should not be more extensive than is reasonably required to protect the interests of the party in whose favor it is granted.24
Yes. The evidence at trial showed that sixty-nine or more dogs caused an unreasonable noise invasion that interfered with the plaintiffs’ use and enjoyment of their land.25 However, the evidence was insufficient to support a finding that Wiggins must reduce the number of dogs to six to abate the nuisance.26 Wiggins had kept dogs on the property for more than ten years without complaint.27
He had also implemented several noise-reduction measures after the August 2007 complaint.28 The circuit court had insufficient evidence to determine the maximum number of dogs that could be maintained without creating a nuisance.29
The circuit court's permanent injunction limiting Wiggins to no more than six dogs was unjust and unreasonable.30
Whether the circuit court improperly admitted audio recordings of his barking dogs?31
Evidentiary rulings are within the sound discretion of the trial court and will be upheld absent an abuse of discretion that resulted in prejudice to the objecting party.32 Sound recordings are generally admissible if a proper foundation is laid.33 The authentication of an audio recording is sufficient if a witness testifies to having been present at the time the conversation was recorded and states that the recording fully, fairly, and accurately reflects the conversation.34
No. Larry Dobbs identified the digital recorders used to make the recordings, testified concerning where and how he took the recordings, and testified concerning what he did with the recordings after they were made.35 Both Larry and Frances testified that the portions of the tape recordings played at the trial fairly and accurately reflected what they heard while on their property.36 Any questions about manipulation of the recording process went to the weight of the evidence rather than its admissibility.37 There is a strong presumption in a bench trial that the trier of fact relied only on proper evidence.38
The circuit court did not improperly admit audio recordings of Wiggins's barking dogs.39