544 U.S. 581 (2005)
Oklahoma maintains a semiclosed primary system under which a political party may invite only its own registered members and voters registered as Independents to participate in its primary election.1
In May 2000 the Libertarian Party of Oklahoma notified the secretary of the Oklahoma State Election Board that it wished to open its primary to all registered voters regardless of party affiliation.2 The secretary permitted the participation of Independent voters but declined to allow voters registered with other parties to vote in the LPO primary.3
The LPO and several voters registered as Republicans and Democrats filed suit in the United States District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma.4 They sought declaratory and injunctive relief against the respondents, the Oklahoma election officials.5 Following a two-day bench trial after the 2000 primary, the District Court upheld the semiclosed primary statute.6 On appeal the Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reversed the District Court's judgment.7 The Tenth Circuit concluded that the semiclosed primary imposed a severe burden on associational rights.8 The Supreme Court granted certiorari.9
Whether Oklahoma's semiclosed primary system unconstitutionally burdens the associational rights of the Libertarian Party of Oklahoma and voters registered with other parties?10
The First Amendment protects citizens' right to band together in promoting among the electorate candidates who espouse their political views.11 Regulations imposing severe burdens on associational rights must be narrowly tailored to serve a compelling state interest.12 However, when regulations impose lesser burdens, a State's important regulatory interests will usually be enough to justify reasonable, nondiscriminatory restrictions.13
No. Applying the rule to the established facts, Oklahoma's semiclosed primary system does not severely burden the LPO's associational rights.14 The LPO remains free to endorse candidates and communicate with the public.15 Voters registered with other parties can change their registration to Independent or Libertarian with only nominal effort by filing a form with the county election board secretary.16 The burden is therefore minor rather than severe.17
Oklahoma's semiclosed primary system does not unconstitutionally burden the associational rights of the Libertarian Party of Oklahoma and voters registered with other parties.18
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justice Ginsburg
Justice Stevens joins Parts I, II, and III of the Court's opinion.19 He agrees that the burden imposed by Oklahoma's semiclosed primary is not severe.20 He also agrees that the State's asserted interests are sufficient to justify that burden.21
He writes separately to note that he would not extend the reasoning of California Democratic Party v. Jones to this case.22 In his view, Jones was wrongly decided.23 The State has a legitimate interest in regulating the manner in which its elections are conducted.24
That interest is sufficient to justify the modest burdens that Oklahoma's semiclosed primary imposes on the associational rights of political parties and their members.25
Joined by Justice Breyer
Justice O'Connor joins the Court's opinion except for Part II-A.26 She agrees with most of the Court's reasoning.27 She writes separately to emphasize two points.28
She thinks respondents' claim implicates important associational interests.29 She sees no reason to minimize those interests to dispose of this case.30 She agrees that only Oklahoma's semiclosed primary law is properly under review.
She states that standing alone it imposes only a modest, nondiscriminatory burden on respondents' associational rights. She concludes that this burden is justified by the State's legitimate regulatory interests. She notes grounds for concern that other Oklahoma laws may unreasonably restrict voters' ability to participate in the LPO's primary.31
Joined by Justice Kennedy
Justice Souter dissents.32 In his view, Oklahoma's semiclosed primary system imposes a severe burden on the associational rights of the LPO and its members.33 The State's ban on the LPO's ability to invite registered members of other parties to vote in its primary severely burdens the LPO's right to define its own membership for the purpose of selecting its nominees.34
The State's asserted interests do not justify that severe burden.35 The State's interest in preventing party raiding can be addressed by less restrictive means.36 The State's interest in the stability of the political system is not sufficient to justify the severe burden that its semiclosed primary imposes on the LPO's associational rights.37
He would affirm the judgment of the Court of Appeals.38
Whether the burdens imposed by Oklahoma's semiclosed primary system on the Libertarian Party of Oklahoma and its potential voters are justified by state interests?39
When a state electoral provision places no heavy burden on associational rights, a State's important regulatory interests will usually be enough to justify reasonable, nondiscriminatory restrictions.40 Oklahoma's semiclosed primary advances a number of regulatory interests that this Court recognizes as important: It preserves political parties as viable and identifiable interest groups, enhances parties' electioneering and party-building efforts, and guards against party raiding and sore loser candidacies by spurned primary contenders.
Yes. Applying the rule to the established facts, the state's interests in preserving the political parties as viable and identifiable interest groups are sufficient.41 The interests in enhancing electioneering efforts and guarding against party raiding justify the minor burden.42 The system prevents voters from roaming among parties' primaries without demonstrating commitment through registration.43
The burdens imposed by Oklahoma's semiclosed primary system on the Libertarian Party of Oklahoma and its potential voters are justified by state interests.44
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justice Ginsburg
Justice Stevens would affirm the Court of Appeals' judgment.45 He concludes that the statute impairs both the party's right to define its mission and the voters' right to vote for the candidate of their choice.46 The Court's decision today diminishes the value of two important rights protected by the First Amendment.47
The individual citizen's right to vote for the candidate of her choice and a political party's right to define its own mission are diminished.48 The importance of vindicating that individual right far outweighs any public interest in punishing registered Republicans or Democrats for acts of disloyalty.49 The balance becomes even more lopsided when the individual right is reinforced by the right of the Libertarian Party of Oklahoma to associate with willing voters.
In concluding that the State's interests override those important values, the Court focuses on interests that are not legitimate.50 States do not have a valid interest in manipulating the outcome of elections, in protecting the major parties from competition, or in stunting the growth of new parties.51
Joined by Justice Breyer
Justice O'Connor agrees that the State's regulatory interests are adequate to justify the limited burden the semiclosed primary law imposes on respondents' freedom of association.52 She assumes reasonable avenues for voters to reregister as Independents or Libertarians.53 She agrees with the Court that the semiclosed primary law imposes only a modest and politically neutral burden on associational rights.54
The burden is not altogether trivial.55 A voter with a significant commitment to a major party must forfeit registration with that party in order to participate in the LPO primary in any given election cycle.56 The LPO cannot define the bounds of the association as broadly as it would like.57
But neither is it severe or discriminatory.58
Joined by Justice Kennedy
Justice Souter would affirm the judgment of the Court of Appeals.59 He states that the State's interest in preventing party raiding can be addressed by less restrictive means.60 He concludes that the interest in the stability of the political system is not sufficient to justify the severe burden.61
He respectfully dissents.62 In his view, Oklahoma's semiclosed primary system imposes a severe burden on the associational rights of the LPO and its members. The State's asserted interests do not justify that severe burden.