475 U.S. 211 (1986)
In 1974 Congress enacted the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, which created the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation to administer an insurance program covering both single-employer and multiemployer pension plans.1 The statute required contributing employers to pay insurance premiums and, upon plan termination, imposed contingent liability on employers that had contributed during the preceding five years, capped at thirty percent of net worth.2
In 1980 Congress enacted the Multiemployer Pension Plan Amendments Act, which required an employer withdrawing from a multiemployer plan to pay a fixed debt equal to its proportionate share of the plan's unfunded vested benefits.3 The Operating Engineers Pension Trust, established in 1960 under a trust agreement executed pursuant to section 302(c)(5) of the Labor Management Relations Act, received contributions from several thousand employers in the southern California and southern Nevada construction industry; each employer's obligation was limited by the trust agreement and plan documents to the amounts specified in collective-bargaining agreements, with no further liability for benefits even if contributions proved insufficient.4
In 1975 the trustees of the Operating Engineers Pension Trust sued the PBGC in the United States District Court for the Central District of California, seeking declaratory and injunctive relief on the ground that the plan was a defined-contribution plan exempt from ERISA or, alternatively, that the statute was unconstitutional.5 The district court granted summary judgment to the trustees, the Ninth Circuit reversed, and on remand the district court denied a request to convene a three-judge court.6
After enactment of the MPPAA the trustees amended the complaint to challenge the new statute, and Woodward Sand Co., an employer assessed approximately two hundred thousand dollars in withdrawal liability representing nearly twenty-five percent of its net worth, intervened as a plaintiff.7 A three-judge district court granted summary judgment to the PBGC, holding that the contractual limitation on employer liability was not property protected by the Takings Clause.8
The trustees and Woodward Sand Co. invoked the Supreme Court's appellate jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1253; the Court noted probable jurisdiction and set the cases for argument.9
Whether the withdrawal liability provisions of the Multiemployer Pension Plan Amendments Act of 1980 violate the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment?10
The Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment provides that private property shall not be taken for public use without just compensation. Legislation readjusting rights and burdens is not unlawful solely because it upsets otherwise settled expectations.11 This is true even though the effect of the legislation is to impose a new duty or liability based on past acts.12 To determine whether a regulation constitutes a taking, the Court examines three factors of particular significance.13 Those factors are the economic impact of the regulation on the claimant, the extent to which the regulation has interfered with distinct investment-backed expectations, and the character of the governmental action.14
No. The withdrawal liability provisions do not violate the Takings Clause because the government does not physically invade or permanently appropriate any of the employer's assets for its own use.15 Instead, the Act requires withdrawing employers such as Woodward Sand Co. to fund their share of the plan obligations incurred during their association with the plan.16
The economic impact is moderated by several provisions in the Act that exempt specific transactions such as sales of assets under defined conditions from being characterized as withdrawals.17 Other provisions reduce the size of financial liability, including a de minimis rule and a free look provision.18
The interference with investment-backed expectations is not unreasonable because pension plans were the objects of legislative concern long before the passage of ERISA in 1974.19 Employers had more than sufficient notice that withdrawal itself might trigger additional financial obligations.20
The character of the governmental action is a public program that adjusts the benefits and burdens of economic life to promote the common good rather than a physical invasion of property.21 The contractual limitation of liability in the Operating Engineers Pension Trust agreement is not property that prevents Congress from imposing additional obligations that are otherwise within its power to impose.22
The withdrawal liability provisions of the Multiemployer Pension Plan Amendments Act of 1980 do not violate the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment.23
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justice Powell
Justice O'Connor joined the Court's opinion but wrote separately to emphasize issues the Court does not decide today.24 She notes that the Court has left open whether the imposition of withdrawal liability under the MPPAA may in some circumstances be so arbitrary and irrational as to violate the Due Process Clause.25 O'Connor observes that the Court has never intimated that Congress possesses unlimited power to readjust rights and burdens and upset otherwise settled expectations.26
She leaves open the possibility that retroactive liability on employers may be arbitrary and irrational in the absence of any connection between the employer's conduct and some detriment to the employee.27 She highlights that for Taft-Hartley plans such as the Operating Engineers Pension Plan the imposition of liability may not always be rationally traceable to the employer's conduct. Employers have limited control over the level of benefits set by trustees. The plans possess characteristics of both fixed contributions and fixed benefits.28 O'Connor suggests that the application of the MPPAA in particular cases may raise constitutional doubts under the Taking Clause or the Due Process Clause even though the facial challenge presented here fails.29