438 U.S. 478 (1978)
In 1970 the Department of Agriculture initiated an administrative proceeding against Arthur N. Economou and his company Arthur N. Economou and Co., Inc., which was then registered as a commodity futures commission merchant.1
On February 19, 1970, following an audit, the Department issued an administrative complaint alleging that Economou, while registered, had willfully failed to maintain the minimum financial requirements prescribed by the Department.2 After a second audit an amended complaint was issued on June 22, 1970.3 A hearing was held before the Chief Hearing Examiner, who filed a recommendation sustaining the administrative complaint.4 The Judicial Officer of the Department, to whom the Secretary had delegated his decisional authority in enforcement proceedings, affirmed the Chief Hearing Examiner's decision.5
On respondent's petition for review, the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit vacated the order of the Judicial Officer.6 It reasoned that the essential finding of willfulness had been made in a proceeding instituted without the customary warning letter, which the Judicial Officer conceded might well have resulted in prompt correction of the claimed insufficiencies.7
While the administrative complaint was pending before the Judicial Officer, Economou filed suit in federal district court.8 He initially sought to enjoin the progress of the administrative proceeding but was unsuccessful.9 On March 31, 1975, respondent filed a second amended complaint seeking damages.10 Named as defendants were the individuals who had served as Secretary and Assistant Secretary of Agriculture during the relevant events, the Judicial Officer and Chief Hearing Examiner, several officials in the Commodity Exchange Authority, the Agriculture Department attorney who had prosecuted the enforcement proceeding, and several of the auditors who had investigated respondent or were witnesses against respondent.11
The complaint stated that prior to the issuance of the administrative complaints respondent had been sharply critical of the staff and operations of the defendants.12 He carried on a vociferous campaign for the reform of the Commodity Exchange Authority to obtain more effective regulation of commodity trading. The complaint also stated that some time prior to the issuance of the February 19 complaint, respondent and his company had ceased to engage in activities regulated by the defendants.13 The complaint charged that each of the administrative complaints had been issued without the notice or warning required by law, that the defendants had furnished the complaints to interested persons and others without furnishing respondent's answers as well, and that following the issuance of the amended complaint, the defendants had issued a deceptive press release that falsely indicated to the public that respondent's financial resources had deteriorated.14
The complaint then presented 10 causes of action, some of which purported to state claims for damages under the United States Constitution.15 The defendants moved to dismiss the complaint on the ground that as to the individual defendants it is barred by the doctrine of official immunity.16 The defendants relied on an affidavit submitted earlier in the litigation by the attorney who had prosecuted the original administrative complaint against respondent. The District Court dismissed the second amended complaint as to the individual defendants.17 The Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reversed the District Court's judgment of dismissal with respect to the individual defendants.18 The Supreme Court granted certiorari.19
Whether all federal officials sued for damages are absolutely immune from liability even if they infringed constitutional rights in the course of enforcing statutes and even if the violation was knowing and deliberate?20
Federal executive officials are not entitled to absolute immunity from damages liability for constitutional violations merely because their acts fall within the outer perimeter of their authority.21 Instead, they receive only qualified immunity unless their particular functions demonstrate that absolute immunity is essential to the conduct of public business.22
No. The established facts show that the Secretary and Assistant Secretary of Agriculture, the Judicial Officer, the Chief Hearing Examiner, Commodity Exchange Authority officials, the prosecuting attorney, and the auditors initiated an administrative complaint and amended complaint against Economou alleging willful failure to maintain financial requirements.23 They furnished the complaints to interested persons without his answers and issued a deceptive press release after Economou had ceased regulated activities and while he was publicly criticizing the agency.24 These actions formed the basis of claims for denial of due process and infringement of First Amendment rights.25 The Court rejected absolute immunity for such executive conduct because the facts reveal no special functional need that would justify shielding knowing or deliberate constitutional violations from all liability.26
Federal officials do not enjoy absolute immunity from damages liability for constitutional violations.27
