263 N.W.2d 420 (Minn. 1978)
In September 1973, the city of Mounds View retained Kenneth H. Walijarvi, an architect, and his firm to design and provide other architectural services in connection with the construction of an addition to the Mounds View city hall.1 The parties executed a standard form agreement between owner and architect which had been prepared by the American Institute of Architects.2 Article 12 of that agreement provided in part that the agreement may be amended only by written instrument signed by both Owner and Architect.3
Following the approval of Walijarvi’s design for the new addition, the general construction contract was awarded to B-E Enterprises, Inc.4 At some point after substantial progress had been made on the construction of the addition, the city became concerned about excessive dampness being experienced in the basement of the new construction.5 The city’s concern was expressed in a letter written by the city administrator to the architectural firm, though this letter was never introduced into evidence.6
Walijarvi responded on March 20, 1975 with a letter addressed to the city administrator.7 In the letter, the architects stated they guarantee that their design of the lower level is such that, in their opinion, the lower level shall remain water-tight and damp-free.8 The letter also noted that most basements are damp in summer months, that responsibility is not singularly theirs because they did not construct the building, and requested the contractor to guarantee from a construction point of view.9
Sometime later, serious water seepage did in fact develop in the new addition, necessitating extensive and costly remedial measures.10 The city brought this action in an effort to recover the damages it suffered as a consequence of the water problems.11 The city alleged that the architects’ plans were negligently prepared.12 The city alleged that the architects’ letter amended the original written agreement with the city by inserting an express warranty.13 The city alleged that the failure of the architects’ design to produce a watertight basement constituted a breach of both the express warranty and an implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose.14
The architects moved for partial summary judgment on the issue of the breach of express and implied warranties, and the motion was granted by the trial court.15 The city appeals from the judgment entered on that order.16
Whether the architects’ letter amended the parties’ original agreement by inserting a new term expressly warranting that the basement of the new structure would be watertight?17
No. The original agreement between the city of Mounds View and the architects provided that it may be amended only by written instrument signed by both parties.20 The letter from the city administrator expressing concern over dampness was never introduced into evidence, so its contents cannot be examined to determine whether it solicited an express warranty.21 The architects' March 20, 1975 response therefore cannot be fused with the unseen letter to qualify as a signed amendment under the contract terms.22
The architects’ letter did not amend the parties’ original agreement by inserting a new term expressly warranting that the basement of the new structure would be watertight.23
Whether the interpretation of the architects’ letter was a proper matter for resolution on a motion for summary judgment?24
When the amendment requirement of the original agreement disposes of an express warranty claim, a court need not interpret the language of the architects' letter itself before granting summary judgment on that claim.25
Yes. Because the agreement required amendment by a written instrument signed by both parties and the city's letter is absent from the record, the express warranty claim fails regardless of how the architects' letter is construed.26 The trial court therefore correctly granted partial summary judgment on the express warranty issue without needing to resolve any factual dispute over the letter's meaning.27
The interpretation of the architects’ letter was a proper matter for resolution on a motion for summary judgment.28
Whether an architect’s agreement to design a structure includes an implied warranty that the finished product will be fit for the purpose for which it was designed?29
An architect rendering professional services is held only to the duty to exercise the care, skill, and diligence that professionals in that field ordinarily exercise under like circumstances; the law does not impose an implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose or strict liability for defects in the completed structure.30
No. Architects deal in inexact sciences and must exercise skilled judgment to account for random factors that cannot be precisely measured in advance.31 The city alleged that the failure of the design to produce a watertight basement breached an implied warranty of fitness, yet the prevailing rule limits architect liability to negligence.32 Adoption of an implied warranty would impose strict liability for latent defects even when the architect applied state-of-the-art techniques, a result the court declines to reach for professional services.33
An architect’s agreement to design a structure does not include an implied warranty that the finished product will be fit for the purpose for which it was designed.34