71 F.3d 1024 (2d Cir. 1995)
In January 1988, Rotorex Corporation, a New York corporation, agreed to sell 10,800 compressors to Delchi Carrier SpA, an Italian manufacturer of air conditioners, for use in its Ariele line of portable room air conditioners scheduled for sale in spring and summer 1988.1 Prior to the contract, Rotorex sent Delchi a sample compressor along with written performance specifications for cooling capacity and power consumption.2 The compressors were to be delivered in three shipments before May 15, 1988.3
Rotorex shipped the first lot by sea on March 26, 1988; Delchi paid by letter of credit and the shipment arrived at its Italian factory on April 20.4 Rotorex sent a second shipment on or about May 9, which Delchi also paid for by letter of credit.5 While the second shipment was en route, Delchi discovered the first lot failed to conform to the sample and specifications.6 On May 13, after a Rotorex representative visited the factory, Delchi rejected 93 percent of the compressors because they had lower cooling capacity and consumed more power than the sample and specifications indicated.7
Delchi made unsuccessful attempts to cure the defects.8 Rotorex refused to supply new conforming compressors, claiming the performance specifications had been inadvertently communicated.9 In a faxed letter dated May 23, 1988, Delchi cancelled the contract.10 It expedited a previously planned order from Sanyo but could not obtain timely substitute compressors from other sources and therefore suffered a loss in 1988 Ariele sales volume.11
Delchi filed suit under the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods.12 On January 10, 1991, Judge Cholakis granted Delchi partial summary judgment on liability.13 After a bench trial on damages before Judge Munson, the district court awarded Delchi $1,248,331.87, including consequential damages for lost profits from diminished Ariele sales, expenses to remedy the nonconformity, costs of expediting the Sanyo shipment, and handling and storage of the rejected compressors, plus prejudgment interest.14
The district court denied Delchi recovery for shipping, customs, and incidentals on the two Rotorex shipments, the cost of obsolete insulation and tubing purchased only for Rotorex compressors, the cost of obsolete tooling purchased only for Rotorex units, and labor costs for four idle production days in May 1988.15 It also denied recovery for 4000 additional claimed lost sales in Italy.16 Rotorex appealed the damages award; Delchi cross-appealed the denials of the additional expenses and lost sales.17
Whether Rotorex delivered compressors that conformed to the sample and written specifications provided to Delchi?18
Under the CISG, the seller must deliver goods which are of the quantity, quality and description required by the contract, and the goods do not conform with the contract unless they possess the qualities of goods which the seller has held out to the buyer as a sample or model. CISG art. 35. The seller is liable in accordance with the contract and this Convention for any lack of conformity. CISG art. 36.19
No. Rotorex provided a sample compressor and written specifications for cooling capacity and power consumption prior to the January 1988 contract for 10,800 compressors.20 The first shipment arrived on April 20, 1988.21 Delchi discovered that 93 percent of those compressors had lower cooling capacity and consumed more power than the sample and specifications required.22 Rotorex's engineering representative admitted in a May 13, 1988 letter that the specification sheet was in error.23
The president conceded in a May 17 letter that the compressors were less efficient than the sample.24 Rotorex admitted in its answer that some compressors did not conform to the nominal performance information.25 These specific facts establish a lack of conformity under the Convention.26
Rotorex did not deliver compressors that conformed to the sample and written specifications provided to Delchi.27
Whether Delchi proved the number of lost Ariele sales with sufficient evidence under the CISG?28
The CISG provides that damages for breach of contract consist of a sum equal to the loss, including loss of profit, suffered by the other party as a consequence of the breach, provided the loss was foreseeable. CISG art. 74.29 A reviewing court must defer to the trial judge's findings of fact unless they are clearly erroneous.30
Yes. After a bench trial, the district court found that Delchi had proven the number of lost sales with sufficient evidence on the basis of documents and testimony concerning orders from European affiliates and Italian sales agents.31 The court of appeals held that these findings were not clearly erroneous.32 Rotorex's breach forced manufacturing shutdowns in May and delayed unit availability so that units ready only in late July could not fulfill spring and early summer orders even though total inventory might eventually have sufficed.33
Delchi proved the number of lost Ariele sales with sufficient evidence under the governing convention.34
Whether fixed costs and depreciation must be subtracted from sales revenue when calculating lost profits?35
The CISG does not explicitly state whether only variable expenses or both fixed and variable expenses should be subtracted from sales revenue in calculating lost profits under article 74.36 Courts generally do not include fixed costs in the calculation of lost profits because those costs would have been encountered whether or not the breach occurred.37
No. The district court calculated lost profits by subtracting only the 478,783 lire manufacturing cost, which represented total variable cost, from the 654,644 lire average sale price of an Ariele unit.38 The court of appeals affirmed this approach.39 Fixed costs and depreciation should not be subtracted when the plaintiff is an ongoing business whose fixed costs are not affected by the breach.40 This approach follows the standard formula employed by most American courts in the absence of a specific CISG provision.41
Fixed costs and depreciation must not be subtracted from sales revenue when calculating lost profits.42
Whether expenses for returned shipments, obsolete materials, tooling, and idle labor constitute recoverable incidental or consequential damages?43
The CISG provides that a contract plaintiff may collect damages to compensate for the full loss, including lost profits, subject only to the limitation that the breaching party must have foreseen or should have foreseen the loss as a probable consequence. CISG art. 74.44 An award for lost profits does not compensate for costs actually incurred that led to no sales.45
Yes. The district court denied recovery for shipping, customs, and incidentals on the two Rotorex shipments.46 It denied the cost of obsolete insulation and tubing purchased only for Rotorex compressors.47 It denied the cost of obsolete tooling purchased only for Rotorex units.48
It denied labor costs for four idle production days in May 1988.49 The court of appeals reversed in part.50 These expenses were reasonably foreseeable incidental or consequential damages.51 They did not duplicate the lost profits award because they were up-front costs incurred before nonconformities were detected or costs that led to no sales.52
The court remanded only the labor costs issue for factual findings on whether they were variable or fixed.53
Expenses for returned shipments, obsolete materials, tooling, and idle labor constitute recoverable incidental or consequential damages, except that the idle labor costs require further factual determination on remand.54
Whether Delchi proved the additional 4000 lost sales in Italy with sufficient evidence?55
The CISG requires that damages be limited by the principle of foreseeability. The district court was entitled to rely upon documents and testimony regarding lost sales while deciding which orders were proven with sufficient evidence.56
No. Delchi cross-appealed from the denial of its claimed 4000 additional lost sales in Italy.57 The district court held that Delchi did not prove these orders with sufficient evidence.58 It evaluated the testimony of Italian sales agents who stated they would have ordered more Arieles if available.59 The court of appeals affirmed that this conclusion was not clearly erroneous.60 The trial court was in the best position to assess the speculative nature of the claims.61
Delchi did not prove the additional 4000 lost sales in Italy with sufficient evidence.62