471 U.S. 343, 354 (1985)
In October 1980, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission filed a complaint in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois against Chicago Discount Commodity Brokers alleging violations of the Commodity Exchange Act.1 On the same day, Frank McGhee, acting as sole director and officer of CDCB, entered into a consent decree providing for the appointment of a receiver, and the court appointed John K. Notz, Jr., as receiver.2 Notz subsequently filed a voluntary petition in bankruptcy on behalf of CDCB under Chapter 7 of the Bankruptcy Code, and the Bankruptcy Court appointed him as interim trustee and later as permanent trustee.3
As part of its investigation, the Commission served a subpoena duces tecum on CDCB's former counsel, Gary Weintraub, seeking testimony about suspected misappropriation of customer funds and other fraudulent activities.4 Weintraub appeared for deposition but refused to answer 23 questions, asserting CDCB's attorney-client privilege.5 The Commission moved to compel answers and requested that Notz waive the privilege.6 Notz waived any interest in the attorney-client privilege for communications occurring on or before October 27, 1980.7
A United States Magistrate ordered Weintraub to testify, finding that Notz was the successor in interest and that his waiver was valid.8 The District Court upheld the order.9 Frank McGhee and his brother Andrew McGhee intervened, arguing that Notz could not waive the privilege over their objection, but the District Court rejected this argument and entered an order requiring Weintraub to testify without asserting the privilege on behalf of CDCB.10
The McGhees appealed to the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, which reversed the District Court's order.11 The Seventh Circuit held that a bankruptcy trustee does not have the power to waive a corporate debtor's attorney-client privilege with respect to pre-petition communications.12 The Supreme Court granted certiorari to resolve a conflict among the circuits.13
Whether the trustee of a corporation in bankruptcy has the power to waive the debtor corporation's attorney-client privilege with respect to communications that took place before the filing of the petition in bankruptcy?14
The Bankruptcy Code does not explicitly address which actor controls the attorney-client privilege of a corporate debtor.15 The trustee assumes the role most analogous to management of a solvent corporation because the Code gives the trustee wide-ranging management authority over the debtor while severely limiting the powers of the debtor's directors.16 The trustee is accountable for all property received, has the duty to maximize the value of the estate, is directed to investigate the debtor's financial affairs, and is empowered to sue officers and directors to recover fraudulent or preferential transfers.17 Vesting control of the privilege in the trustee facilitates uncovering insider fraud and comports with the allocation of the waiver power to management outside of bankruptcy without obstructing the careful design of the Bankruptcy Code.18
Yes. The established facts demonstrate that Notz, as trustee, properly exercised the power to waive CDCB's attorney-client privilege over pre-petition communications.19 The Commission served a subpoena duces tecum on Weintraub seeking testimony about suspected misappropriation of customer funds and other fraudulent activities by CDCB officers and employees.20 Weintraub refused to answer twenty-three questions by asserting the privilege.21
The Commission requested that Notz waive the privilege, and Notz did so for all communications occurring on or before October 27, 1980.22 A United States Magistrate found that Notz was the successor in interest to all rights and privileges of CDCB, including the attorney-client privilege, and that the waiver was valid.23 The District Court upheld that order.24 After the McGhees intervened and objected, the District Court rejected their argument and ordered Weintraub to testify without asserting the privilege on behalf of CDCB.25
The Seventh Circuit reversed, but the Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals, confirming that the trustee's waiver was effective because the trustee's functions are more closely analogous to those of solvent-corporation management than are the functions of the debtor's directors.26
The trustee of a corporation in bankruptcy has the power to waive the debtor corporation's attorney-client privilege with respect to communications that took place before the filing of the petition in bankruptcy.27