568 U.S. 165 (2013)
Jeffrey Lee Chafin, a United States citizen and sergeant first class in the U.S. Army, married Lynne Hales Chafin, a United Kingdom citizen, in Germany in 2006 while stationed there, and their daughter E. C. was born the following year; later in 2007 Mr. Chafin deployed to Afghanistan, after which Ms. Chafin took E. C. to Scotland before Mr. Chafin was transferred to Huntsville, Alabama.1
In February 2010, Ms. Chafin traveled to Alabama with E. C., prompting Mr. Chafin to file for divorce and child custody in Alabama state court; toward the end of 2010, Ms. Chafin was arrested for domestic violence, an incident that alerted immigration authorities she had overstayed her visa, leading to her deportation in February 2011, after which E. C. remained in Mr. Chafin’s care for several more months.2
In May 2011, Ms. Chafin filed a petition in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Alabama under the Hague Convention and the International Child Abduction Remedies Act seeking an order returning E. C. to Scotland; on October 11 and 12, 2011, the district court held a bench trial and, at the close of arguments, ruled that Scotland was E. C.’s country of habitual residence and granted the return petition, after which Mr. Chafin immediately moved for a stay pending appeal, which the court denied, allowing Ms. Chafin to leave the country with E. C. headed for Scotland within hours.3
By December 2011, Ms. Chafin had initiated custody proceedings in Scotland, where the court granted her interim custody and a preliminary injunction prohibiting Mr. Chafin from removing E. C. from Scotland, while Mr. Chafin appealed the district court order to the Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit; in February 2012, the Eleventh Circuit dismissed the appeal as moot in a one-paragraph order citing its prior decision in Bekier v. Bekier and remanded with instructions to dismiss the suit as moot and vacate the district court order.45
On remand, the district court dismissed the case and ordered Mr. Chafin to pay Ms. Chafin over $94,000 in court costs, attorney’s fees, and travel expenses; the Alabama state court dismissed Mr. Chafin’s custody proceeding for lack of jurisdiction, and the Supreme Court granted certiorari to review the judgment of the Eleventh Circuit.67
Whether, after a child is returned pursuant to a district court order under the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, any appeal of that order is moot?8
Article III of the Constitution restricts federal courts to cases and controversies.9 A suit becomes moot when the issues presented are no longer live or the parties lack a legally cognizable interest in the outcome.10 This occurs only when it is impossible for a court to grant any effectual relief whatever to the prevailing party.11 As long as the parties have a concrete interest, however small, in the outcome of the litigation, the case is not moot.12
No. The parties continue to contest E. C.’s country of habitual residence, with Mr. Chafin seeking reversal of the district court’s Scotland ruling and a re-return order while Ms. Chafin pursues custody in Scotland.13 Mr. Chafin also seeks vacatur of the district court’s order requiring him to pay over $94,000 in costs, fees, and expenses.14
U.S. courts retain personal jurisdiction over Ms. Chafin and may enforce commands with sanctions even if Scotland declines to assist, preserving a concrete interest in effectual relief.15
The appeal is not moot because the parties retain a concrete interest in the outcome and effectual relief remains possible.16
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Ginsburg concurred in the judgment that the case is not moot but stressed the Convention’s emphasis on prompt return and the risks of protracted litigation and rival custody proceedings.17 She noted that reversal could allow a re-return order and Alabama custody adjudication yet warned that shuttling the child across borders harms the child’s welfare, the very concern the Convention seeks to address.18 Ginsburg highlighted procedures in England and Wales requiring leave to appeal and targeted stays to balance expedition with fairness, and she urged rulemakers and legislators to adopt measures ensuring Convention cases reach finality without unnecessary delay.19