385 U.S. 116 (1966)
Julian Bond, a Negro, was elected on June 16, 1965, as the Representative to the Georgia House of Representatives from the 136th House District. Of the District’s 6,500 voters, approximately 6,000 are Negroes. Bond defeated his opponent, Malcolm Dean, Dean of Men at Atlanta University, also a Negro, by a vote of 2,320 to 487.1
On January 6, 1966, the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee, a civil rights organization of which Bond was then the Communications Director, issued a statement on American policy in Vietnam and its relation to the work of civil rights organizations in this country.2 The statement expressed opposition to United States involvement in Viet Nam, criticized the government for deception regarding freedom, noted violence against civil rights workers, questioned the ability of the United States government to guarantee free elections abroad, expressed sympathy with and support for men unwilling to respond to a military draft, and urged Americans to seek alternatives to the draft such as work in the civil rights movement.3 On the same day Bond was interviewed by telephone by a reporter from a local radio station and endorsed the statement, describing himself as a pacifist who opposes that war and any other war, agreeing that it is hypocritical to fight for liberty abroad while not guaranteeing it at home, stating he did not believe he had a requirement to support the war as a second class citizen, and expressing opposition to the draft while noting he did not advocate breaking laws.4
Before January 10, 1966, when the Georgia House of Representatives was scheduled to convene, petitions challenging Bond’s right to be seated were filed by 75 House members.5 These petitions charged that Bond’s statements gave aid and comfort to the enemies of the United States and Georgia, violated the Selective Service laws, and tended to bring discredit and disrespect on the House, and that his endorsement was inconsistent with the mandatory oath.6 When Bond appeared at the House on January 10 to be sworn in, the clerk refused to administer the oath to him until the issues raised in the challenge petitions had been decided.7 Bond filed a response stating his willingness to take the oath and arguing that the challenge had been filed to deprive him of his First Amendment rights and was racially motivated.8 A special committee was appointed and a hearing was held.9
At the hearing the only testimony given against Bond was that which he himself gave the committee. Both opponents Bond had defeated testified to his good character and loyalty to the United States.10 A recording of the interview was played and Bond was cross-examined; he admitted his statements, concurred in the SNCC statement without reservation, and clarified that he admired the courage of persons who burn their draft cards but had never suggested or counseled anyone to do so and did not advocate breaking laws.11 Tapes of a later press interview were also heard in which Bond stated he had not counselled burning draft cards, had suggested congressionally outlined alternatives to military service, and intended to take the oath.12 The special committee report gave general approval to the charges that Bond would not support the Constitutions, adhered to enemies of the State, gave aid and comfort to enemies of the United States, violated the Universal Military Training and Service Act, and made statements that tended to bring discredit to the House.13 On the same day the House adopted the committee report and resolved by a vote of 184 to 12 that Bond shall not be allowed to take the oath or be seated.14
While the appeal was pending, the Governor called a special election to fill the vacancy.15 Bond entered and won overwhelmingly, but after a hearing in which he declined to recant he was again prevented from taking the oath.16 Bond again sought the seat in the regular 1966 election, won the Democratic primary in September 1966, and won an overwhelming majority in the election of November 8, 1966.17
Whether the Georgia House of Representatives may constitutionally exclude a duly elected representative from membership because of his statements, and statements to which he subscribed, criticizing the policy of the Federal Government in Vietnam and the operation of the Selective Service laws?18
The First Amendment, as applied to the States through the Fourteenth Amendment, protects a legislator's expressions in opposition to national foreign policy and the Selective Service system, and a state legislature may not exclude a duly elected member for such statements when they would be protected if made by a private citizen and do not incite violation of law.19
No.
Julian Bond was elected on June 16, 1965, as the Representative to the Georgia House of Representatives from the 136th House District, defeating his opponent by a vote of 2,320 to 487 in a district where approximately 6,000 of the 6,500 voters were Negroes.20 On January 6, 1966, the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee, of which Bond was the Communications Director, issued a statement opposing United States involvement in Vietnam, criticizing the government for deception regarding freedom both abroad and at home, and expressing sympathy with and support for men unwilling to respond to a military draft while urging alternatives such as work in the civil rights movement.21 On the same day, Bond endorsed the statement in a telephone interview with a local radio reporter, describing himself as a pacifist who opposes the war and any war, agreeing that it is hypocritical to fight for liberty abroad while not guaranteeing it at home, and stating his opposition to the draft without advocating that people break laws.22
Subsequently, before the House convened on January 10, 1966, 75 House members filed petitions challenging Bond's right to be seated on grounds that his statements gave aid and comfort to enemies, violated Selective Service laws, and were inconsistent with the oath of office.23 When Bond appeared to be sworn in, the clerk refused to administer the oath until the challenges were resolved.24 Bond responded by affirming his willingness to take the oath and arguing that the challenge was racially motivated and aimed at depriving him of First Amendment rights.25 A special committee held a hearing where Bond clarified his statements, admitting endorsement of the SNCC statement without reservation but emphasizing that he had never counseled or advocated burning draft cards or breaking laws, and that he admired only the courage of those acting on convictions.26
After the hearing, the special committee approved the charges against Bond, and the House adopted the report by a vote of 184 to 12, resolving that Bond shall not be allowed to take the oath or be seated as a member.27 Bond then filed suit in the District Court for the Northern District of Georgia seeking injunctive and declaratory relief on First Amendment grounds, leading to a three-judge court decision that was appealed to the Supreme Court.28 While the appeal was pending, Bond won a special election and the regular 1966 election but was again prevented from taking the oath after declining to recant his statements.29
Applying the rule to these facts, Bond's statements and endorsements, including his clarifications at the hearing that he does not advocate breaking laws and supports alternatives to the draft, fall within the protection of the First Amendment as they do not counsel violation of the Selective Service laws under 50 U.S.C. App. § 462(a), and the Georgia House's exclusion based on those statements therefore violates his constitutional rights.30
The Georgia House of Representatives may not constitutionally exclude Julian Bond from membership based on his statements criticizing federal policy in Vietnam and the Selective Service laws.31