65 N.Y.2d 536, 483 N.E.2d 110, 493 N.Y.S.2d 435
In 1978, Credit Alliance Corporation and related financial service companies, which financed purchases of capital equipment, required L. B. Smith, Inc. of Virginia to provide audited financial statements as a condition for extending additional financing.1 Smith supplied consolidated financial statements for the years ended December 31, 1977 and 1976, along with a report from Arthur Andersen & Co. stating that the statements had been examined in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards and fairly reflected the company's financial position under generally accepted accounting principles.2 Relying on these statements, the plaintiffs extended substantial credit to Smith.3 In 1979, Smith provided updated statements for the years ended February 28, 1979 and December 31, 1977, again with Andersen's certification, leading to further financing by the plaintiffs.4
Subsequently, in 1980, Smith filed for bankruptcy after defaulting on millions of dollars owed to the plaintiffs.5 The plaintiffs alleged that the statements overstated Smith's assets and financial health, and that Andersen had failed to conduct proper audits.6 In August 1981, the plaintiffs sued Andersen for negligence and fraud in preparing the audit reports, claiming Andersen knew or should have known that the statements were being used to induce credit extensions to companies like the plaintiffs.7
Separately, beginning in 1979, European American Bank and Trust Company made substantial loans to Majestic Electro Industries and its subsidiaries pursuant to written agreements.8 Majestic Electro retained Strauhs & Kaye to audit its financial records in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards and to report findings under generally accepted accounting principles.9 EAB relied on the interim and year-end reports prepared by Strauhs & Kaye to determine loan amounts.10 Representatives of EAB and Strauhs & Kaye maintained direct oral and written communications throughout the lending relationship, including meetings to discuss inventory and accounts receivable valuations.11
In December 1982, a Majestic Electro subsidiary defaulted, leading EAB to discover inaccuracies in the reports that overstated solvency.12 Majestic Electro later filed for bankruptcy, resulting in substantial losses to EAB.13 In May 1983, EAB sued Strauhs & Kaye for negligence and gross negligence, alleging the accountants knew EAB was the principal lender and relied on the reports.14 In Credit Alliance, Special Term initially dismissed the negligence claim on statute of limitations grounds but later reinstated it, and the Appellate Division affirmed denial of the motion to dismiss.15 In European American, Special Term dismissed the complaint, but the Appellate Division reversed and reinstated it.16 Both Appellate Divisions certified questions to the Court of Appeals.17
Whether an accountant may be held liable, absent privity of contract, to a party who relies to his detriment upon a negligently prepared financial report and, if so, within what limits does that liability extend?18
Before accountants may be held liable in negligence to noncontractual parties who rely to their detriment on inaccurate financial reports, three prerequisites must be satisfied. The accountants must have been aware that the financial reports were to be used for a particular purpose or purposes. In the furtherance of that purpose, a known party or parties was intended to rely. There must have been some conduct on the part of the accountants linking them to that party or parties, which evinces the accountants' understanding of that party or parties' reliance.19
Yes. Application of these criteria to the established facts distinguishes the two cases.20 In Credit Alliance Corp. v. Arthur Andersen & Co., the allegations fail to demonstrate a relationship approaching privity. There is no claim that Andersen was employed to prepare the reports with the particular purpose of inducing the plaintiffs' credit extensions. There is also no allegation of any direct dealings with the plaintiffs or specific agreement to provide the reports to them.21
By contrast, in European American Bank & Trust Co. v. Strauhs & Kaye, the facts show that Strauhs & Kaye knew EAB was the principal lender. The accountants maintained direct oral and written communications with EAB throughout the lending relationship. They met to discuss the financial condition and valuations. They made repeated representations directly to EAB's representatives concerning the value of assets.
This created a nexus sufficiently approaching privity to permit the negligence claims.22
Therefore, the negligence cause of action in Credit Alliance must be dismissed for lack of a relationship approaching privity, while the claims in European American are adequately alleged and may proceed.23
Whether the second cause of action for fraud in Credit Alliance was sufficiently pleaded under CPLR 3016(b)?24
A cause of action for fraud must be pleaded with particularity under CPLR 3016(b), requiring additional detail concerning the facts constituting the alleged fraud beyond mere conclusory allegations of scienter.25
No. The fraud claim in Credit Alliance merely repeats the negligence allegations. It adds a single claim that Andersen recklessly disregarded facts which would have apprised it that its reports were misleading or had actual knowledge that such was the case. This lacks the requisite additional detail about the facts constituting the fraud.26
The fraud cause of action in Credit Alliance therefore fails to meet the special pleading standards and should be dismissed.27