179 N.E. 383, 258 N.Y. 194 (1932)
On December 27, 1927, the Canadian Industrial Alcohol Co. contracted with the Dunbar Molasses Co. to purchase approximately 1,500,000 wine gallons of refined blackstrap molasses of the usual run from the National Sugar Refinery, Yonkers, New York, to test around 60% sugars, with shipments scheduled to begin after April 1, 1928 and continue through the warm weather.1
After April 1, 1928, the Dunbar Molasses Co. delivered 344,083 gallons of the molasses to the buyer.2 The National Sugar Refinery produced a total of 485,848 gallons while the contract remained in force, and the defendant allocated all of this output to the plaintiff's order.3
The Canadian Industrial Alcohol Co. commenced an action against the Dunbar Molasses Co. to recover damages for the seller's failure to deliver the remaining quantity of molasses.4 The defendant maintained that its performance obligation depended on the refinery's production levels, though the record reveals no prior arrangement between the defendant and the refinery and no disclosure to the buyer regarding any such limitation.5
The buyer kept the contract in effect until October 25, 1928, when it announced its intention to procure the molasses from the open market and hold the defendant responsible for any price differential.6 In June 1928 the defendant tendered 400,000 gallons from another refinery at a lower price, and in October 1928 it offered an alternative contract for 400,000 to 850,000 gallons, but the plaintiff declined both proposals.7 The trial court excluded post-April 10, 1928 correspondence between the parties and issued rulings concerning the calculation of damages.8
Whether the seller's duty to deliver under the contract was conditioned upon the National Sugar Refinery producing sufficient molasses to fulfill the buyer's order?9
A seller's duty to deliver under an executory contract is discharged only if the contract terms, interpreted against the setting of the transaction, reveal that continued production at a particular refinery was a tacit presupposition conditioning the obligation.10 Discharge may occur upon destruction of the refinery or crop failure.11 The seller bears the burden of showing it was not contributorily at fault by failing to secure its own supply contract or by failing to disclose the absence of such a contract to the buyer.12
No. The contract between the Canadian Industrial Alcohol Co. and the Dunbar Molasses Co. did not keep the defendant's duty within boundaries so narrow as to condition performance on the refinery's actual output.13 The defendant failed to relieve itself of the imputation of contributory fault because nothing shows it tried to get a contract from the refinery during the months between acceptance of the order and the start of shipments.14 Nothing shows the plaintiff was informed that performance would be contingent on obtaining one.15 Business could not be transacted with security or smoothness if a presumption that the contract would lapse whenever the refiner chose to diminish production were at the root of its engagements.16
The seller's duty to deliver was not conditioned upon the National Sugar Refinery producing sufficient molasses to fulfill the buyer's order.17
Whether the trial court erred in excluding correspondence exchanged between the parties after April 10, 1928?18
An evidentiary ruling excluding correspondence is not reversible error when the letters, if received, would not have affected the result on liability or damages.19
No. The correspondence that passed between the Canadian Industrial Alcohol Co. and the Dunbar Molasses Co. after April 10, 1928, when deliveries began, would not have affected the result because it could not alter the conclusion that the contract contained no implied condition limiting the defendant's duty to the refinery's output or change the analysis of the buyer's obligation to accept substitute tenders.20
The trial court did not err in excluding correspondence exchanged between the parties after April 10, 1928.21
Whether the buyer was obligated to accept the seller's tenders of substitute molasses or an alternative contract?22
A buyer keeping a contract alive after breach is not chargeable with a duty to accept a tender of substitute performance made by the delinquent seller for accommodation rather than as a matter of obligation.23 This is particularly true when the buyer has lost faith in the seller's readiness or ability to perform.24
No. The Canadian Industrial Alcohol Co. was not obligated to accept the June 1928 tender of 400,000 gallons from a different refinery at six and one-half cents per gallon or the October 1928 tender of an alternative contract for 400,000 to 850,000 gallons at seven and one-quarter cents per gallon.25 Both tenders were made in a spirit of accommodation solely and not as a matter of obligation, and the plaintiff was entitled to decline them after the defendant had already failed to perform the original contract.26
The buyer was not obligated to accept the seller's tenders of substitute molasses or an alternative contract.27