503 U.S. 159 (1992)
Shortly after midnight on December 1, 1986, petitioner David Dawson and three other inmates escaped from the Delaware Correctional Center near Smyrna, Delaware.1 Dawson stole a car and headed south, while the other three inmates stole another car and drove north.2 Early that morning, Dawson burglarized a house near Kenton, Delaware, stealing a motorcycle jacket, several pocket watches, and containers of loose change.3 He then proceeded to the home of Richard and Madeline Kisner, located about half a mile from the burglary site, where Mrs. Kisner was alone in the house preparing to leave for work.4
Dawson brutally murdered Mrs. Kisner, stole the Kisners’ car and some money, and fled further south.5 He reappeared later that evening at the Zoo Bar in Milford, Delaware, wearing a motorcycle jacket that was too big for him.6 While at the bar, Dawson introduced himself to Patty Dennis and told her that his name was “Abaddon,” which he said meant one of Satan’s disciples.7 Dawson was subsequently asked to leave the bar.8 Later that evening, a Delaware state police officer responded to a call to investigate a one-car accident involving a vehicle stolen from a location near the Zoo Bar.9 The police began a house-to-house search for Dawson and found him at 5:25 the next morning on the floor of a Cadillac parked about three-tenths of a mile from the accident site.10
A jury convicted Dawson of first-degree murder, possession of a deadly weapon during the commission of a felony, and other crimes.11 The trial court then conducted a penalty hearing before the jury to determine whether Dawson should be sentenced to death.12 The prosecution gave notice that it intended to introduce expert testimony regarding the origin and nature of the Aryan Brotherhood.13 The notice also covered the fact that Dawson had the words “Aryan Brotherhood” tattooed on the back of his right hand.14 It included testimony that Dawson referred to himself as “Abaddon” and had that name tattooed across his stomach.15 The notice further encompassed photographs of multiple swastika tattoos on Dawson’s back and a picture of a swastika he had painted on the wall of his prison cell.16
Before the penalty phase began, the parties agreed to a stipulation.17 The stipulation stated that the Aryan Brotherhood refers to a white racist prison gang that began in the 1960’s in California in response to other gangs of racial minorities.18 It also stated that separate gangs calling themselves the Aryan Brotherhood now exist in many state prisons including Delaware.19 In return for Dawson’s agreement to the stipulation, the prosecution agreed not to call any expert witnesses.20 At the penalty hearing, the prosecution read the stipulation to the jury and introduced evidence that Dawson had tattooed the words “Aryan Brotherhood” on his hand.21 The trial judge permitted the prosecution to present the evidence related to the name “Abaddon” but excluded all of the swastika evidence.22 In addition, the prosecution submitted proof of Dawson’s lengthy criminal record.23 Dawson presented mitigating evidence based on the testimony of two family members and on the fact that he had earned good time credits in prison for enrolling in drug and alcohol programs.24
The jury found three statutory aggravating circumstances making Dawson eligible for the death penalty: that the murder was committed by an escaped prisoner, that the murder was committed during the commission of a burglary, and that the murder was committed for pecuniary gain.25 The jury further concluded that the aggravating evidence outweighed the mitigating evidence and recommended that Dawson be sentenced to death.26 The trial court imposed the death penalty.27 The Supreme Court of Delaware affirmed the convictions and the death sentence.28 The United States Supreme Court granted certiorari to consider whether the admission of the Aryan Brotherhood evidence was constitutional error.29
Whether the First and Fourteenth Amendments prohibit the introduction, in a capital sentencing proceeding, of the fact that the defendant was a member of an organization called the Aryan Brotherhood, where the evidence has no relevance to the issues being decided in the proceeding?30
The Constitution does not erect a per se barrier to the admission of evidence concerning one's beliefs and associations at sentencing simply because those beliefs and associations are protected by the First Amendment.31 The admission of such evidence violates the First and Fourteenth Amendments when it proves nothing more than the defendant's abstract beliefs and has no relevance to the sentencing issues such as character, aggravating circumstances, or rebuttal of mitigating evidence.32
Yes. The established facts indicate that the prosecution and Dawson agreed to a stipulation describing the Aryan Brotherhood as a white racist prison gang originating in California with separate gangs in Delaware prisons.33 The prosecution read this stipulation to the jury at the penalty hearing along with evidence of Dawson's tattoo.34 This evidence had no connection to the murder of Mrs. Kisner or to any of the three statutory aggravating circumstances found by the jury.35 The stipulation also did not rebut Dawson's mitigating evidence of family kindness and good time credits from prison programs, as it showed only abstract beliefs without proof of unlawful acts by the gang.36
Therefore, the admission of the evidence violated Dawson's rights under the First and Fourteenth Amendments.37
The First and Fourteenth Amendments prohibit the introduction of the Aryan Brotherhood membership evidence in this capital sentencing proceeding because the evidence had no relevance to the issues being decided.38
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Blackmun joined the Court's opinion but wrote separately to clarify his understanding regarding harmless-error review.39 He noted that the Court, by the penultimate paragraph of its opinion, does not require application of harmless-error review on remand.40 This Court has previously declined to apply harmless-error analysis to certain categories of constitutional error, including racial discrimination in the selection of a petit jury.41
Because of the potential chilling effect that consideration of First Amendment activity at sentencing might have, there is a substantial argument that harmless-error analysis is not appropriate for the type of error before us today.42 The parties did not address this issue, and it is better left for the Supreme Court of Delaware on remand.43
Justice Thomas dissented from the Court's holding that the gang membership evidence had no relevance to the issues being decided in the proceeding.44 He contended that Dawson's membership in the Aryan Brotherhood prison gang had relevance at sentencing under Delaware law.45 After a jury finds a statutory aggravating factor, it may consider all relevant evidence in aggravation or mitigation relating to the character and propensities of the defendant.46 Under this provision, Dawson's character became an issue in determining whether he should receive the death penalty.47
The stipulation implied much more than that Dawson shared the gang's abstract racist creed; it indicated that Dawson had engaged in prison gang activities, and that he had the character of a person who engages in these activities.48 This evidence tended to establish that Dawson has not been a well-behaved and well-adjusted prisoner, which itself is an indication of future dangerousness.49 The evidence also tended to rebut Dawson's attempt to show kindness to others.50