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by The Chief Justice, Justice Stewart, And Justice Stevens
Justice Rehnquist dissented from the denial of absolute immunity to high-ranking executive officials.28 He maintained that Spalding v. Vilas establishes absolute immunity for heads of Executive Departments when engaged in the discharge of duties imposed upon them by law, even when malice or unconstitutionality is alleged.29 The threat of suit would otherwise dampen the ardor of all but the most resolute in the unflinching discharge of their duties.30
He argued that the majority's distinction between constitutional and common-law claims is illogical because the fear that inhibits is that of a long lawsuit and money judgment, not the type of claim.31 The practical effect would be to expose Cabinet-level officers to burdensome litigation that impairs vigorous performance of statutory duties.32
Whether federal executive officials exercising discretion are entitled only to qualified immunity from damages liability for constitutional violations?33
Federal executive officials exercising discretion are entitled only to qualified immunity from damages liability for constitutional violations.34 Under this standard they are shielded unless they knew or reasonably should have known that their actions would violate clearly established constitutional rights or acted with malicious intent to cause such a deprivation.35
Yes. The established facts identify the named Agriculture Department officials as executive officers who exercised discretion when deciding to issue complaints and a press release in response to Economou's regulatory violations and public criticism.36 The Court applied the qualified-immunity standard from Scheuer and Wood to these facts.37 The officials would be protected if they acted in good faith and with reasonable grounds but could be held liable if they knowingly violated due process or First Amendment rights.38
This standard balances the need to vindicate constitutional interests against the risk of deterring legitimate enforcement actions.39
Federal executive officials exercising discretion receive only qualified immunity for constitutional violations.40
Whether persons performing adjudicatory functions within a federal agency are entitled to absolute immunity from damages liability for their judicial acts?41
Yes. The established facts show that the Chief Hearing Examiner conducted a hearing and recommended sustaining the complaint while the Judicial Officer, exercising delegated decisional authority, affirmed that recommendation.44 These officials operated under APA procedures that guarantee an impartial trier insulated from political influence, an exclusive record, and rotation of assignments.45 The Court held that these structural protections justify absolute immunity for such adjudicatory acts.46
Any claims of error must be directed to agency or judicial review rather than damages actions.47
Agency adjudicators receive absolute immunity for their judicial acts.48
Whether agency officials responsible for the decision to initiate or continue a proceeding subject to agency adjudication are entitled to absolute immunity?49
Agency officials responsible for the decision to initiate or continue a proceeding subject to agency adjudication are entitled to absolute immunity.50 Their discretionary choice closely resembles a prosecutor's decision to bring charges and adequate checks already exist within the administrative and judicial process.51
Yes. The established facts establish that the Secretary, Assistant Secretary, and Commodity Exchange Authority officials authorized the original and amended administrative complaints against Economou.52 The Court analogized this initiation decision to prosecutorial charging discretion and concluded that absolute immunity is necessary to prevent retaliatory suits from distorting enforcement priorities.53 The availability of full administrative hearings and judicial review of the resulting order supplies sufficient safeguards against abuse.54
Agency officials who decide to initiate administrative proceedings receive absolute immunity.55
Whether an agency attorney who arranges for the presentation of evidence on the record in the course of an adjudication is absolutely immune from suits based on the introduction of such evidence?56
An agency attorney who arranges for the presentation of evidence on the record in the course of an adjudication is absolutely immune from suits based on the introduction of such evidence.57 The function is functionally comparable to that of a criminal prosecutor presenting evidence to a trier of fact.58
Yes. The established facts identify the Department attorney who prosecuted the enforcement proceeding as the official responsible for presenting evidence and witnesses against Economou before the Chief Hearing Examiner.59 The Court held that this advocacy role warrants absolute immunity because cross-examination, rebuttal, and the impartial judgment of the hearing examiner provide adequate checks just as they do in criminal trials.60 Personal liability would risk deterring the presentation of relevant evidence.61
Agency attorneys presenting evidence in adjudications receive absolute immunity.62