489 U.S. 803 (1989)
Paul S. Davis is a Michigan resident and former employee of the United States Government.1 He receives retirement benefits pursuant to the Civil Service Retirement Act, 5 U.S.C. § 8331 et seq.2 In each of the years 1979 through 1984, Davis paid Michigan state income tax on his federal retirement benefits in accordance with Mich. Comp. Laws Ann. § 206.30(1)(f) (Supp. 1988).3
That statute defines taxable income in a manner that excludes all retirement benefits received from the State or its political subdivisions but includes most other forms of retirement benefits.4 The effect of this definition is that the retirement benefits of retired state employees are exempt from state taxation while the benefits received by retired federal employees are not.5
In 1984, Davis petitioned for refunds of state taxes paid on his federal retirement benefits between 1979 and 1983.6 After his request was denied, he filed suit in the Michigan Court of Claims.7 His complaint, which was amended to include the 1984 tax year, averred that his federal retirement benefits were not legally taxable under the Michigan Income Tax Law and that the State's inconsistent treatment of state and federal retirement benefits discriminated against federal retirees in violation of 4 U.S.C. § 111.8
The Court of Claims denied relief on October 30, 1985.9 The Michigan Court of Appeals affirmed in 1987.10 The Supreme Court of Michigan denied Davis's application for leave to appeal later that year.11 The United States Supreme Court noted probable jurisdiction in 1988.12
Whether 4 U.S.C. § 111 applies to retired federal employees receiving civil service retirement benefits?13
Section 111 provides that the United States consents to the taxation of pay or compensation for personal service as an officer or employee of the United States by a state taxing authority. This consent applies if the taxation does not discriminate against the officer or employee because of the source of the pay or compensation. Retirement benefits under the Civil Service Retirement Act constitute deferred compensation for past years of service rendered to the Government.14 These benefits therefore fall within the statute's coverage.15
Yes. The plain language of section 111 applies to the taxation of pay or compensation for personal service as an officer or employee of the United States.16 Davis's retirement benefits are computed on the basis of his salary and years of service as a federal employee under the Civil Service Retirement Act.17 These benefits therefore constitute deferred compensation earned as a federal employee and fall squarely within the coverage of the statute.18
Section 111 applies to retired federal employees such as Davis.19
Whether Michigan's income tax exemption for state and local government retirees but not federal retirees violates federal statutory or constitutional protections?20
The nondiscrimination clause of 4 U.S.C. § 111 and the constitutional doctrine of intergovernmental tax immunity prohibit state taxes that discriminate against federal employees on the basis of the source of their compensation.21 The scope of immunity retained in section 111 is coextensive with the modern constitutional prohibition against discriminatory taxes.22
Yes. Michigan's tax scheme exempts all retirement benefits paid by the State or its political subdivisions while taxing those paid by the Federal Government to retirees such as Davis.23 This inconsistent treatment discriminates against federal retirees because of the source of their compensation in violation of the protections retained in section 111 and the intergovernmental tax immunity doctrine.24
Michigan's tax scheme violates federal statutory and constitutional protections.25
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Stevens dissented from the majority's conclusion that the tax violates intergovernmental tax immunity.26 He explained that the Michigan tax applies to approximately 4 1/2 million individual taxpayers in the State, including the 24,000 retired federal employees.27 It exempts only the 130,000 retired state employees.28
In his view the political check against abuse of the taxing power is present because the burden is shared equally by federal agents and the vast majority of the state's citizens.29 Stevens concluded that the intergovernmental immunity doctrine does not constitute a most favored nation provision requiring states to accord federal employees the greatest tax benefits given any other group.30
Whether differences between state and federal retirement benefits justify Michigan's inconsistent tax treatment of the two groups?31
A heavier tax burden on those who deal with one sovereign than is imposed on those who deal with the other must be justified by significant differences between the two classes themselves.32 The state's interest in adopting the discriminatory tax is irrelevant to whether such differences exist.33 Differences in average benefit amounts do not justify a blanket exemption based on source rather than amount received by individual retirees.34
No. The state's interest in attracting and retaining qualified employees demonstrates only a rational reason for discriminating between similar groups rather than significant differences between the classes.35 Although state retirement benefits may be less munificent than federal benefits in terms of vesting and accrual, this does not justify the exemption.36 A tax exemption truly intended to account for differences would discriminate on the basis of the amount of benefits received rather than their source.37 Individual variations prevent the average difference from justifying the blanket exemption at issue.38
Differences between state and federal retirement benefits do not justify Michigan's inconsistent tax treatment.39