453 U.S. 609 (1981)
In 1921 Montana began imposing a severance tax on coal mined within the state, including coal extracted from federal lands where large deposits of low-sulfur coal are located.1
After commissioning a study of coal production taxes in 1974, the Montana Legislature in 1975 enacted a new tax schedule that levies the tax at varying rates depending on the value, energy content, and method of extraction of the coal, reaching a maximum of 30 percent of the contract sales price.2 A 1976 amendment to the Montana Constitution requires that after December 31, 1979, at least 50 percent of the revenues generated by the tax be paid into a permanent trust fund whose principal may be appropriated only by a three-fourths vote of each house of the legislature.3
The great bulk of Montana coal, allegedly as much as 90 percent, is exported to other states pursuant to long-term purchase contracts with out-of-state utilities.4 Those contracts typically provide that the costs of state taxation shall be passed on to the utilities, and fuel adjustment clauses allow the utilities to pass the cost along to their consumers.5 Appellants assert that the tax now supplies almost 20% of the State's total revenue.6 It has been suggested that by the year 2010, Montana will have collected more than $20 billion through the implementation of this tax.7
In 1978 four Montana coal producers and eleven of their out-of-state utility company customers filed suits in Montana state court.8 The plaintiffs sought refunds of over $5.4 million in severance taxes paid under protest, a declaration that the tax is invalid under the Supremacy and Commerce Clauses, and an injunction against further collection of the tax.9 Without receiving any evidence, the trial court upheld the tax and dismissed the complaints.10
On appeal the Montana Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the trial court.11 The United States Supreme Court noted probable jurisdiction in 1980.12 The case was argued on March 30, 1981, and decided on July 2, 1981.13
Whether the Montana coal severance tax is subject to scrutiny under the Commerce Clause?14
A state severance tax is not immunized from Commerce Clause scrutiny by a claim that the tax is imposed on goods prior to their entry into the stream of interstate commerce.15 Instead the tax must be evaluated under the Complete Auto Transit four-part test focusing on the practical effect of the challenged tax.16
Yes. The Court rejected the Heisler approach as undermined by later decisions emphasizing practical effects on interstate commerce rather than formal distinctions between local and interstate activities.17 The tax reaches coal of which the great bulk is exported to other states under long-term contracts that pass costs to out-of-state utilities and ultimately their consumers.18 This produces the very economic effects that trigger Commerce Clause review under Complete Auto Transit.19
The Montana coal severance tax is subject to scrutiny under the Commerce Clause and must be tested under Complete Auto Transit.20
Related opinions on this issue
Justice White concurred in the judgment but expressed doubt. He noted that Montana collects most of its tax from coal on federal land while sharing royalties with the federal government.21 The tax may prove an intolerable burden on commerce.22
Nevertheless, because Congress is aware of the tax and the trend toward high extraction taxes yet has chosen not to act, he concluded that the better course is to respect the judgment of the political branches and uphold the tax for now.23
Whether the Montana coal severance tax discriminates against interstate commerce?24
No. The tax is levied at the same rate on all coal regardless of destination and contains no suggestion of uneven administration.27 Although ninety percent of the coal is shipped out of state under contracts that shift the burden to out-of-state consumers, the tax does not discriminate.28 The absence of any distinction between in-state and out-of-state consumers means the tax does not discriminate within the meaning of the Commerce Clause precedents.29
The Montana coal severance tax does not discriminate against interstate commerce.30
Whether the Montana coal severance tax is fairly related to services provided by the State?31
Under the fourth prong of the Complete Auto Transit test a tax satisfies the fair-relation requirement when its measure is reasonably related to the extent of the taxpayer's contact with the state.32 The taxpayer must bear a just share of the cost of providing police and fire protection, a trained work force, and the advantages of a civilized society.33
Yes. The tax is measured as a percentage of the value of coal severed within Montana.34 The activity creates the substantial nexus with the state.35 Because the entire value of the coal before transportation originates in Montana and mining depletes the state's resource base, the tax is in proper proportion to the coal producers' activities and their enjoyment of the opportunities and protections the state affords.36
The Montana coal severance tax is fairly related to services provided by the State.37
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justice Powell And Justice Stevens
Justice Blackmun dissented on this issue. He argued that the fourth prong requires a factual inquiry into whether the tax is tailored to force interstate commerce to pay more than its way.38 This is especially true when the tax is exported to out-of-state consumers and generates revenues far in excess of the direct and indirect costs attributable to coal production.39
Because the majority's mechanical test would uphold even a 1000 percent tax, he concluded that appellants were entitled to a trial to prove the tax bears no reasonable relationship to services provided by the state.40
Whether the Montana coal severance tax conflicts with the Mineral Lands Leasing Act under the Supremacy Clause?41
Section 32 of the Mineral Lands Leasing Act expressly authorizes states to levy and collect taxes upon the output of mines on federal lands without any limit on amount.42 Therefore a state severance tax is not inconsistent with the Act unless it conflicts with a specific federal purpose to maximize and capture all economic rents for the federal treasury.43
No. The 1920 Act and its 1975 amendments contain no language or legislative history indicating Congress intended to capture all economic rents from federal coal and distribute them solely according to the statutory formula.44 Section 32 preserves state taxing authority. Any reduction in federal royalties caused by the tax does not invalidate an otherwise lawful state tax.
The Montana coal severance tax does not conflict with the Mineral Lands Leasing Act under the Supremacy Clause.45
Whether the Montana coal severance tax substantially frustrates federal energy policies under the Supremacy Clause?46
General statements of national policy favoring coal use do not preempt state severance taxes.47 Preemption requires either unmistakable congressional intent or a direct conflict with specific statutory provisions.48 The Powerplant and Industrial Fuel Use Act expressly contemplates continued state severance taxes by requiring that such revenues be taken into account in determining eligibility for impact aid.49
No. Although federal statutes encourage greater use of coal, they contain no specific preemptive language directed at state severance taxes.50 The Powerplant and Industrial Fuel Use Act itself recognizes the continued existence of state severance taxes and was enacted with Montana's tax in mind, confirming that the tax is not preempted.51
The Montana coal severance tax does not substantially frustrate federal energy policies under the Supremacy Clause.52