258 N.Y.S. 229 (App. Div. 1932)
In 1910 plaintiff purchased two vacant lots at the corner of Abby and Baraga streets in the city of Buffalo, and two years later built a house thereon. The front of the building was converted into a grocery store, and plaintiff occupied the rear as a dwelling. She rented the two apartments on the second floor.1
Defendant operates a large coke oven on the opposite side of Abby street. The plant runs twenty-four hours in the day, and three hundred and sixty-five days in the year. The coke is heated to a temperature of around 2,000 degrees F., and is taken out of the ovens and run under a “quencher,” where 500 or 600 gallons of water are poured onto it at one time. This results in a tremendous cloud of steam, which rises in a shaft and escapes into the air, carrying with it minute portions of coke, and more or less gas, along with dust from a huge coal pile and gases and odors.2
According to the plaintiff this results in an unusual amount of dirt and soot accumulating in her house, and prevents her opening the windows on the street side. She also claims that she suffers severe headaches by breathing the impure air occasioned by this dust and these offensive odors, and that her health and that of her family has been impaired, all to her very great discomfort and annoyance. She also asserts that this condition has lessened the rental value of her property, and has made it impossible at times to rent her apartments.3
The plant was built under a contract with the Federal government. The plans were drawn by the Koppers Construction Company, one of the largest and best known manufacturers of coke plants in the world, and the work was done under the supervision of the War Department. The plant is modern and up to date in every particular. No reasonable change or improvement in the property can be made which will eliminate any of the things complained of.4
When plaintiff bought her lots and built her house the land on which these coke ovens now stand was a hickory grove.5 The land is low and lies adjacent to the Buffalo river, a navigable stream connecting with Lake Erie.6 Seven different railroads run through this area.7 In 1910 there were at least eight industrial plants, with a total assessed valuation of over a million dollars, within a radius of a mile from plaintiff’s house.8 To-day there are twenty industrial plants within a radius of less than a mile and three-quarters from appellant’s house, with more than sixty-five smokestacks rising in the air. Every day there are 148 passenger trains, and 225 freight trains passing over these railroad tracks near to the plaintiff’s property. Over 10,000 boats, a large portion of which burn soft coal, pass up and down the Buffalo river every season. Across the street, and within 300 feet from plaintiff’s house, is a large tank of the Iroquois Gas Company. In 1925 the city passed a zoning ordinance putting this area in the third industrial district, a zone in which coke ovens were permitted to be located.9
Claiming that such use of its plant by the defendant deprives her of the full enjoyment of her home, invades her property rights, and constitutes a private nuisance, plaintiff brings this action in equity to enjoin the defendant from the further maintenance of said nuisance, and to recover the damages which she asserts she has already sustained.10 The Special Term rendered a decision which the Appellate Division affirmed.11
Whether the use to which the defendant has recently put its property constitutes a private nuisance, which a court of equity should abate?12
An owner is at liberty to use his property as he sees fit without objection from his neighbor unless the use violates an ordinance or statute.13 An owner will not be permitted to make an unreasonable use of his premises to the material annoyance of his neighbor if the latter’s enjoyment of life or property is materially lessened thereby.14 The maxim sic utere tuo ut alienum non laedas restrains each owner from exercising rights so as to injure the legal rights of another.15 Whether a particular use constitutes a nuisance is generally a question of fact that turns on whether the use is reasonable under all surrounding circumstances, including the character of the neighborhood.16 The inconvenience must be substantial rather than fanciful or theoretical and must interfere with the physical comfort of the ordinarily reasonable person.17 Residents of industrial centers must endure without redress the annoyance and discomfiture which is incident to life in such a locality.18 A court of equity will not enjoin a business conducted in an approved and expert manner at a location where the local zoning ordinance expressly permits it.19
No. The established facts demonstrate that the defendant's coke plant operates in a manner that is reasonable under all surrounding circumstances.20 The area was already an industrial zone when the plaintiff purchased her lots in 1910 and built her house, with eight industrial plants and seven railroads already present. The city later confirmed this character by zoning the district to permit coke ovens.21 The plant was built to modern federal specifications under War Department supervision, and no feasible alteration can remove the steam, dust, and odors that necessarily accompany coke production.22
The plaintiff selected the location with full awareness of these industrial conditions and the likelihood they would worsen.23 Any resulting annoyance therefore falls within the category of inconvenience that residents of industrial centers must accept rather than a substantial interference with the physical comfort of the ordinarily reasonable person that would justify equitable relief.24
The use to which the defendant has put its property does not constitute a private nuisance that a court of equity should abate.25