887 F.3d 803, 816 (7th Cir. 2018)
In late 2012, hackers infiltrated Schnuck Markets' computer network in Missouri and installed malware on its system that harvested track data from payment card transactions.1 The breach affected 79 of Schnucks' 100 Midwest stores and continued for four months until Schnucks learned of the intrusion on March 14, 2013, from its payment processor.2 An outside consultant identified the source days later, and Schnucks issued a public announcement of the breach on March 30, 2013.3 The incident placed approximately 2.4 million credit and debit cards at risk, with plaintiffs estimating that more than 300,000 cards may have been compromised in the period after Schnucks learned of the breach but before it announced the incident publicly.4
The electronic card payment system routes customer track data from the merchant through a payment processor and acquiring bank. The data then reaches the card networks and the issuing banks that approve transactions and later collect payment from cardholders.5 In this case, Schnucks routed data through First Data Merchant Services to its acquiring bank, Citicorp, which then routed the data through Visa or MasterCard networks to the plaintiff issuing banks.6 All participants in the system operate under a network of contracts that impose Payment Card Industry Data Security Standards on merchants and processors, require issuing banks to indemnify cardholders for unauthorized transactions, and establish reimbursement and assessment processes for breach-related losses.7 No direct contracts link the plaintiff banks to Schnucks.8
The four plaintiff banks, which include both Illinois and Missouri citizens, bore the initial costs of reissuing compromised cards and indemnifying customers for fraudulent charges and cash withdrawals after the breach.9 They estimate their total losses, including employee time, indemnification payments, and lost fees, in the tens of millions of dollars.10 Through the card networks' processes, over $1.5 million in charges and fees were assessed against Schnucks, which later split that liability with its processor and acquiring bank, though the plaintiffs may not have received full reimbursement for all their costs.11
The plaintiff banks filed suit against Schnucks in 2014, voluntarily dismissed the first complaint, and refiled the action in the Southern District of Illinois in October 2015.12 They amended the complaint in October 2016.13 The district court dismissed the amended complaint on May 1, 2017, for failure to state a claim under any of the asserted theories.14 The banks appealed, and the Seventh Circuit heard argument on January 10, 2018.15
Whether Illinois or Missouri tort law offers card-issuing banks a remedy against a retail merchant for losses from a data breach above and beyond the remedies provided by the network of contracts linking merchants, processors, acquiring banks, issuing banks, and card brands?16
The economic loss doctrine, known as the Moorman doctrine in Illinois and applied similarly in Missouri, bars tort recovery for purely economic losses when the parties' relationship and remedies are defined by a network of contracts, because contract law supplies the proper mechanism for allocating commercial risks among sophisticated parties.17
No. The plaintiff banks and Schnucks participated in the card payment system under contracts that imposed PCI DSS data security standards on merchants, required issuing banks to indemnify cardholders, and established reimbursement and assessment processes for breach losses.18 The banks incurred tens of millions of dollars in losses from reissuing cards and indemnifying customers after the breach that placed 2.4 million cards at risk. Yet the contracts already channeled over $1.5 million in assessments against Schnucks that were later shared with its processor and acquiring bank.19 The economic loss rule prevents courts from layering additional tort liability on top of this contractual framework for the same economic harms.20
The contracting parties paradigm applies because all participants voluntarily joined the network and accepted its risk allocations, including the possibility of incomplete reimbursement.21 No direct contract between the banks and Schnucks alters this result, as the web of agreements still governs the duties and remedies at issue.22
Illinois and Missouri tort law does not offer card-issuing banks a remedy against Schnucks beyond the contractual network.23
Whether the plaintiff banks stated viable claims for negligence, negligence per se, unjust enrichment, implied contract, or third-party beneficiary status under Illinois or Missouri common law arising from Schnucks' handling of the data breach?24
Illinois and Missouri common law do not impose a duty on merchants to safeguard payment card data beyond statutory notice requirements, the economic loss rule bars negligence and negligence per se claims for economic losses, and unjust enrichment, implied contract, and third-party beneficiary claims fail where existing contracts govern the relationship and no clear intent to benefit the banks appears.25
No. Cooney rejected a common law duty to safeguard personal information under Illinois law, and Missouri law reaches the same result by limiting statutory mandates to notice without creating reimbursement liability.26 Negligence per se claims fail because neither state has enacted statutes imposing the monetary liability the banks seek.27 Unjust enrichment and implied contract theories are unavailable because the card network contracts already allocate the risks of data breaches and incomplete reimbursement.28 Third-party beneficiary status does not exist because those contracts do not clearly intend to benefit the issuing banks directly.29
The banks' allegations of delayed announcement and substandard security do not create an exception, as the economic loss rule applies to these foreseeable commercial risks rather than sudden physical hazards.30
The plaintiff banks did not state viable common law claims under Illinois or Missouri law.31
Whether the plaintiff banks stated a claim under the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act based on Schnucks' data security procedures or its delay in announcing the breach?32
An ICFA claim requires a deceptive act or practice, proximate causation through actual deception of the plaintiff, and a consumer nexus when businesses sue one another; market-theory allegations of inflated prices or concealed risks without specific misrepresentations do not satisfy these elements.33
No. The banks' unfair practice theory, which alleged that Schnucks minimized security costs and delayed announcement to maintain prices, mirrors the market-theory causation rejected in Oliveira and De Bouse because it fails to show that the banks themselves were actually deceived by any statement or omission.34 The complaint did not identify any specific deceptive guarantee about data security that the banks relied upon.35
The consumer nexus test need not be resolved because the banks failed to allege an underlying ICFA violation in the first instance.36
The plaintiff banks did not state a viable claim under the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act.37
Whether the plaintiff banks stated a claim under the Illinois Personal Information Protection Act that could support relief under the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act?38
A PIPA violation can constitute a per se unlawful practice under the ICFA, but the plaintiff must specifically identify the statutory violation and explain its application in the district court to preserve the claim for appellate review.39
No. The banks mentioned PIPA only in a footnote and in general references within their ICFA briefing without explaining which subsections applied to Schnucks' two-week delay or how the statute supported their particular theory.40 This failure to proffer a legal basis in the district court waived the argument on appeal.41
Even if preserved, the claim would require showing that the delay violated PIPA's notice provisions without falling within any exception, an analysis the banks never supplied.42
The plaintiff banks did not preserve or state a viable PIPA-based claim under the ICFA.43