11 East 60, 103 Eng. Rep. 926 (1809)
In 1809, Butterfield brought an action on the case against Forrester in the King's Bench for injuries he sustained when thrown from his horse after encountering an obstruction on the highway.1 The defendant had erected a pole across the road near his house while making repairs to the property, leaving an alternative passage available via another branch of the street.2
On an August evening, the plaintiff left a nearby public house at eight o'clock and rode along the road at a violent pace, at a time when there was still enough light to see the obstruction from one hundred yards away.3 A witness indicated that the plaintiff could have observed and avoided the pole if he had not been riding extremely hard.4 The plaintiff proceeded violently into the obstruction, fell with his horse, and was injured, though no evidence showed he was intoxicated.5
At trial before Bayley J. at Derby, the judge directed the jury to find for the defendant if the plaintiff had been riding without ordinary care, and the jury returned a verdict for the defendant.6 A motion for a new trial followed the verdict.7
Whether the plaintiff could recover damages for injuries caused by the defendant's obstruction in the highway despite not using ordinary care to avoid it?8
A party is not to cast himself upon an obstruction which has been made by the fault of another.9 He may not avail himself of it if he does not himself use common and ordinary caution to be in the right.10 In particular, the fact that one person is in fault does not authorise another to abandon ordinary care for his own safety.11 Two things must concur to support this action: an obstruction in the road by the fault of the defendant, and a lack of ordinary care to avoid it on the part of the plaintiff.12
No. Although the defendant placed an obstruction in the highway, the plaintiff failed to exercise ordinary care.13 The plaintiff left the public house at eight o'clock in the evening in August and rode violently along the road when there was still light enough to discern the obstruction at a distance of one hundred yards. A witness confirmed that the plaintiff could have observed and avoided the pole if he had not been riding extremely hard. Because the plaintiff did not use common and ordinary caution, the required elements did not concur.14
The plaintiff cannot recover damages because he did not use ordinary care to avoid the obstruction.15